Investigation of Coupled Axial-lateral-torsional Drillstring Vibrations Using a Multi-body Dynamics Approach


Book Description

Drillstring vibration is a very crucial phenomenon which has a great effect on the drilling process. The drillstring is responsible to transfer rotary motion and energy to the drill bit. Unwanted vibration causes reduction in the rate of penetration (ROP), bit wear and connection failure between drillstring parts. In this thesis, a model of a realistic drill collar is generated which can predict any possible motion of the drill collar. This study contains several analyses about drillstring vibration in three main modes. The focus is on the drill collar section of the drillstring because of the importance of this section in vibration generation of the whole drillstring. This study attempts to determine the vibration behavior of the drill collar in axial, lateral and torsional directions in the presence of vibration-assisted rotary drilling (VARD) and unbalanced rotation. The model includes self weight, hydraulic forces due to drilling mud circulation and most realistic boundary condition for each particular scenario. This model also can be used for coupled vibration states and determination of vibration behavior of the drillstring in three coupled modes, simultaneously. Simulation results show the vibration behavior of the drillstring due to several cases and boundary conditions. The time response to each single mode is expressed and will be validated by finite element method (FEM). The vibration behavior of the rotating drillstring in three coupled modes will be studied using unbalanced rotation of the drillstring. The rock-bit interaction will also be applied to the model. Finally, the effect of the VARD tool will be examined.




Dynamic Analysis of a Drill-string Under Deterministic and Random Excitations


Book Description

Drill-strings are slender structures used to dig into the rock in search of oil and gas. Failures of drill-strings are time and money consuming and therefore the dynamics of drill-strings must be investigated and carefully controlled. In the thesis, a dynamic model of the drill-string that is suitable for predicting axial, torsional and lateral vibrations is built using Euler-Bernoulli beam theory. The drillstring is driven by a DC motor on the top and is subjected to distributed loads due to its own weight as well as bit/formation interaction. The model is axial-torsional, lateral-torsional coupled. Under deterministic excitations, the model captures stickslip behavior in drilling operation. Analysis on its negative effect on drilling performance is made, and potential mitigation measures are also discussed. In random model, the excitations to the drill-bit are modeled as combination of deterministic and random components. Monte Carlo (MC) simulation is employed to obtain the statistics of the response. Two cases of random excitation with different intensities are investigated. The results from MC simulation are compared against that from deterministic case. Secondly, the thesis focuses on the drill-string torsional vibration and its stick-slip analysis. A finite element model of the drillstring with inclusion of both deterministic and random excitations is also developed. Simulation is carried out under certain parameters and it is shown that in deterministic case the torsional vibration may behave stick-slip. With change of some parameters, bifurcation and chaos of the system are observed. In the random case, Monte Carlo simulation and path integration method are used to capture the probabilistic information of the response. The results of path integration match well to those of deterministic cases. Although there are some limitations, this thesis will help the author better understand drill-string downhole behaviors and lay a foundation for further research work.




Modeling and Control of Drillstring Dynamics for Vibration Suppression


Book Description

Drill-string vibrations could cause fatigue failure to downhole tools, bring damage to the wellbore, and decrease drilling efficiency; therefore, it is important to understand the drill-string dynamics through accurately modeling of the drill-string and bottom-hole assembly (BHA) dynamics, and then develop controllers to suppress the vibrations. Modeling drill-string dynamics for directional drilling operation is highly challenging because the drill-string and BHA bend with large curvatures. In addition, the interaction between the drill-string and wellbore wall could occur along the entire well. This fact complicates the boundary condition of modeling of drill-string dynamics. This dissertation presents a finite element method (FEM) model to characterize the dynamics of a directional drill-string. Based on the principle of virtual work, the developed method linearizes the drill-string dynamics around the central axis of a directional well, which significantly reduced the computational cost. In addition, a six DOF curved beam element is derived to model a curved drill-string. It achieves higher accuracy than the widely used straight beam element in both static and dynamic analyses. As a result, fewer curved beam elements are used to achieve the same accuracy, which further reduces the computational cost. During this research, a comprehensive drill-string and wellbore interaction model is developed as the boundary condition to simulate realistic drilling scenarios. Both static and dynamic analyses are carried out using the developed modeling framework. The static simulation can generate drill-string internal force as well as the drilling torque and drag force. The dynamic simulation can provide an insight of the underlying mechanism of drilling vibrations. Top drive controllers are also incorporated as torsional boundary conditions. The guidelines for tuning the control parameters are obtained from dynamic simulations. Drill-string vibrations can be suppressed through BHA configuration optimization. Based on the developed modeling framework, the BHA dynamic performance is evaluated using vibration indices. With an objective to minimize these indices, a genetic algorithm is developed to optimize the BHA stabilizer location for vibration suppression. After optimization, the BHA strain energy and the stabilizer side force, two of the vibration indices, are significantly reduced compared to the original design, which proves the BHA optimization method can lead to a significant reduction of undesirable drilling dynamics. At the end of this dissertation, reduced order models are also discussed for fast simulation and control design for real time operation




Analysis of Downhole Drilling Vibrations


Book Description

Downhole vibrations lead to downhole failures and decrease the rate of penetration (ROP). The bottom hole assembly (BHA) static and dynamic design is a key factor in optimizing drilling operations. The BHA should be designed to minimize the vibration levels in the axial, lateral, and torsional directions. This would be achieved by avoiding rotating the drillstring in the speeds that are nearby the natural frequency of BHA. The complexity associated with current BHA components requires using advanced computational tools that are capable of solving complex and time-consuming equations. Finite Element Analysis (FEA) is the most used technique in analyzing vibration behavior of the drillstring by mesh discretizing of a continuous body into small elements. This thesis will study the dynamic behavior of different BHA designs for Manifa and Karan fields of Saudi Aramco to optimize the drilling operations. The FEA software that will be used to conduct these studies is called Vibrascope, which was developed by NOV. The software will determine the critical speeds of the drillstring that should be avoided to prevent resonance of the BHA, which will lead to severe downhole vibration.










Numerical and Field Data Analysis of Drill Stem Vibration


Book Description

"Drill stem vibration is a major cause of premature failure of drill stem components and drilling inefficiency. In severe cases, drill stem vibration may lead to wellbore instability that could lead to increased operational cost. Drill stem vibrations are affected by design decisions and the drilling environment. Examples are; bottom hole assembly configurations, selection of operational parameters, and frequent changes in lithology. Vibration modeling, analysis of vibration data, and specialized vibration reduction tools are methods in use to prevent and mitigate severe vibrations. A drill stem vibration model was created using nonlinear strain formulation which couples the axial, lateral and torsional vibration of the entire drill stem. The model includes the effect of geometric stiffening arising from the applied axial load, two new developed vibration reduction tools used to reduce drill stem vibrations and fluid flow inside and outside the drill stem taking into account two different fluid rheological models. The obtained equation of motion was assembled using the finite element analysis which was solved numerically in Matlab®. The sensitivity analysis using Euler-Bernoulli and Timoshenko models, showed that the Euler-Bernoulli assumption is satisfactory when modeling drill stem vibrations at typical drilling conditions. Analyzing three adjacent wells in the North Sea with different bottom hole assembly and recorded vibration data, revealed that including drill stem vibration reduction tools reduces drill stem vibration and decreases stick-slip tendency. Including drilling fluid circulation, by imposing dynamic pressures on the inside and outside of the drill stem, affect lateral natural frequencies. High flow rate and wrong selection of total flow area at the drill bit could lead to vibrations"--Abstract, page iii.