Dynamic Portfolio Choice with Bayesian Learning


Book Description

This paper examines the importance of parameter uncertainty and learning in the context of dynamic portfolio choice. In a discrete time setting, we consider a Bayesian investor who faces parameter uncertainty and solves her portfolio choice problem while updating her beliefs about the parameters. For different return data generating processes, including i.i.d. returns, autoregressive returns, and exogenous predictability, we show how the investor makes dynamic portfolio choices, taking into account that she will learn from future data. We find that, in general, learning introduces negative horizon effects and that ignoring parameter uncertainty may lead to significant losses in certainty equivalent return on wealth. However, the significance of learning is reduced when the investor uses more past data in her estimation and/or when her risk aversion increases. Learning about unconditional expected returns appears to be the most important aspect of the learning process. Using the earnings-to-price ratio as a predictor and an empirical Bayes prior, we find that learning reduces, but does not necessarily eliminate, the positive hedging demands induced by predictability and correlation between the return and predictor innovations.




Dynamic Bayesian Learning and Optimization in Portfolio Choice Models


Book Description

We develop two dynamic Bayesian portfolio allocation models that address questions of learning and model uncertainty by taking model-specific shortcomings into account. In our first model, we formulate a multi-period portfolio choice problem in which the investor is uncertain about parameters of the model, can learn these parameters over time from observing asset returns, but is also concerned about robustness. To address these concerns, we introduce an objective function which can be regarded as a Bayesian version of relative regret. The optimal portfolio is characterized and shown to involve a ``tilted'' posterior, where the tilting is defined in terms of a family of stochastic benchmarks. We have found this model to perform at least as well as a benchmark given the true market parameters, while outperforming it when the market assets have the same trend. Our next model extends the Black-Litterman portfolio choice model by taking several potential errors into account. We extend Black-Litterman to multiple periods, which allows for us to take into account the pairs of expert forecasts and the realized return. By doing so, we can then perform inference on these experts and discover whether they may have any bias for or against any specific assets. We can also perform similar inference on the market equilibrium distribution, which is typically represented by the capital asset pricing model (CAPM). The result is a model that is analytically intractable but may be solved numerically via Gibbs sampling. Controlled tests show our model performs favorably when Black-Litterman's model assumptions about the market equilibrium and expert views are violated. Backtests shed light on the model's ability to account for CAPM's shortcomings.




Portfolio Choice Problems


Book Description

This brief offers a broad, yet concise, coverage of portfolio choice, containing both application-oriented and academic results, along with abundant pointers to the literature for further study. It cuts through many strands of the subject, presenting not only the classical results from financial economics but also approaches originating from information theory, machine learning and operations research. This compact treatment of the topic will be valuable to students entering the field, as well as practitioners looking for a broad coverage of the topic.




A Simulation Approach to Dynamic Portfolio Choice with an Application to Learning About Return Predictability


Book Description

We present a simulation-based method for solving discrete-time portfolio choice problems involving non-standard preferences, a large number of assets with arbitrary return distribution, and, most importantly, a large number of state variables with potentially path-dependent or non-stationary dynamics. The method is flexible enough to accommodate intermediate consumption, portfolio constraints, parameter and model uncertainty, and learning. We first establish the properties of the method for the portfolio choice between a stock index and cash when the stock returns are either iid or predictable by the dividend yield. We then explore the problem of an investor who takes into account the predictability of returns but is uncertain about the parameters of the data generating process. The investor chooses the portfolio anticipating that future data realizations will contain useful information to learn about the true parameter values.




Sequential Binary Investment Decisions


Book Description

This book describes some models from the theory of investment which are mainly characterized by three features. Firstly, the decision-maker acts in a dynamic environment. Secondly, the distributions of the random variables are only incompletely known at the beginning of the planning process. This is termed as decision-making under conditions of uncer tainty. Thirdly, in large parts of the work we restrict the analysis to binary decision models. In a binary model, the decision-maker must choose one of two actions. For example, one decision means to undertake the invest ·ment project in a planning period, whereas the other decision prescribes to postpone the project for at least one more period. The analysis of dynamic decision models under conditions of uncertainty is not a very common approach in economics. In this framework the op timal decisions are only obtained by the extensive use of methods from operations research and from statistics. It is the intention to narrow some of the existing gaps in the fields of investment and portfolio analysis in this respect. This is done by combining techniques that have been devel oped in investment theory and portfolio selection, in stochastic dynamic programming, and in Bayesian statistics. The latter field indicates the use of Bayes' theorem for the revision of the probability distributions of the random variables over time.




Some Contributions of Bayesian and Computational Learning Methods to Portfolio Selection Problems


Book Description

The present thesis is a study of different optimal portfolio allocation problems in the case where the appreciation rate, named the drift, of the Brownian motion driving the dynamics of the assets is uncertain. We consider an investor having a belief on the drift in the form of a probability distribution, called a prior. The uncertainty about the drift is managed through a Bayesian learning approach which allows for the update of the drift's prior probability distribution. The thesis is divided into two self-contained parts; the first part being split into two chapters: the first develops the theory and the second contains a detailed application to actual market data. A third part constitutes an Appendix and details the data used in the applications. The first part of the thesis is dedicated to the multidimensional Markowitz portfolio selection problem in the case of drift uncertainty. This uncertainty is modeled via an arbitrary prior law which is updated using Bayesian filtering. We first embed the Bayesian-Markowitz problem into an auxiliary standard control problem for which dynamic programming is applied. Then, we show existence and uniqueness of a smooth solution to the related semi-linear partial differential equation (PDE). In the case of a Gaussian prior probability distribution, the multidimensional solution is explicitly computed. Additionally, we study the quantitative impact of learning from the progressively observed data, by comparing the strategy which updates the initial estimate of the drift, i.e. the learning strategy, to the one that keeps it constant, named the non-learning strategy. Ultimately, we analyze the sensitivity of the gain from learning, called value of information or informative value, with respect to different parameters. Next, we illustrate the theory with a detailed application of the previous results on actual market data. We emphasize the robustness of the value added of learning by comparing learning to non-learning optimal strategies in different investment universes: indices of various asset classes, currencies and smart beta strategies. The second part tackles a discrete-time portfolio optimization problem. Here, the goal of the investor is to maximize the expected utility of the terminal wealth of a portfolio of risky assets, assuming an uncertain drift and a maximum drawdown constraint. In this part, we formulate the problem in the general case, and we solve numerically the Gaussian case with the Constant Relative Risk Aversion (CRRA) type utility function via a deep learning resolution. Ultimately, we study the sensitivity of the strategy to the degree of uncertainty of the drift and, as a byproduct, give empirical evidence of the convergence of the non-learning strategy towards a no short-sale constrained Merton problem.










Multiperiod Portfolio Selection and Bayesian Dynamic Models


Book Description

Techniques inspired by Bayesian statistics provide an elegant solution to the classic investment problem of optimally planning a sequence of trades in the presence of transaction costs.




Portfolio Management under Stress


Book Description

Portfolio Management under Stress offers a novel way to apply the well-established Bayesian-net methodology to the important problem of asset allocation under conditions of market distress or, more generally, when an investor believes that a particular scenario (such as the break-up of the Euro) may occur. Employing a coherent and thorough approach, it provides practical guidance on how best to choose an optimal and stable asset allocation in the presence of user specified scenarios or 'stress conditions'. The authors place causal explanations, rather than association-based measures such as correlations, at the core of their argument, and insights from the theory of choice under ambiguity aversion are invoked to obtain stable allocations results. Step-by-step design guidelines are included to allow readers to grasp the full implementation of the approach, and case studies provide clarification. This insightful book is a key resource for practitioners and research academics in the post-financial crisis world.