Measuring the Growth of Structure with Multi-wavelength Surveys of Galaxy Clusters


Book Description

Current and near-future galaxy cluster surveys at a variety of wavelengths are expected to provide a promising way to obtain precision measurements of the growth of structure over cosmic time. This in turn would serve as an important precision probe of cosmology. However, to realize the full potential of these surveys, systematic uncertainties arising from, for example, cluster mass estimates and sample selection must be well understood. This work follows several different approaches towards alleviating these uncertainties. Cluster sample selection is investigated in the context of arcminute-resolution millimeter-wavelength surveys such as the Atacama Cosmology Telescope (ACT) and the South Pole Telescope (SPT). Large-area, realistic simulations of the microwave sky are constructed and cluster detection is simulated using a multi-frequency Wiener filter to separate the galaxy clusters, via their Sunyaev-Zel'dovich signal, from other contaminating microwave signals. Using this technique, an ACT-like survey can expect to obtain a cluster sample that is 90% complete and 85% pure above a mass of 3 x 10^14 Msun. Cluster mass uncertainties are explored by comparing X-ray and weak-lensing mass estimates for shear-selected galaxy clusters in the Deep Lens Survey (DLS) to study possible biases in using cluster baryons or weak-lensing shear as tracers of the cluster total mass. Results are presented for four galaxy clusters that comprise the top-ranked shear-selected system in the DLS, and for three of these clusters there is agreement between X-ray and weak-lensing mass estimates. For the fourth cluster, the X-ray mass estimate is higher than that from weak-lensing by 2-sigma, and X-ray images suggest this cluster may be undergoing a merger with a smaller cluster, which may be biasing the X-ray mass estimate high. The feasibility of measuring galaxy cluster peculiar velocities using an ACT-like instrument is also investigated. Such a possibility would allow one to measure structure growth via large-scale velocity fields and circumvent the uncertainties associated with measuring cluster masses. We show that such measurements are possible and yield statistical uncertainties of roughly 100 km/sec given either a temperature prior with 1-sigma errors of less than 2 keV or additional lower frequency millimeter-band observations.




A Multi-wavelength Study of Optically Selected Galaxy Clusters from the Blanco Cosmology Survey


Book Description

Abundance measurements of galaxy clusters provide powerful constraints of cosmology. The observed distribution of clusters can potentially be used to disentangle whether the accelerated cosmic expansion can be explained by a modification to Einstein's theory of gravity or whether the explanation involves a new form of 'dark' energy. Such growth of structure measurements are both complementary to and provide an important cross-check of measurements of the geometry of the universe. There are two key requirements for cosmology with galaxy clusters: a census of these systems through cosmic time and the ability to connect the measured signal with the underlying mass of the galaxy cluster. In this era of large-area millimeter and optical wavelength surveys (including the South Pole Telescope (SPT) 2500-square-degree SZ-Survey and the Dark Energy Survey (DES)) where hundreds (mm-wave) to hundreds of thousands (optical) of clusters will be detected, the most serious limitation to cluster cosmology remains understanding and calibrating observable-mass relations. Combining cluster observables across wavelengths can both test and inform our knowledge of such scaling relations. As a pilot program for future explorations of the combined SPT and DES datasets, we explore the relation between the optical-richness, lambda, and SZ-signal for a sample of 567 optically-selected clusters from the Blanco Cosmology Survey, an ~ 80 square-degree survey located within the SPT-SZ survey. In this study we detect SZ-signal at increasing significance as a function of cluster richness but find that the recovered signal falls below expectations derived from models based on X-ray samples. We explore possible biases to our recovered signal and find that contamination from cluster members -- in particular radio and dust emission from galaxies--is small and that the majority of the discrepancy at the high mass end can be explained by errors in identifying the optical centers of clusters. The toolset developed here can be combined with future cluster catalogs from the Dark Energy Survey to help improve mass-richness scaling relations and ultimately constrain cosmological models.




Precision Cosmology with Galaxy Cluster Surveys


Book Description

The acceleration of the universe, which is often attributed to "dark energy, " has posed one of the main challenges to fundamental physics. Galaxy clusters provide one of the most sensitive probes of dark energy because their abundance reflects the growth rate of large-scale structure and the expansion rate of the universe. Several large galaxy cluster surveys will soon provide tremendous statistical power to constrain the properties of dark energy; however, the constraining power of these surveys will be determined by how well systematic errors are controlled. Of these systematic errors, the dominant one comes from inferring cluster masses using observable signals of clusters, the so-called "observable--mass distribution." This thesis focuses on extracting dark energy information from forthcoming large galaxy cluster surveys, including how we maximize the cosmological information, how we control important systematics, and how precisely we need to calibrate theoretical models. We study how multi-wavelength follow-up observations can improve cluster mass calibration in optical surveys. We also investigate the impact of theoretical uncertainties in calibrating the spatial distributions of galaxy clusters on dark energy constraints. In addition, we explore how the formation history of galaxy clusters impacts the self-calibration of cluster mass. In addition, we use N-body simulations to develop a new statistical sample of cluster-size halos in order to further understand the observable--mass distribution. We study the completeness of subhalos in our cluster sample by comparing them with the satellite galaxies in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey. We also study how subhalo selections impact the inferred correlation between formation time and optical mass tracers, including cluster richness and velocity dispersion.




Clusters of Galaxies: Physics and Cosmology


Book Description

Clusters of galaxies are large assemblies of galaxies, hot gas and dark matter bound together by gravity. Galaxy clusters are now one of the most important cosmological probes to test the standard cosmological models. Constraints on the Dark Energy equation of state from the cluster number density measurements, deviations from the Gaussian perturbation models, the Sunyaev-Zeldovich effect as well as the dark matter proles are among the issues to be studied with clusters. The baryonic composition of clusters is dominated by hot gas that is in quasi-hydrostatic equilibrium within the dark matter-dominated gravitational potential well of the cluster. The hot gas is visible through spatially extended thermal X-ray emission, and it has been studied extensively both for assessing its physical properties and as a tracer of the large-scale structure of the Universe. Magnetic fields as well as a number of non-thermal plasma processes play a role in clusters of galaxies as we observe from radioastronomical observations. The goal of this volume is to review these processes and to investigate how they are interlinked. Overall, these papers provide a timely and comprehensive review of the multi-wavelength observations and theoretical understanding of clusters of galaxies in the cosmological context. Thus, the volume will be particularly useful to postgraduate students and researchers active in various areas of astrophysics and space science. Originally published in Space Science Reviews in the Topical Collection "Clusters of Galaxies: Physics and Cosmology"







Multiwavelength Cosmology


Book Description

The recent scientific efforts in Astrophysics & Cosmology have brought a revolution to our understanding of the Cosmos. Amazing results is the outcome of amazing experiments! The huge scientific, technological & financial effort that has gone into building the 10-m class telescopes as well as many space and balloon observatories, essential to observe the multitude of cosmic phenomena in their manifestations at different wavelengths, from gamma-rays to the millimetre and the radio, has given and is still giving its fruits of knowledge. These recent scientific achievements in Observational and Theoretical Cosmology were presented in the "Multiwavelength Cosmology" conference that took place on beautiful Mykonos island in the Aegean between 17 and 20 June 2003. More than 180 Cosmologists from all over the world gathered for a four-day intense meeting in which recent results from large ground based surveys (AAT/2-df, SLOAN) and space missions (WMAP, Chandra, XMM, ISO, HST) were presented and debated, providing a huge impetus to our knowledge of the Cosmos. The future of the subject (experiments, and directions of research) was also discussed. The conference was devoted mostly on the constraints on Cosmological models and galaxy formation theories that arise from the study of the high redshift Universe, from clusters of galaxies, and their evolution, from the cosmic microwave background, the large-scale structure and star-formation history.




Multi-probe Cluster Cosmology Analyses with Photometric Surveys


Book Description

The universe we live in is expanding faster and faster. This phenomenon called cosmic acceleration is one of the most puzzling cosmological discoveries in the past 25 years: even the least exotic explanation requires a new pervasive energy component in our universe (called dark energy). Despite the mysterious nature of dark energy, a model ($\Lambda$CDM) based on Einstein's general relativity, a cosmological constant (a specific form of dark energy), and slowly moving dark matter, seems to be able to describe a variety of observations from the high- to low-redshift universe. To understand the nature of dark energy and to test the $\Lambda$CDM paradigm, ambitious cosmological surveys, such as the Dark Energy Survey (DES), the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument (DESI), the Rubin Observatory's Legacy Survey of Space and Time (LSST), and the Roman Space Telescope, aim to precisely and robustly measure cosmic structure and its evolution via various cosmological probes, such as weak gravitational lensing, galaxy clustering, and other techniques. Combining multiple cosmological probes (known as multi-probe analyses) provides precise and robust cosmological constraints. Galaxy clustering, weak gravitational lensing, and abundances of galaxy clusters each are sensitive to different aspects of cosmic structure formation and are affected by different astrophysical and observational uncertainties. Thus, their combination is expected to be more precise and robust than any of the probe alone. Among these probes, the abundances and spatial distribution of galaxy clusters, which are associated with the highest peaks in the matter density field, provide powerful probes of cosmic structure and its evolution. This thesis presents original research that improves our understandings of the universe by observations of galaxy clusters. In the three self-contained projects, I (1) develop and validate methods for combining cluster abundances and two-point correlation functions, (2) perform the first blind cosmology analysis on combining cluster abundances, weak gravitational lensing, and galaxy clustering using data taken in the first season (DES-Y1) of the Dark Energy Survey, and (3) quantify the connections between red galaxies and their host dark matter halos by modeling luminosity functions of galaxies in galaxy clusters. While these three projects have already advanced our understandings of the cosmos, they also serve as an example of how one can use millions of clusters expected to be detected with the upcoming surveys in 2020s to improve our knowledge of the universe. These opportunities are also discussed in this thesis.




Cosmology with Clusters of Galaxies


Book Description

This book presents a comprehensive review of the methods applied to derive cosmological parameters for a given model and test different cosmological models using the most massive collapsed structures in our Universe: clusters of galaxies. Clusters typically consist of hundreds of galaxies and high-temperature ionised gas trapped in their gravitational field dominated by dark matter extending out to 2-3 Mpc. The formation, evolution, and structure of these massive rare objects are sensitive probes of the assumed cosmology. This is a multidisciplinary field of astrophysics involving multi-wavelength observations, gravity theory, atomic physics, plasma physics, magneto-hydrodynamics, astrophysical cosmology and numerical simulations. Our understanding of the physics of clusters, which is essential when using them for cosmology, has been improved tremendously due to the recent advent of technology and observational strategy in multi-frequency observations, and enhanced by improved numerical simulations made possible by more advanced high performance computers. As a result of these developments, cosmology with clusters of galaxies has become a mature discipline recently, and provided an important contribution to establish our concordance cosmological constant dominated cold dark matter model. In the near future we expect a rapid expansion of this field due to results from new cluster surveys and multi-wavelength observations. This timely volume on this exciting newly established field discusses galaxy cluster physics and provides a detailed description of using clusters to derive cosmological parameters applying accurate measurements of individual clusters as well as using clusters as a statistical tool. A detailed discussion is given on degeneracies between derived parameters and the systematic effects, which are becoming a limiting factor. An account for using clusters to test different cosmological models is also presented. This volume provides an introduction to galaxy cluster cosmology for physics and astronomy graduate students and serves as a reference source for professionals.




Cosmological Constraints from Galaxy Clusters in the 2500 Square-degree SPT-SZ Survey


Book Description

(Abridged) We present cosmological constraints obtained from galaxy clusters identified by their Sunyaev-Zel'dovich effect signature in the 2500 square degree South Pole Telescope Sunyaev Zel'dovich survey. We consider the 377 cluster candidates identified at z>0.25 with a detection significance greater than five, corresponding to the 95% purity threshold for the survey. We compute constraints on cosmological models using the measured cluster abundance as a function of mass and redshift. We include additional constraints from multi-wavelength observations, including Chandra X-ray data for 82 clusters and a weak lensing-based prior on the normalization of the mass-observable scaling relations. Assuming a LCDM cosmology, where the species-summed neutrino mass has the minimum allowed value (mnu = 0.06 eV) from neutrino oscillation experiments, we combine the cluster data with a prior on H0 and find sigma_8 = 0.797+-0.031 and Omega_m = 0.289+-0.042, with the parameter combination sigma_8(Omega_m/0.27)^0.3 = 0.784+-0.039. These results are in good agreement with constraints from the CMB from SPT, WMAP, and Planck, as well as with constraints from other cluster datasets. Adding mnu as a free parameter, we find mnu = 0.14+-0.08 eV when combining the SPT cluster data with Planck CMB data and BAO data, consistent with the minimum allowed value. Finally, we consider a cosmology where mnu and N_eff are fixed to the LCDM values, but the dark energy equation of state parameter w is free. Using the SPT cluster data in combination with an H0 prior, we measure w = -1.28+-0.31, a constraint consistent with the LCDM cosmological model and derived from the combination of growth of structure and geometry. When combined with primarily geometrical constraints from Planck CMB, H0, BAO and SNe, adding the SPT cluster data improves the w constraint from the geometrical data alone by 14%, to w = -1.023+-0.042.




Merging Processes in Galaxy Clusters


Book Description

Mergers are the mechanisms by which galaxy clusters are assembled through the hierarchical growth of smaller clusters and groups. Major cluster mergers are the most energetic events in the Universe since the Big Bang. Many of the observed properties of clusters depend on the physics of the merging process. These include substructure, shock, intra cluster plasma temperature and entropy structure, mixing of heavy elements within the intra cluster medium, acceleration of high-energy particles, formation of radio halos and the effects on the galaxy radio emission. This book reviews our current understanding of cluster merging from an observational and theoretical perspective, and is appropriate for both graduate students and researchers in the field.