A Comparison of the Corrosion Behavior and Protective Value of Electrodeposited Zinc and Cadmium Coatings on Steel


Book Description

Electrodeposited coatings of both zinc and cadmium are commonly used to prevent the rusting of steel parts exposed to the atmosphere. During the period of World War II the armed services and, particularly, the Navy Department were inclined to favor the use of cadmium for this purpose, as judged from their general specifications for that time. Because of the acute shortage of cadmium and cadmium plating facilities during World War II it was necessary to give serious consideration to the substitution of zinc wherever possible. This resulted in considerable controversy as to the relative merits of the two metals, particularly their protective value when applied in equal thicknesses. Previous work (1-3) had shown zinc coatings to be superior to cadmium coatings when exposed to industrial atmospheres. The tests of Blum, Strausser, and Brenner also showed zinc coatings to have somewhat longer protective life than cadmium coatings in mild, rural locations such as State College, Pa., and urban sites such as Washington, D. C. While only comparatively thin coatings were involved, it was concluded from this same work that the difference in protective value between the two kinds of coatings in marine locations was not significant. On the other hand, the results of many comparative salt spray tests had shown cadmium coatings to be markedly superior to zinc coatings under the particular conditions prevailing in a salt spray cabinet. Undoubtedly the results of these accelerated tests contributed in a large measure to the generally prevalent attitude favoring cadmium coatings in marine atmospheres. The work reported herein was undertaken to determine the relative protective value of zinc and cadmium coatings in a wide variety of environments including accelerated corrosion tests.




Zinc and Cadmium Coatings


Book Description







Quality Metal Finishing Guide


Book Description













Sliding Wear and Fretting Behaviour of Electrodeposited Γ-phase Zinc-nickel Coatings as a Replacement for Electrodeposited Cadmium Coatings


Book Description

Electrodeposited Zn-Ni coatings is used as a sacrificial corrosion protective coating for steel in the automotive industry. Recently, the aerospace industry has taken an interest in these coatings due to the increasing restrictions on cadmium. Many studies have been made on improving the plating process and corrosion properties of Zn-Ni coatings. Although these coatings encounter tribological situations, there is still an information gap on their tribological behaviour. Therefore, the tribological behaviour of Zn-Ni coatings are studied in terms of fretting and sliding wear in this work and are compared with cadmium.Tribological studies of the fretting and sliding wear behaviour on Zn-Ni and Cd coatings were conducted. For Zn-Ni coating, studies showed that the surface morphology had a strong effect on the velocity accommodation mechanisms. In the stick or partial slip regime, the smoother and dense coating formed cracks on the surface in order to accommodate wear, whereas for the rougher coating, only asperities of the coating were deformed, as the morphology of the coating allowed some degree of elastic deformation. In the mixed slip and the gross slip regimes, shearing of the third bodies accommodated the velocity in both cases. When slipping occurred, the rougher coating also showed higher wear, as the morphology of the coating allowed easier detachment, as cracks and through thickness defects were present where the agglomerates of the coating meets. When compared with Cd coatings, the material properties affected the fretting behaviour strongly. Cadmium coating remained in the partial slip regime despite changing the displacement amplitude, due to the mechanical properties and crystal structure of cadmium. Plastic flow of the coating material accommodated the velocity for cadmium coating, as cadmium has a hexagonal crystal structure and is very ductile. Although cadmium remained in the stick and partial slip regime, increasing the displacement amplitude increased the friction and wear of the coating. When a high displacement amplitude was used, cadmium coating was removed from the center of the contact and the substrate was exposed.Sliding wear studies of the effect of normal load, surface morphology and humidity for Zn-Ni coatings were conducted and the results were compared with Cd. Formation of an oxide layer appeared to have a strong effect on the sliding wear behaviour, the smoother and dense coating was subjected to test performed in various humidity conditions. At high humidity, a continuous nanocrystalline ZnO film was formed on the surface of the wear track, which helped mitigate wear and stabilize the friction. This is because velocity was accommodated through shearing of the nanocrystalline film. In contrast, at zero humidity level, a prow formed due to adhesive wear behaviour. Velocity was accommodated by ploughing of the wear track and shearing of the particles. When tests were performed in high humidity, increasing the normal load caused breaking of the oxide layer that was formed on the wear track, which resulted in more adhesive wear. At low normal loads, the rougher coating showed more wear than the smoother coating. At the highest normal load, the wear of the smoother coating became more severe as the lack of a continuous oxide film caused more adhesive wear. The rougher coating was less sensitive to increase of initial Hertzian contact stress, as the surface morphology of the coating allowed some degree of elastic and plastic deformation. When compared to Cd, humidity also affected the sliding wear behaviour of Cd due to change in the composition of the third bodies. Decreasing the humidity was beneficial to cadmium but detrimental to Zn-Ni. Due to material properties, a lower CoF was observed for cadmium, while a higher wear resistance was observed in Zn-Ni coating.