An Empirical Comparison of the Short Term Interest Rate Models


Book Description

This article attempts to identify the best model of the short term interest rates that can predict its stochastic process over time.We studied eight different models of interest rates in the short term. The choice of these models was the aim of analyzing the relevance of certain specifications of the stochastic process of the short term interest rates, the effect of mean reversion and the sensitivity of the volatility to the level of interest rate.The yield on three months treasury bills is used as a proxy for the short term interest rates. The parameters of the different stochastic process are estimated using the generalized method of moments. The results show that the effect of mean reversion is not statistically significant and that volatility is highly sensitive to the level of interest rates.To further study the performance prediction of the intertemporal behavior of the short term interest rate of the various models; we simulated their stochastic process for different periods.The results show that none of the studied models reproduce the actual path of the short term interest rates. The problem lies in the parametric specification of the mean and volatility of the diffusion process.










Comparison of Alternative Models of the Short-term Interest Rate


Book Description

The paper proposes a procedure for testing the alternative continuous time models of short term riskless interest rates. Parameters estimation and models comparison are presented using the Generalized Method of Moments. An empirical research to LIBOR in US dollar is given and found that the volatility of interest rate changes is to be less sensitive to the interest rate levels in contrast to previous findings. In addition the Brennan-Schwartz model is suggested to be superior to the others in term of data fit under daily observations, and CIR SR model cannot be rejected.




An Empirical Comparison of Continuous Time Models of the Short Term Interest Rate


Book Description

This paper compares the empirical performance of a wide variety of well-known diffusion models - with particular emphasis on the Black, Derman, and Toy (1990) term structure model - in capturing the dynamic behavior of interest rate volatility. Many popular models are nested within a more flexible time-varying BDT framework that allows us to determine the appropriate specification of the spot rate process. The empirical results for the one-month Treasury yields indicate that the equilibrium models that do not allow the drift and diffusion parameters to vary over time and parameterize the volatility only as a function of interest rate levels fail to model adequately the serial correlation in conditional variances. On the other hand, the serial-correlation-based arbitrage-free models with time-dependent parameters in the drift and diffusion functions may fail to capture adequately the relationship between interest rate levels and volatility. The results also suggest that time-varying volatilities within the BDT framework may lead to non-recombining binomial trees that increase the storage requirements and computational cost substantially in pricing interest rate contingent claims.




Comparison of Alternative Models of the Short-term Interest Rate


Book Description

The paper proposes a procedure for testing the alternative continuous time models of short term riskless interest rates. Parameters estimation and models comparison are presented using the Generalized Method of Moments. An empirical research to LIBOR in US dollar is given and found that the volatility of interest rate changes is to be less sensitive to the interest rate levels in contrast to previous findings. In addition the Brennan-Schwartz model is suggested to be superior to the others in term of data fit under daily observations, and CIR SR model cannot be rejected.




Estimating Parameters of Short-Term Real Interest Rate Models


Book Description

This paper sheds light on a narrow but crucial question in finance: What should be the parameters of a model of the short-term real interest rate? Although models for the nominal interest rate are well studied and estimated, dynamics of the real interest rate are rarely explored. Simple ad hoc processes for the short-term real interest rate are usually assumed as building blocks for more sophisticated models. In this paper, parameters of the real interest rate model are estimated in the broad class of single-factor interest rate diffusion processes on U.S. monthly data. It is shown that the elasticity of interest rate volatility—the relationship between the volatility of changes in the interest rate and its level—plays a crucial role in explaining real interest rate dynamics. The empirical estimates of the elasticity of the real interest rate volatility are found to be about 0.5, much lower than that of the nominal interest rate. These estimates show that the square root process, as in the Cox-Ingersoll-Ross model, provides a good characterization of the short-term real interest rate process.




An Empirical Comparison of Single-Factor Consistent Models


Book Description

Yield-curve models are broadly used by the industry for valuating fixed-income securities. These models reply term-structure of interest rates observed in the market accurately. In this work we make an empirical comparison among the main one-factor models used as management portfolio tools: the Hull-White model, the squared Gaussian model and a restricted version of Black-Karasinski model.




Modeling the Term Structure of Interest Rates


Book Description

Modeling the Term Structure of Interest Rates provides a comprehensive review of the continuous-time modeling techniques of the term structure applicable to value and hedge default-free bonds and other interest rate derivatives.




An Empirical Comparison of Alternative Models for Valuing Interest Rate Options


Book Description

This article presents the first comprehensive comparative study of alternative models for valuing interest rate options. One and two factor inversion models of the Hull/White type and one and two factor Heath/J arrow/Morton models are considered. The valuation models are assessed by different criteria which are of considerable importance for the practical use of the models. To assess empirical performance, the models are tested on an identical set of bond warrant data. Not only the empirical quality, however, but also the practical problems in implementing the different approaches contribute to the differentiation of the models.