Credit Rating Impact on Earnings Management Around Initial Public Offerings


Book Description

This study examines the impact of having a credit rating on earnings management (EM) through accruals and real activities manipulation by initial public offering (IPO) firms. We find that firms going public with a credit rating are less likely to engage in income-enhancing accrual-based and real EM in the offering year. The monitoring by a credit rating agency (CRA) and the reduced information asymmetry due to the provision of a credit rating disincentivise rated issuers from managing earnings. We also suggest that the participation of a reputable auditing firm is crucial for CRAs to effectively restrain EM. Moreover, we document that for unrated issuers, at-issue income-increasing EM is not linked to future earnings and negatively related to post-issue long-run stock performance. However, for rated issuers, at-issue income-increasing EM is positively associated with subsequent accounting performance and unrelated to long-run stock performance following the offering. The evidence indicates that managers in unrated firms generally manipulate earnings to mislead investors, while managers in rated firms tend to exercise their accounting and operating discretion for informative purposes.













Earnings Quality at Initial Public Offerings


Book Description

Financial reporting around the time of IPOs is consistent with listed firms reporting more conservatively than previously as private firms, consistent with the results in Ball and Shivakumar (2005). We hypothesize that IPO firms supply the higher quality financial reports demanded by public investors, who face higher information asymmetry than private investors. The market mechanisms for enforcing this demand include monitoring by internal and external auditors, boards, analysts, rating agencies, the press and other parties. Once public, firms are subject to greater regulatory scrutiny and penalties. From the point of releasing the public prospectus document onwards, IPO firms face a greater threat of shareholder litigation and regulatory action if they do not meet higher reporting standards. The evidence is overwhelmingly in favor of this hypothesis. We show that the evidence reported by Teoh, Welch and Wong (1998) in support of the alternative hypothesis, that IPO firms opportunistically inflate earnings to influence the IPO price, is unreliable for a variety of reasons. We provide cleaner evidence, from samples of U.K. and U.S. IPOs, that IPO prospectus financials are conservative by several standards. We conjecture that the types of bias we observe in conventional estimates of quot;discretionaryquot; accruals occur in a broad genre of studies on earnings management around large transactions and events.




A Comparative Analysis of Real and Accrual Earnings Management Around Initial Public Offerings Under Different Regulatory Environments


Book Description

While earnings management around IPOs has been researched in a number of settings, there has been a relative absence of work that analyses the impact of the regulatory environment on such activities. We find that the regulatory environment does impact the real and accrual earnings management activities of IPO firms. Our results show that IPO firms listing on the lightly regulated UK Alternative Investment Market (AIM) have higher (lower) levels of accrual based and sales based (discretionary expenses based) earnings management around the IPO than firms listing on the more heavily regulated Main market in the UK.




Incentives and Opportunities for Earnings Management in Initial Public Offerings


Book Description

This paper examines accounting earnings and the associated accrual and cash flow components in the years surrounding an initial public offering (IPO) to study the incentives and opportunities for firms to manage earnings when going public. We identify firm and offering characteristics that may be related to the amount of earnings management in IPO firms. We find that age and ownership retention by original entrepreneurs are significantly negatively related to industry-adjusted discretionary accounting accruals. In addition, we find that net income and cash flow from operations increase in the fiscal year prior to the IPO, and decline significantly in the year of the IPO. Net income continues to decline subsequently but not cash flows. Discretionary working capital and total accruals in the year of the IPO are negatively related to future cash flows and the change in net income between the pre-and post-IPO period. Taken together, the evidence is consistent with a scenario where firms either time an IPO immediately after a year of unusually high cash flow or boost cash flows right before the IPO, and then use accounting accruals to sustain reported net income in the year of the IPO. Thus, the evidence is consistent with the IPO firm attempting to manage investor perceptions with discretionary accruals.




Earnings Management


Book Description

This book is a study of earnings management, aimed at scholars and professionals in accounting, finance, economics, and law. The authors address research questions including: Why are earnings so important that firms feel compelled to manipulate them? What set of circumstances will induce earnings management? How will the interaction among management, boards of directors, investors, employees, suppliers, customers and regulators affect earnings management? How to design empirical research addressing earnings management? What are the limitations and strengths of current empirical models?




ACCOUNTING & STOCK PERFORMANCE


Book Description

This dissertation, "Accounting and Stock Performance of Initial Public Offerings and Seasoned Equity Offerings: Evidence in China" by Liangyi, Ouyang, 歐陽良宜, was obtained from The University of Hong Kong (Pokfulam, Hong Kong) and is being sold pursuant to Creative Commons: Attribution 3.0 Hong Kong License. The content of this dissertation has not been altered in any way. We have altered the formatting in order to facilitate the ease of printing and reading of the dissertation. All rights not granted by the above license are retained by the author. Abstract: Abstract of the thesis entitled Accounting and Stock Performance of Initial Public Offerings and Seasoned Equity Offerings: Evidence in China Submitted By OUYANG Liangyi For the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy at the University of Hong Kong in August 2004 Although it has a short history, the China stock market developed very fast in the past decade. Stock is now a primary investment instrument for Chinese. This research studies the long-term accounting and stock performance of initial public offerings and seasoned equity offerings in China. We find that operating performance of initial public offerings and seasoned equity offerings in China experience substantial deterioration in the post-issue period. Issuers typically have significant higher earnings and sales revenue than their industry peers before year 0. However, their advantages shrink to nothing in a short period. Extraordinarily high current accruals are reported in year 0, which consist of a large discretionary component after broken down by a Jones (1991) model. We attribute the unusual changes in accruals and operating performance to be a result of earnings management. Moreover, we find that both absolute and discretionary current accruals in year 0 are powerful in predicting changes of income and cash flow in the following three years. This finding further strengthens the hypothesis that managers dress up their earnings to meet the earnings threshold by recording aggressive accruals, which cause earnings reverse in the aftermarket period. Investors are surprised at the poor earnings. Earnings announcement effects, measured by 3-, 9- and 21-day market-adjusted abnormal returns are significantly negative in post-issue period. We also find stock offerings have negative buy-and-hold abnormal ii returns in a three-year window. Both IPOs and SEOs have around 30% less returns than size-matched non-issuers. However, when the matching standard changes to be size and book-to-market ratio, the abnormal returns are reduced by half and not significant for SEOs. We also apply the Fama and French (1993) model to monthly trading data of issuers. The result shows that the time-weighted abnormal return is not significant. We consider this difference to be a result of the time-clustering and cyclical pattern of stock issues in China. Due to high volumes of stock issues in periods of high past returns and low volumes in periods of low past returns, a time-weighted method may not find underperformance while an equal-weighted method may. We explain the negative cross-sectional abnormal returns as results of investor overoptimism and information asymmetry. Investors have insufficient information about issuers and overestimate issuers' future earnings. Along with new information released in earnings reports, they gradually downgrade their valuation, thus contributing to the negative cross-sectional returns. We find that the three-year buy-and-hold abnormal returns on issuers are significantly correlated with changes in net income during the same period, which is also supportive of the investor overoptimism hypothesis. This research contributes to the literature by providing new evidence from China, a major emerging economy with high growth. We suggest that earnings management could be stimulated by explicit earnings requirement and exacerbated by inve




Credit Rating Changes and Earnings Management


Book Description

We examine whether they engage in income-increasing accruals manipulation (AM) or real activities earnings management (RM) to affect the future rating changes when firm managers have private information about the upcoming credit rating change. Using the large sample of U.S. data over the period of 1990-2011, we find that firms with upcoming credit rating changes are likely to engage in real activities earnings management, whereas they tend to decrease discretionary accruals before credit rating changes. We also find a positive relation between real activities management and credit rating upgrades, but no relation with between real activities management and downgrades. The findings suggest that the firm's management tries to influence the upcoming changes of credit ratings by actively engaging in real activities earnings management rather than accruals-based earnings management.