Advanced Statistical Modeling of the Frequency and Severity of Traffic Crashes on Rural Highways


Book Description

The primary objective of practitioners working on traffic safety is to reduce the number and severity of crashes. The Highway Safety Manual (HSM) provides practitioners with analytical tools and techniques to estimate the expected crash frequency and severity with the aim to identify and evaluate safety countermeasures. Expected crash frequency can be estimated using Safety Performance Functions (SPFs) provided in Part C of the HSM. The HSM provides simple SPFs which are developed using the most frequently used crash counts model, the negative binomial regression model. The rural nature of Wyoming highways coupled with the mountainous terrain (i.e., challenging roadway geometry) make the HSM basic SPFs unsuitable to determine crash contributing factors for Wyoming conditions. In this regard, the objective of this study is to implement advanced statistical methods such as the different functional forms of Negative Binomial, and Bayesian approach, to develop crash prediction models, investigate crash contributing factors, and determine the impact of safety countermeasures. Bayesian statistics in combination with the power of Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) sampling techniques provide frameworks to model small sample datasets and complex models at the same time, where the traditional Maximum Likelihood Estimation (MLE) based methods tend to fail. As such, a novel No-U-Turn Sampler for Hamiltonian Monte Carlo (NUTS HMC) sampling technique in a Bayesian framework was utilized to investigate the crash frequency, injury severity of crashes on the interstate freeways and some rural highways in Wyoming. The Poisson and the Negative Binomial (NB) models are the most commonly used regression models in traffic safety analysis. The advantage of the NB model can be further enhanced by providing different functional forms of the variance and the dispersion structure. The NB-2 is the most common form of the NB model, typically used in developing safety performance functions (SPFs) largely due to the mean-variance quadratic relationship. However, studies in the literature have shown that the mean-variance relationship could be unrestrained. Another introduced formulation of the NB model is NB-1, which assumes that there is a constant ratio linking the mean and the variance of the crash frequencies. A more general type of the NB model is the NB-P model, which does not constrain the mean-variance relationship. Thus, leveraging the power of this unrestrained mean-variance relationship, more accurate safety models could be developed, and these would lead to more accurate estimation of crash risk and benefits of potential solutions. This study will help practitioners to implement advanced methodologies to solve traffic safety problems of rural highways that have plagued the researchers for a long time now. The methodologies proposed in this study will help practitioners to replace the outdated and inefficient traditional models and obtain more accurate traffic safety models to predict crashes and the resulting crash injury severity. Moreover, this research quantified the safety effectiveness of some unique countermeasures on rural highways.




Highway and Traffic Safety


Book Description

Transportation Research Record contains the following papers: Method for identifying factors contributing to driver-injury severity in traffic crashes (Chen, WH and Jovanis, PP); Crash- and injury-outcome multipliers (Kim, K); Guidelines for identification of hazardous highway curves (Persaud, B, Retting, RA and Lyon, C); Tools to identify safety issues for a corridor safety-improvement program (Breyer, JP); Prediction of risk of wet-pavement accidents : fuzzy logic model (Xiao, J, Kulakowski, BT and El-Gindy, M); Analysis of accident-reduction factors on California state highways (Hanley, KE, Gibby, AR and Ferrara, T); Injury effects of rollovers and events sequence in single-vehicle crashes (Krull, KA, Khattack, AJ and Council, FM); Analytical modeling of driver-guidance schemes with flow variability considerations (Kaysi, I and Ail, NH); Evaluating the effectiveness of Norway's speak out! road safety campaign : The logic of causal inference in road safety evaluation studies (Elvik, R); Effect of speed, flow, and geometric characteristics on crash frequency for two-lane highways (Garber, NJ and Ehrhart, AA); Development of a relational accident database management system for Mexican federal roads (Mendoza, A, Uribe, A, Gil, GZ and Mayoral, E); Estimating traffic accident rates while accounting for traffic-volume estimation error : a Gibbs sampling approach (Davis, GA); Accident prediction models with and without trend : application of the generalized estimating equations procedure (Lord, D and Persaud, BN); Examination of methods that adjust observed traffic volumes on a network (Kikuchi, S, Miljkovic, D and van Zuylen, HJ); Day-to-day travel-time trends and travel-time prediction form loop-detector data (Kwon, JK, Coifman, B and Bickel, P); Heuristic vehicle classification using inductive signatures on freeways (Sun, C and Ritchie, SG).




Statistical Methods and Modeling and Safety Data, Analysis, and Evaluation


Book Description

Covers empirical approaches to outlier detection in intelligent transportation systems data, modeling of traffic crash-flow relationships for intersections, profiling of high-frequency accident locations by use of association rules, analysis of rollovers and injuries with sport utility vehicles, and automated accident detection at intersections via digital audio signal processing.




Highway Safety


Book Description

Transportation Research Record contains the following papers: Incorporating crash risk in selecting congestion-mitigation strategies : Hampton Roads area (Virginia) case study (Garber, NJ and Subramanyan, S); Development of artificial neural network models to predict driver injury severity in traffic accidents at signalized intersections (Abdelwahab, HT and Abdel-Aty, MA); Transferability of models that estimate crashes as a function of access management (Miller, JS, Hoel, LA, Kim, S and Drummond, KP); Sensor-friendly vehicle and roadway cooperative safety systems : benefits estimation (Misener, JA, Thorpe, C, Ferlis, R, Hearne, R, Siegal, M and Perkowski, J); Interstate highway crash injuries during winter snow and nonsnow events (Khattak, AJ and Knapp, KK); Simulation of road crashes by use of systems dynamics (Mehmood, A, Saccamanno, F and Hellinga, B); Longitudinal analysis of fatal run-off-road crashes, 1975 to 1997 (McGinnis, RG, Davis, MJ and Hathaway, EA); Injury severity in multivehicle rear-end crashes (Khattack, AJ); Computing and interpreting accident rates for vehicle types driver groups (Hauer, E); Geographics information system-based accident data management for Mexican federal roads (Mendoza, A, Mayoral, EF, Vicente, JL and Quintero, FL); Bayesian identification of high-risk intersections for older drivers via gibbs sampling (Davis, GA and Yang, S); Automated accident detection system (Harlow, C and Wang, Y); Evaluation of inexpensive global positioning system units to improve crash location data (Graettinger, AJ, Rushing, TW and McFadden, J).




A Novel Approach to Modeling and Predicting Crash Frequency at Rural Intersections by Crash Type and Injury Severity Level


Book Description

Safety at intersections is of significant interest to transportation professionals due to the large number of possible conflicts that occur at those locations. In particular, rural intersections have been recognized as one of the most hazardous locations on roads. However, most models of crash frequency at rural intersections, and road segments in general, do not differentiate between crash type (such as angle, rear-end or sideswipe) and injury severity (such as fatal injury, non-fatal injury, possible injury or property damage only). Thus, there is a need to be able to identify the differential impacts of intersection-specific and other variables on crash types and severity levels. This thesis builds upon the work of Bhat et al., (2013b) to formulate and apply a novel approach for the joint modeling of crash frequency and combinations of crash type and injury severity. The proposed framework explicitly links a count data model (to model crash frequency) with a discrete choice model (to model combinations of crash type and injury severity), and uses a multinomial probit kernel for the discrete choice model and introduces unobserved heterogeneity in both the crash frequency model and the discrete choice model, while also accommodates excess of zeros. The results show that the type of traffic control and the number of entering roads are the most important determinants of crash counts and crash type/injury severity, and the results from our analysis underscore the value of our proposed model for data fit purposes as well as to accurately estimate variable effects.







Relationship Between Speed Metrics and Crash Frequency and Severity


Book Description

Reducing the number and severity of crashes on highways and streets is of high importance for government officials and transportation professionals in the United States. Substantial research has focused on various speed metrics, such as operating speeds and the posted speed limit, and their relationship to safety, such as crash frequency and crash severity. Crash severity is the safety measure most often linked to measures of speed and is based on dissipation of kinetic energy. However, many aspects of the relationships between speed metrics and crash frequency and risk have yet to be studied in depth, so a complete understanding of speeding-related crashes is unknown. Design speeds are used to establish geometric design criteria, and operating speed results from the geometric design process. Posted speed limits may be established based on operating speeds or by statute. When posted speed limits are inconsistent with design or operating speeds, road safety performance may be affected. A more complete understanding of the relationship between safety performance and operating speeds, posted speed limits, and design speeds may produce rational speed limits and lead to improved safety performance on roadways.This research combined real-time vehicle probe speed data, roadway inventory data, and crash data to assess crash risk and crash frequency.This thesis first determined the risk of a crash on two-lane rural highways based on operating speed metrics, differences between speed metrics, and traffic volume data. Results from the crash risk analysis indicate that operating speeds in 1-minute and 5-minute averages improve the statistical fit and prediction of binary logistic regression models. Higher traffic volumes and operating speeds higher than either the road average speed or road reference speed were associated with increased crash risk. Whereas, variations in travel speeds between vehicles were associated with decreased crash risk. This thesis also analyzed the frequency of crashes on horizontal curve segments of two-lane rural roadways using operating speed data, differences among speed metrics, traffic volume data, roadway inventory data, and crash data. Negative binomial regression models improve the statistical fit and prediction of crash frequency models compared to random-effects negative binomial regression. Generally, increases in the differences between operating speed and road average speed and the differences between operating speed and inferred design were associated with an increase in crash frequency. Increases in the differences between inferred design speed and posted speed limit were also associated with an expected increase in crash frequency; however, increases in the operating speed variance and in the difference between operating speeds and posted speed limit were associated with an expected decrease in crash frequency.




Modeling Multilevel Data in Traffic Safety


Book Description

Background: In the study of traffic system safety, statistical models have been broadly applied to establish the relationships between the traffic crash occurrence and various risk factors. Most of the existing methods, such as the generalised linear regression models, assume that each observation (e.g. a crash or a vehicle involvement) in the estimation procedure corresponds to an individual situation. Hence, the residuals from the models exhibit independence. Problem: However, this "independence" assumption may often not hold true since multilevel data structures exist extensively because of the data collection and clustering process. Disregarding the possible within-group correlations may lead to production of models with unreliable parameter estimates and statistical inferences. Method: Following a literature review of crash prediction models, this book proposes a 5 T-level hierarchy, viz. (Geographic region level -- Traffic site level -- Traffic crash level -- Driver-vehicle unit level -- Vehicle-occupant level) Time level, to establish a general form of multilevel data structure in traffic safety analysis. To model properly the potential between-group heterogeneity due to the multilevel data structure, a framework of hierarchical models that explicitly specify multilevel structure and correctly yield parameter estimates is employed. Bayesian inference using Markov chain Monte Carlo algorithm is developed to calibrate the proposed hierarchical models. Two Bayesian measures, viz. the Deviance Information Criterion and Cross-Validation Predictive Densities, are adapted to establish the model suitability. Illustrations: The proposed method is illustrated using two case studies in Singapore: 1) a crash-frequency prediction model which takes into account Traffic site level and Time level; 2) a crash-severity prediction model which takes into account Traffic crash level and Driver-vehicle unit level. Conclusion: Comparing the predictive abilities of the proposed models against those of traditional methods, the study demonstrates the importance of accounting for the within-group correlations and illustrates the flexibilities and effectiveness of the Bayesian hierarchical approach in modelling multilevel structure of traffic safety data.







Highway Safety Analytics and Modeling


Book Description

Highway Safety Analytics and Modeling comprehensively covers the key elements needed to make effective transportation engineering and policy decisions based on highway safety data analysis in a single. reference. The book includes all aspects of the decision-making process, from collecting and assembling data to developing models and evaluating analysis results. It discusses the challenges of working with crash and naturalistic data, identifies problems and proposes well-researched methods to solve them. Finally, the book examines the nuances associated with safety data analysis and shows how to best use the information to develop countermeasures, policies, and programs to reduce the frequency and severity of traffic crashes. Complements the Highway Safety Manual by the American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials Provides examples and case studies for most models and methods Includes learning aids such as online data, examples and solutions to problems