An Investigation of Innovative Technologies for Reduction of Jet Noise in Medium and High Bypass Turbofan Engines


Book Description

This research project has developed a new, large-scale, nozzle acoustic test rig capable of simulating the exhaust flows of separate flow exhaust systems in medium and high bypass turbofan engines. This rig has subsequently been used to advance the understanding of two state-of-the-art jet noise reduction technologies. The first technology investigated is an emerging jet noise reduction technology known as chevron nozzles. The fundamental goal of this investigation was to advance the understanding of the fundamental physical mechanisms responsible for the acoustic benefits provided by these nozzles. Additionally, this study sought to establish the relationship between these physical mechanisms and the chevron geometric parameters. A comprehensive set of data was collected, including far-field and near-field acoustic data as well as flow field measurements. In addition to illustrating the ability of the chevron nozzles to provide acoustic benefits in important aircraft certification metrics such as effective perceived noise level (EPNL), this investigation successfully identified two of the fundamental physical mechanisms responsible for this reduction. The flow field measurements showed the chevron to redistribute energy between the core and fan streams to effectively reduce low frequency noise by reducing the length of the jet potential core. However, this redistribution of energy produced increases in turbulent kinetic energy of up to 45% leading to a degradation of the chevron benefit at higher frequencies ... plane to reduce jet noise. The principal advantage of such an approach is that it is an active technology that can be activated as needed and, as such, may be more acceptable in aircraft engines from a performance standpoint than passive technologies. This study successfully demonstrated the feasibility of this technology by showing that effective jet noise reduction can be provided in a broad range of flow conditions using less than 1% of the mean jet mass flow. An investigation of injection geometric parameters identified the injection pitch angle as the most influential parameter with respect to jet noise reduction. Furthermore, an investigation of scaling effects showed a momentum ratio of approximately 1.5% to provide reductions in sound pressure level between 1 and 2 dB across a wide range of frequencies for a wide range of flow conditions and scales including both single stream and dual stream flows. PIV flow field measurements identified the fundamental physical mechanism of the noise reduction to be a near uniform reduction in shear layer turbulence.




Jet Noise Reduction with Micro Turbojet Engine Noise Investigations


Book Description

Jet noise remains a significant noise component in modern aero-engines. A high-speed flow mixing with the surrounding air constitutes noise sources behind the nozzle. This book consists of two parts. The first part is to provide an overview of the aircraft noise generating sources with emphasis on the jet noise, the main technologies employed for control and reduction of aircraft noise for subsonic and supersonic jets, and finally a survey of the current applications of large-eddy simulation (LES) for predicting of the noise from single stream turbulent jets, including numerical methods for simulation of near and far field of a jet nozzle. The second part of the book describes a test rig constructed for the study of jet noise from JetCat micro turbojet engine used for unmanned aerial vehicles (UAV) to investigate the near field noise generated by turbulent high subsonic single stream jet.




Noise Reduction Technologies for Turbofan Engines


Book Description

Significant progress continues to be made with noise reduction for turbofan engines. NASA has conducted and sponsored research aimed at reducing noise from commercial aircraft. Since it takes many years for technologies to be developed and implemented, it is important to have aggressive technology goals that lead the target entry into service dates. Engine noise is one of the major contributors to the overall sound levels as aircraft operate near airports. Turbofan engines are commonly used on commercial transports due to their advantage for higher performance and lower noise. The noise reduction comes from combinations of changes to the engine cycle parameters and low noise design features. In this paper, an overview of major accomplishments from recent NASA research programs for engine noise will be given. Huff, Dennis L. Glenn Research Center NASA/TM-2007-214495, E-15787




The Effect of Bypass Nozzle Exit Area on Fan Aerodynamic Performance and Noise in a Model Turbofan Simulator


Book Description

The design of effective new technologies to reduce aircraft propulsion noise is dependent on identifying and understanding the noise sources and noise generation mechanisms in the modern turbofan engine, as well as determining their contribution to the overall aircraft noise signature. Therefore, a comprehensive aeroacoustic wind tunnel test program was conducted called the Fan Broadband Source Diagnostic Test as part of the NASA Quiet Aircraft Technology program. The test was performed in the anechoic NASA Glenn 9- by 15-Foot Low Speed Wind Tunnel using a 1/5 scale model turbofan simulator which represented a current generation, medium pressure ratio, high bypass turbofan aircraft engine. The investigation focused on simulating in model scale only the bypass section of the turbofan engine. The test objectives were to: identify the noise sources within the model and determine their noise level; investigate several component design technologies by determining their impact on the aerodynamic and acoustic performance of the fan stage; and conduct detailed flow diagnostics within the fan flow field to characterize the physics of the noise generation mechanisms in a turbofan model. This report discusses results obtained for one aspect of the Source Diagnostic Test that investigated the effect of the bypass or fan nozzle exit area on the bypass stage aerodynamic performance, specifically the fan and outlet guide vanes or stators, as well as the farfield acoustic noise level. The aerodynamic performance, farfield acoustics, and Laser Doppler Velocimeter flow diagnostic results are presented for the fan and four different fixed-area bypass nozzle configurations. The nozzles simulated fixed engine operating lines and encompassed the fan stage operating envelope from near stall to cruise. One nozzle was selected as a baseline reference, representing the nozzle area which would achieve the design point operating conditions and fan stage performance. The total area change from the smallest to the largest nozzle was 12.9 percent of the baseline nozzle area. The results will show that there are significant changes in aerodynamic performance and farfield acoustics as the fan nozzle area is increased. The weight flow through the fan model increased between 7 and 9 percent, the fan and stage pressure dropped between 8 and 10 percent, and the adiabatic efficiency increased between 2 and 3 percent--the magnitude of the change dependent on the fan speed. Results from force balance measurements of fan and outlet guide vane thrust will show that as the nozzle exit area is increased the combined thrust of the fan and outlet guide vanes together also increases, between 2 and 3.5 percent, mainly due to the increase in lift from the outlet guide vanes. In terms of farfield acoustics, the overall sound power level produced by the fan stage dropped nearly linearly between 1 dB at takeoff condition and 3.5 dB at approach condition, mainly due to a decrease in the broadband n




Advanced Subsonic Technology (Ast) Separate-Flow High-Bypass Ratio Nozzle Noise Reduction Program Test Report


Book Description

NASA s model-scale nozzle noise tests show that it is possible to achieve a 3 EPNdB jet noise reduction with inwardfacing chevrons and flipper-tabs installed on the primary nozzle and fan nozzle chevrons. These chevrons and tabs are simple devices and are easy to be incorporated into existing short duct separate-flow nonmixed nozzle exhaust systems. However, these devices are expected to cause some small amount of thrust loss relative to the axisymmetric baseline nozzle system. Thus, it is important to have these devices further tested in a calibrated nozzle performance test facility to quantify the thrust performances of these devices. The choice of chevrons or tabs for jet noise suppression would most likely be based on the results of thrust loss performance tests to be conducted by Aero System Engineering (ASE) Inc. It is anticipated that the most promising concepts identified from this program will be validated in full scale engine tests at both Pratt & Whitney and Allied-Signal, under funding from NASA s Engine Validation of Noise Reduction Concepts (EVNRC) programs. This will bring the technology readiness level to the point where the jet noise suppression concepts could be incorporated with high confidence into either new or existing turbofan engines having short-duct, separate-flow nacelles. Low, John K. C. and Schweiger, Paul S. and Premo, John W. and Barber, Thomas J. and Saiyed, Naseem (Technical Monitor) Glenn Research Center NAS3-27727; WU 522-81-11...




Ultra High Bypass Ratio Low Noise Engine Study


Book Description

A study was conducted to identify engine cycle and technologies needed for a regional aircraft which could be capable of achieving a 10 EPNdB reduction in community noise level relative to current FAR36 Stage 3 limits. The study was directed toward 100-passenger regional aircraft with engine configurations in the 15,000 pound thrust class. The study focused on Ultra High Bypass Ratio (UHBR) cycles due to low exhaust jet velocities and reduced fan tip speeds. The baseline engine for this study employed a gear-driven, 1000 ft/sec tip speed fan and had a cruise bypass ratio of 14:1. A revised engine configuration employing fan and turbine design improvements are predicted to be 9.2 dB below current takeoff limits and 12.8 dB below current approach limits. An economic analysis was also done by estimating Direct Operating Cost (DOC). Dalton, W. N., III Glenn Research Center NAS3-25950; WBS 22-781-30-12




Simulation of Supersonic Jet Noise Reduction Using Fluid Inserts for Low Bypass Ratio Turbofans


Book Description

The design constraints on jet engines for high performance supersonic military aircraft require lower bypass ratios and supersonic exhaust velocities, which result in very high noise levels. This is a great concern to the US Navy as the noise generated from the jet exhaust of high performance supersonic military aircraft can affect the hearing and performance of personnel working in close proximity of the aircraft. There have been reports about the US Department of Veteran Affairs spending over hundreds of millions of dollars in disability payments for hearing loss compensation to former Navy personnel. In addition to this, jet noise is also a source of annoyance in communities in the vicinity of airbases and military training routes.Over the years, several noise reduction methods have been proposed with varying levels of success. The most effective noise reduction strategies include the installation of chevrons, and the use of corrugated seals, among many others. One primary disadvantage of these technologies is that they are passive technologies and cannot be switched off or modified after take-off and hence may reduce overall aircraft performance. An active, though steady, noise reduction technology is the use of fluid inserts in the divergent section of a converging-diverging nozzle. The fluid inserts consist of rows of injectors that inject a small amount of bypass air into the diverging section of the nozzle. It has been shown that by altering the configuration and operating conditions of the fluid inserts, noise reduction for both mixing and shock noise can be achieved. Since this blowing can be controlled, the fluid inserts can be switched off or modified after take-off to minimize any performance penalty to the aircraft.Although considerable experimental research has been performed to explore the effects of fluid inserts on the jet exhaust, the available data have been found to be insufficient to correlate the noise reduction with changes in the flow-field due to the noise reduction device. The present study is an extension to the previousresearch on fluid inserts that uses Large Eddy Simulation (LES) with the Ffowcs Williams-Hawkings (FWH) analogy for farfield noise prediction. The simulations are carried out using a commercially available CFD package, STAR-CCM+. The project aims to simulate and analyze the unsteady flow changes associated withthe noise reduction device to help understand the detailed mechanisms for the observed noise reductions.Different fluid insert configurations are used to analyze the effect of individual injector placement in a fluid insert on noise generation. It is observed that the changes in upstream noise correlate extremely well with the shock structure of the fluid insert jets downstream of the nozzle exit. Further insight into the noisereduction patterns is obtained by using two-point space time correlations and the use of the modal techniques such as Proper Orthogonal Decomposition on the near-field data on the FWH surface, which show that fluid inserts reduce the amplitude of the noise radiating coherent structures. Using Doaks Momentum Potential Theory, it is observed that the changes associated with fluid insertson the hydrodynamic and acoustic modes correlate well with the far-field noise reduction.




GE Core Engine Noise Investigation - Low Emmission Engines


Book Description

This program was directed towards elements of combustor and turbine noise; the latter including turbine tone interaction with jet stream turbulence. Combustor (Core) Noise - Investigations were conducted to determine the variables affecting source strength, spectrum shape, and farfield directivity. This investigation include scale model tests to evaluate the effects of exhaust nozzle geometry on radiation patterns of low frequency noise. A full-scale combustor rig test was used to identify the controlling variables of combustor noise at the source. Two engine tests were run to validate the findings from the scale model tests and add to the overall data base of core noise measurements. The relationship between combustor source noise and emissions was studied and qualitative trends identified for advanced low emissions combustors. Turbine Noise - Studies were made of the attenuation of high frequency turbine noise by downstream blade rows, the broadband noise generation by turbines, and the controlling parameters for turbine tone/jet stream interaction. This included a turbine rig test in single and multistage configurations, along with a unique data acquisition system. Scale model tests were used to define the effect of the pertinent aero-acoustic parameters on turbine tone scattering by jet stream turbulence. The results of these investigations were used to improve the component prediction techniques derived under the Core Engine Noise Control Program (FAA-RD-74-125, III). These improved prediction techniques were used to predict the noise contribution of each source for high bypass turbofan engines representative of current and advanced technology. (Author).




1980 NASA Authorization


Book Description