A Primer for Deterministic and Stochastic Drill-String Vibration Analyses


Book Description

This is the first book dedicated to oil well drilling vibrations. The objectives are to provide an exposition to important concepts in drilling and drilling dynamics, and to describe both deterministic and probabilistic solution techniques that may be used to gain insight in downhole vibrations. These considerations are addressed based on a collection of drilling technical publications; an exhaustive literature review. Appendices include a detailed description of the mode superposition method, and a technique to generate trivariate random processes with digital filters.




Dynamic Analysis of a Drill-string Under Deterministic and Random Excitations


Book Description

Drill-strings are slender structures used to dig into the rock in search of oil and gas. Failures of drill-strings are time and money consuming and therefore the dynamics of drill-strings must be investigated and carefully controlled. In the thesis, a dynamic model of the drill-string that is suitable for predicting axial, torsional and lateral vibrations is built using Euler-Bernoulli beam theory. The drillstring is driven by a DC motor on the top and is subjected to distributed loads due to its own weight as well as bit/formation interaction. The model is axial-torsional, lateral-torsional coupled. Under deterministic excitations, the model captures stickslip behavior in drilling operation. Analysis on its negative effect on drilling performance is made, and potential mitigation measures are also discussed. In random model, the excitations to the drill-bit are modeled as combination of deterministic and random components. Monte Carlo (MC) simulation is employed to obtain the statistics of the response. Two cases of random excitation with different intensities are investigated. The results from MC simulation are compared against that from deterministic case. Secondly, the thesis focuses on the drill-string torsional vibration and its stick-slip analysis. A finite element model of the drillstring with inclusion of both deterministic and random excitations is also developed. Simulation is carried out under certain parameters and it is shown that in deterministic case the torsional vibration may behave stick-slip. With change of some parameters, bifurcation and chaos of the system are observed. In the random case, Monte Carlo simulation and path integration method are used to capture the probabilistic information of the response. The results of path integration match well to those of deterministic cases. Although there are some limitations, this thesis will help the author better understand drill-string downhole behaviors and lay a foundation for further research work.




Fatigue Estimation of Drill-string and Drill-pipe Threaded Connection Subjected to Random Loadings


Book Description

Drill-strings are slender structures used to drill the oil-well in searching for oil and gas. Failures of drill-strings cause the loss of time and money and therefore predicting fatigue damage induced by vibrations is of benefit. In this thesis, fatigue calculation of drill-strings is conducted in both time domain and frequency domain, considering axial and torsional vibrations. In time domain analysis, the stress time histories at any specific location of the drillstring are obtained from a finite element model. Both deterministic and random excitations are taken into account. Then using a rainflow counting method, the damaging stress cycles are extracted. Based on the linear cumulative damage law, fatigue damage is then calculated and fatigue life of the drill-string is therefore predicted. Results under both deterministic and random excitations are compared against each other. Time domain fatigue analysis gives accurate predictions at the cost of long calculating time. For the sake of time-saving, a method in frequency domain is developed. The drill-string vibration model is built using continuous parameter method. Power spectral densities (PSD) of the random excitation are assumed. In the process to gain expected damage, equivalent stress spectra are calculated based on Mocha's random fatigue failure criterion. Then the expected fatigue damage and predicted life are estimated by a spectral method: Dirlik's method. Further, the drill-pipe threaded connection, which is used to connect numerous drillpipes collars to form a drill-string, is investigated. With the help of ANSYS workbench 15.0, a standard 4.5" API line pipe threaded connection model is built. Random excitation is considered mainly due to the unevenness of rock formation being drilled. Firstly, a static stress analysis is conducted considering "make-up" and "tensile load" steps. Then modal analysis and random vibration analysis are conducted, assuming acceleration PSD as input. Finally, based on three-band technique, the fatigue damage is calculated. Computer simulations are run and results are given by the above three fatigue damage calculation methods. Results show the critical positions of both the drill-string and the threaded connection, where attention should be paid to by the manufacturers and the drilling operators. Although some limitations exist, this thesis proposed two ways to evaluate fatigue damage of a drill-string. The threaded pipe connection, which is a complex structure, is also analyzed. Further research work will aim at the validation of the simulations.







Modeling and Control of Drillstring Dynamics for Vibration Suppression


Book Description

Drill-string vibrations could cause fatigue failure to downhole tools, bring damage to the wellbore, and decrease drilling efficiency; therefore, it is important to understand the drill-string dynamics through accurately modeling of the drill-string and bottom-hole assembly (BHA) dynamics, and then develop controllers to suppress the vibrations. Modeling drill-string dynamics for directional drilling operation is highly challenging because the drill-string and BHA bend with large curvatures. In addition, the interaction between the drill-string and wellbore wall could occur along the entire well. This fact complicates the boundary condition of modeling of drill-string dynamics. This dissertation presents a finite element method (FEM) model to characterize the dynamics of a directional drill-string. Based on the principle of virtual work, the developed method linearizes the drill-string dynamics around the central axis of a directional well, which significantly reduced the computational cost. In addition, a six DOF curved beam element is derived to model a curved drill-string. It achieves higher accuracy than the widely used straight beam element in both static and dynamic analyses. As a result, fewer curved beam elements are used to achieve the same accuracy, which further reduces the computational cost. During this research, a comprehensive drill-string and wellbore interaction model is developed as the boundary condition to simulate realistic drilling scenarios. Both static and dynamic analyses are carried out using the developed modeling framework. The static simulation can generate drill-string internal force as well as the drilling torque and drag force. The dynamic simulation can provide an insight of the underlying mechanism of drilling vibrations. Top drive controllers are also incorporated as torsional boundary conditions. The guidelines for tuning the control parameters are obtained from dynamic simulations. Drill-string vibrations can be suppressed through BHA configuration optimization. Based on the developed modeling framework, the BHA dynamic performance is evaluated using vibration indices. With an objective to minimize these indices, a genetic algorithm is developed to optimize the BHA stabilizer location for vibration suppression. After optimization, the BHA strain energy and the stabilizer side force, two of the vibration indices, are significantly reduced compared to the original design, which proves the BHA optimization method can lead to a significant reduction of undesirable drilling dynamics. At the end of this dissertation, reduced order models are also discussed for fast simulation and control design for real time operation










Modeling and Experimental Identification of Torsional Drill String Dynamics Under Uncertainties


Book Description

This D.Sc. thesis proposes new perspectives for modeling drill string torsional dynamics under uncertainties. This work develops a novel stochastic hysteretic (nonreversible) bit-rock interaction model. Firstly, a new nominal interaction model, which depends not only on the bit speed, but also on the bit acceleration is developed. Then, a new stochastic model for the bit-rock interaction, taking into account the inherent fluctuations during the drilling, is also proposed. Furthermore, here a new test-rig is proposed to analyze drill string dynamics and bit-rock interaction, which is able to reproduce stick-slip phenomena while drilling a rock sample using standard masonry bits, as well as to validate bit-rock interaction models. An original strategy for modeling uncertainties globally, based on terms of the nonparametric probabilistic approach, considering a simple torsional model for a drill string, is also proposed herein. This strategy allows to control the dispersion level of each interior and interface DOFs of each drill string substructure independently, which can provide more information to improve the operational safety.