Essays on Monetary and Fiscal Policy Interactions in Small Open Economies


Book Description

This thesis addresses interactions between monetary and fiscal policies in a theoretical dynamic stochastic general equilibrium (DSGE) model of a small open economy and in an empirical model under a structural vector error correction model (SVECM). The thesis consists of three essays. The contribution is both theoretical and empirical that enables a better understanding of the complexity of interactions between monetary and fiscal policies in small open economies. The first essay examines the equilibrium determinacy under monetary and fiscal rules. The goal is to investigate how monetary and fiscal policy interactions ensure a unique and non-explosive (determinate) equilibrium for a small open economy. The study focuses when policy makers implement a set of policy mixes to address domestic output price inflation control for monetary policy, debt stabilization for fiscal policy, and joint output stabilization tasks. The result indicates that two policy schemes facilitate a determinate equilibrium. First, monetary policy actively controls inflation when fiscal policy sets a sufficient feedback on debt. Second, monetary policy becomes passive against inflation when fiscal policy is insolvent. Adding output stabilization to each rule simply causes variants of this fundamental. An interest rate rule with output stabilization can be more passive against inflation while providing a stronger response to the output gap. Fiscal policy is required to set higher feedback on debt along with its stronger counter-cyclical policy. The second essay links between the equilibrium determinacy and policy optimization. This essay provides insights into the design of policy mixes and compares determinacy outcomes between two theoretical models of a small open economy: with and without an explicit exchange rate role. This study shows that policy interactions in a small open economy with an endogenous exchange rate is quite sophisticated, especially when a monetary rule is added with an output stabilization task and/or targeted to Consumer Price Index (CPI) inflation. Additional concern for monetary policy in an open economy causes a partial offset to its reaction on domestic output price inflation that weakens its effect on the real debt burden. To minimize economic fluctuations, policy makers should mute the role of output stabilization for monetary policy, and set minimum feedback on debt that is compatible with the degree of counter-cyclical fiscal policy. Substantially active response to inflation is satisfactory for monetary policy with CPI inflation targeting. The third essay empirically presents monetary and fiscal policy interactions in Thailand's SVECM suggested by a theoretical DSGE model developed from the previous essays. This essay shows that the DSGE-SVECM model can be supported by Thai data. A shock to monetary policy is effective with a lag. Government spending policy is also effective with a lag and some crowding-out effects on output. An adverse shock in tax policy unexpectedly stimulates the economy, indicating room for enhancing economic growth by relaxing revenue constraint. Monetary policy is mainly implemented to correct a consequence of a fiscal shock on inflation (and also the domestic and foreign shocks), while fiscal policy appears to counter a consequence of the monetary policy shock on output.













Essays on Small Open Economies


Book Description

This dissertation research puts a focus on small open economies, whose policies do not affect world prices and interest rates. In the first chapter, it is shown that recent Canadian data from 2001 to 2013 feature a notable procyclical trade balance, which contrasts with the countercyclical trade balance in 1981-2000. By using a dynamic small open economy model built based upon Mendoza's (1991) framework, driven by correlated domestic productivity shocks and world credit spread shocks, I can generate the observed trade balance pattern in the pre-2000 and post-2000 periods. In addition, my analysis shows that the world credit spread shocks explain a large portion of the considerable change in the cyclicality of trade balance, and that the low world real risk-free interest rate after 2000 partially accounts for the procyclical trade balance in the same time period. Applications of the model to other developed small open economies, such as Australia and New Zealand, yield similar results, suggesting that the world credit spread shocks have an impact on macroeconomic dynamics and help improve model performance. The second chapter concerns an innovative exchange rate policy implemented by the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA). From 2013 to mid-2015, in order to achieve balanced economic growth, the RBA tried to bring down the Australian dollar by presenting public speeches and monetary policy statements that expressed a strong preference for a lower exchange rate, which is known as jawboning down the currency. To investigate the effectiveness of the central bank's jawboning strategy, I analyze the Australian economy with a structural vector autoregressive (SVAR) model, in which the Exchange Rate Stance Index (ERSI) is constructed to measure the magnitude of jawboning. The empirical results show that an unanticipated increase in the ERSI, which is equivalent to strengthened jawboning by the RBA, will lead to a significant and lasting fall in the real exchange rate. However, the ERSI shock fails to improve GDP over the medium term, suggesting that the jawboning strategy is not an effective exchange rate policy tool to boost GDP growth. The third chapter investigates how the global and local financial shocks would contribute to the large fluctuations of the unemployment rates in the emerging markets. We use a panel structural vector autoregressive (VAR) model to analyze monthly data from six emerging countries between 1999 and 2015. The results show that the local financial risk factors, including the country spread and the dividend yield, account for a larger portion of unemployment movements than the global financial risks, including the U.S. risk-free real interest rate and the global financial risk proxied by the U.S. Baa corporate spread.







Essays in Open Economy Macroeconomics


Book Description

This dissertation consists of two independent essays on open economy macroeconomics. The first chapter of the dissertation is motivated by the question: "What rationalizes the stylized facts of emerging market business and credit cycles?" Business and credit cycles in emerging countries display very volatile consumption, highly volatile and countercyclical net exports, strongly countercyclical real interest rates, and procyclical flows of credit to the household sector and to the business sector. The standard small-open-economy (SOE) model cannot generate this cyclical pattern of the interest rate and the change in credit market liabilities of households. In order to correct this irregularity and account for the data pattern, this paper augments the SOE model to include collateral constraints for the household sector and limited enforcement constraints for the banking sector. The model generates business and credit cycles consistent with Korean data and gives a rationale for highly volatile consumption, countercyclical country interest rates, and procyclical credit flows. In the counterfactual experiments, we find that the output volatility in Korea is reduced by 11% and welfare gains amount to 0.17% increase in one quarter's steady-state consumption when the default risk in the financial sector is completely eliminated. The second chapter investigates how the presence of pricing-to-market and the degree of imperfect financial market integration affects the effectiveness of optimal monetary policy. Global resource allocation can be inefficient because exporting firms may set different prices among markets and households in different countries may pay different prices for identical goods. On the other hand, political, technological, or informational barriers may hinder capital flows across countries, leading to deviations from perfect cross-country risk sharing. Considering this stylized setting, we augment a standard monetary open economy model to include the failure of the law of one price and imperfect financial market integration. We characterize the optimal monetary policy and assess its effectiveness in compared to inward-looking policies




Essays on Examining Monetary Policy in Emerging Countries


Book Description

This dissertation consists of three essays, which provides insights into monetary policy of emerging countries in various aspects. The first essay thoroughly investigates how the central banks in two emerging countries; Korea and Thailand, respond to economic fluctuations and observe whether their monetary policies have comparable effects on the economies. Carefully taken into account of time-series properties and the regression stability, many econometric tests are applied and the fully modified OLS with the block bootstrap is performed on their monetary policy rules to get unbiased estimation. The evidence indicates the differences of monetary policy between pre- and post-crisis and suggests that although both countries have similar economic conditions and announce the same monetary policy, the degree on stabilizing the economy in each country using the interest rate instrument is noticeably different. The second essay examines if New Keynesian type model, which is recently popular in explaining many developed economies, can as well explain an emerging economy such as Thailand in this case. The evidence suggests that simulating a New Keynesian small open economy model can capture some characteristics of Thai monetary data where their volatilities are close to volatilities of actual data, but only when the central bank is assumed to follows the Taylor rule that incorporates interest rate smoothing policy. However, comparing with the structural VAR model, the simulated model may not generate the correct size of impulse responses for Thai economy. Even so, impulse responses from both models support the implementation of explicit inflation targeting in Thailand. The last essay examines if emerging countries that implement inflation targeting are constrained by fiscal policy since these countries adopt inflation targeting recently without verifying the independence of their central banks. We observe that the interest rate setting process in inflation targeting emerging countries are not influenced by fiscal policy, and also find that the interest rate setting process of these countries are clearly different from the process of emerging countries that do not adopt inflation targeting, while it is similar to the process of industrial countries that also adopt inflation targeting.