Analysis of the Effects of Online Homework on the Achievement, Persistence, and Attitude of Developmental Mathematics Students


Book Description

This dissertation summarizes a study of the use of online homework with developmental mathematics students at the University of Alaska Fairbanks. To address the problem of high failure rates in developmental mathematics courses this study investigated the relationship between online homework and academic achievement, persistence, and attitude. Special focus was placed on non-traditional and Alaska Native students. A matched pair experimental design was employed. The independent variable was homework type and the dependent variables were achievement, persistence, and attitude. Nineteen sections of developmental mathematics, six instructors, and 423 student participants were involved. The main effect of homework type was not statistically significant to any of the dependent variables. However, the effect of the interaction between homework type and course level was significant (p = 0.005). Upon further analysis it was found that one of the four levels (beginning algebra) had significantly higher post-test scores when online homework was assigned. The interaction effects of homework type/ Native status and homework type/ non-traditional status were not statistically significant on any of the dependent variables. Also, results from homework questionnaires were compared. In general, students rated paper homework slightly higher than online homework. Instructors rated online homework higher than students did. Non-traditional students scored paper homework higher than online homework. The conclusion of this study is that while students have a slightly more favorable attitude toward paper homework, online homework in conjunction with graded paper quizzes and face-to-face instruction does not have a negative effect on achievement or persistence.




The Effects of Online Homework on Achievement and Self-efficacy of College Algebra Students


Book Description

This study compared the effectiveness, in terms of mathematical achievement and mathematics self-efficacy, of online homework to textbook homework over an entire semester for 145 students enrolled in multiple sections of college algebra at a large community college. A quasi-experimental, posttest design was used to analyze the effect on mathematical achievement, as measured by a final exam. A pretest-posttest design was used to analyze the effect on mathematics self-efficacy, as measured by the Mathematics Self-efficacy Scale. The control group completed their homework using the textbook and the treatment group completed similar homework using an online homework system developed by the textbook publisher. All class sections followed a common syllabus, schedule, and homework list and completed a common, departmental final exam. Classroom observations were also used as a way to establish the similarity between groups. The results of the study found that while the treatment group generally scored higher on the final exam, no significant difference existed between the mathematical achievement of the control and treatment groups. Both the control and treatment group did experience significant improvements in their mathematics self-efficacy, but neither group demonstrated more improvement than the other. When students were divided based on incoming math skill level, analysis showed that low-skilled students who used online homework exhibited significantly higher mathematical achievement than low-skilled students who used textbook homework. Exploratory analysis also showed that more students with low incoming skill levels and more repeating students received a passing grade when using online homework than did their higher-skilled, first-time counterparts, although the differences were not significant. Based on this study it appears as if online homework is just as effective as textbook homework in helping students learn college algebra and in improving students' mathematics self-efficacy. Online homework may be even more effective for helping the large population of college algebra students who enroll in the course with inadequate prerequisite math skills. Instructors and researchers should consider the possibility that online homework can successfully help certain populations of students develop understanding better than traditional approaches. This study has implications for mathematics instructors and for online homework system developers.




The Effects of Online Homework on Achievement on College Preparatory Mathematics Classes


Book Description

This study investigated the effects the online homework system MathXLforschools.com (MXL) had on student achievement as measured by exam scores in a high school Algebra 1 course. One hundred eight high school students, ranging from ninth to eleventh grade, from three different Algebra 1 classes, participated in the study. All three classes were taught by the author. The scores on a benchmark and final exam of students who completed homework using the MXL online homework system were compared to the scores of students who completed their homework using their textbook. During the first semester of the 2013-2014 school year all participants of the study completed their homework using only their textbooks. The study then compared the first quarter benchmark scores of participants who completed their homework using the MXL online homework system with their third quarter benchmark scores. In addition, the study compared the semester one final exam scores of the same participants with their semester two final exam scores. The study found that there was no statistical difference in exam scores of students who completed homework using MXL compared to students who completed homework using their textbook.







Internet Homework Activities and Traditional Homework Activities


Book Description

The purpose of the study was to provide information on the assessment of student learning, time spent on homework, and student attitudes toward the subject matter when taught a risk management unit using two different types of homework assignments. The two types of homework assignments studied were Internet homework activities and traditional homework activities. An experimental design with a posttest-only control group was selected to test the major hypotheses. A posttest was developed for the risk management unit. At the conclusion of the experiment, the students also were given a subject matter attitude scale that was a modified form of the "Attitude Toward any School Subject" instrument. Analysis of data showed no statistical significance on unit examination scores between the two homework methods, no statistical significance on student perception of risk management between the two homework methods, and no statistical significant relationship between unit examination scores and ownership of a computer as well as knowledge of Internet applications. However, a significant difference was found in time spent on homework and the two homework methods. In addition, a significant relationship was found between unit examination scores and prior knowledge of risk management. Conclusions were: (a) Internet homework activities and traditional homework activities are both effective in reinforcing subject matter. (b) Internet homework activities and traditional homework activities require different amounts of time for completion. (c) Student perception about risk management subject matter is not affected by the homework method. (d) Students who have prior knowledge of the subject matter appear to have higher subject matter examination scores. (e) Students who own a computer do not perform better on subject matter examination scores when compared to students who do not own a computer. (f) There is no improvement in subject matter examination scores if a student has prior knowledge of Internet applications.




Authentic Or Traditional Homework


Book Description

This project examined how authentic and traditional math homework assignments affect student attitudes and achievement. Experimental research was implemented in the study using the pretest-posttest control group design. Likert style surveys were distributed to students and parents to compare attitudes regarding homework assignments. Open-ended questionnaires were given to students to determine emerging themes and patterns. The Tennessee Comprehensive Assessment Program (TCAP) data was used to compare the academic performance of the two groups. Significant differences were found on the student and parent attitude surveys. Themes emerged from the open-ended questionnaires. Significant differences were found on the within-subjects effect TCAP comparison, and the amount of achievement each group made.




Learning in a Web-based Homework System


Book Description

A considerable number of students enter college under-prepared and are required to enroll in developmental math courses to increase their knowledge and skills. To help these students learn, web-based homework systems offer endless opportunities for students to practice problem solving with immediate feedback and provide numerous opportunities to access help resources. However, research results are mixed and findings do not indicate that completing web-based homework significantly increases performance when compared to completing paper-based homework. For the purpose of understanding these inconsistent findings, this study seeks to explore how developmental math students utilize the help resources to solve problems in a web-based system and what, if any, knowledge and skills have been acquired. The phenomenological study was conducted at a community college and participants were enrolled in a Beginning Algebra class. Participants were observed solving a set of six problems two times. For the first set of problems, participants were able to seek help from the computer program resources provided. Then immediately after completing the first set of problems, a second set of similar problems was solved without the option of using help resources. Observations were recorded with two devices: (1) CamStudio was used to record the participants' screen activity; and (2) a Livescribe Smartpen was used to record the participants' writing as they solved problems. In addition, interviews were conducted approximately two weeks later as a follow-up to the observations. Findings indicate that participants accessed one resource and developed one strategy when solving a problem. They engaged in primarily executive help seeking behaviors for task completion and at times, instrumental help seeking behaviors for conceptual understanding. The findings also demonstrated that successful homework completion did not ensure successful quiz performance and unfamiliarity with the web-based homework system had a negative impact on learning. Moreover, reading was important but not always helpful. The findings suggest that students need training to develop learning strategies while accessing the resources. Moreover, learning should include understanding the material conceptually and not just mimicking the steps in the problem-solving process. Overall, students need more guidance and not less when learning in a web-based environment. --Abstract










Homework, Learning and Academic Success: The Role of Family and Contextual Variables


Book Description

The main purpose of this Research Topic is to analyze and identify the main family and contextual variables that are involved in the process of carrying out homework. This will require studying the role played by teachers, students, and families in order to ensure that schoolwork is a useful learning tool. Although the role of the student is, obviously, crucial in homework, research has focused on the cumulative time spent by the student carrying out homework. However, the time spent on homework is not in itself evidence of the student’s involvement nor is time spent indicative of quality time. Indeed, an excess of time can sometimes denote low competence in a field of knowledge, while spending less time on homework could be indicative of high competence. It is more likely that a high dedication of time spent on homework reflects high motivation, or comprehension deficits, rather than commitment to learning or academic motivation. In tandem with the role of the student, teachers, as responsible for prescribing homework assignments for students, also become central players in the process of completing homework assignments. The decisions that teachers make about homework prescriptions, and the amount and type of tasks they set, will determine, to a large extent, the quality of the homework process including the student’s motivation and the student’s level of engagement with homework. Furthermore, the fact that homework is useful, interesting and motivating for students, will depend on how the teacher prescribes those tasks and the connection established with classroom learning. Teacher feedback also acquires particular relevance for this point by helping the students to accurately estimate the quality of their progress and overcome the difficulties they may have encountered in carrying out their homework. Lastly, the effectiveness of teacher feedback depends on its contribution to the student’s educational progress and how that student will perform in the future. In addition to the student who performs the task and the teacher who prescribes and corrects it, we must not lose sight of parents’ role. Although there are discrepancies regarding the role that parents play in relation to homework, it is evident that their implication has important consequences not only on the final result of those tasks but also on the very process of carrying them out. Everything seems to indicate that the family environment and, more specifically, the support and feedback provided by parents is a factor that can determine the involvement of students in school duties. In this way, providing emotional support encouraging children to get involved can contribute positively to improving their motivation and interest in the performance of homework. The objective of this Research Topic is to provide researchers and professionals in psychology and education settings with some of the most recent empirical evidence regarding the homework process, its prescription and correction. Overall, we aim to cease making homework a source of conflict and controversy at the socio-educational level in order to provide useful instruments for improving the quality of student learning. This work was developed with the financing of the research projects EDU2013-44062-P (MINECO), EDU2017-82984-P (MEIC).