Environmental Drivers of Habitat Use by Bigheaded Carps to Inform Harvest in the Starved Rock Pool of the Illinois River


Book Description

Lateral habitats provide a multitude of benefits to riverine fishes, including invasive Silver Carp (Hypophthalmicthys molitrix) and Bighead Carp (H. nobilis), hereafter bigheaded carp. Harvesters have focused removal efforts in lateral habitats (e.g., backwaters and side channels); however, little research has examined the lateral habitat use of bighead carps. The Starved Rock Pool (SRP) is the downstream most pool in the upper Illinois River where contracted commercial fishermen target bigheaded carp to reduce dispersal pressure towards the Laurentian Great Lakes. To examine bigheaded carps' movement between the main channel and lateral habitats in SRP, fish were implanted with transmitters and tracked using acoustic telemetry. The ranges and detection probabilities of acoustic telemetry receivers have typically been modelled and examined in with linear distance tools. To derive more realistic receiver ranges and detection probabilities, this study used minimum bounding geometry on detected transmissions obtained from boat-mounted transmitters. Receiver detection ranges estimated using minimum bounding geometry were smaller than those estimated using the linear distance method, but estimated detection probabilities within receiver ranges were higher using the minimum bounding method compared to the linear distance method. Detection histories of bigheaded carp implanted with transmitters were examined to assess fish habitat use from June 2016 to April 2018. During 2017, multiple environmental variables (temperature, river discharge, chlorophyll a, dissolved oxygen, total dissolved solids, and turbidity) were measured weekly and zooplankton samples were collected during June and August to assess potential associations between environmental variables and bigheaded carp habitat use that might be useful for informing locations and times for focusing contracted harvest of bigheaded carps. Habitat selection was also examined using a resource selection index (W) and a mark-recapture multistate model in program MARK. Across all seasons, bigheaded carp used lateral habitats more frequently than main channel habitats. Habitat use was strongly influenced by temperature and marginally by main channel discharge. No strong associations between zooplankton and bigheaded carp habitat use were observed during this study; however, there were some differences in zooplankton community structure and abundance among lateral habitats related to rotifers that may have potentially been related to use of specific lateral habitats by bigheaded carp. While having high return percentages to all lateral habitats, bigheaded carp disproportionately selected for a few individual habitats, possibly due to those habitats being locations where tagging was conducted. Harvest efforts in lateral habitats, especially prior to spawning (spring staging), during lower temperature periods (overwintering), and during higher discharges should be most effective because of bigheaded carps' particularly high use of lateral habitats during these times. Recurring removal efforts in lateral habitats within SRP may facilitate targeting of individuals that frequently return to these lateral habitats and may also reduce bigheaded carp abundance in nearby locations.




Invasive Carp Movement, Behavior, and Habitat Use


Book Description

Invasive species are a major concern for fish populations globally, and the ability to predict the susceptibility of ecosystems to additional invasions or range expansions is needed. Bigheaded carp [Silver Carp (Hypophthalmichthys moltrix) and Bighead Carp (H. nobilis)] pose a serious threat to the Great Lakes Basin and numerous other aquatic ecosystems, where suitable habitat for spawning could allow for the establishment of breeding populations. Evaluating a surrogate would be useful to predict how bigheaded carp behave beyond their current range. To determine whether Common Carp (Cyprinus carpio) is an appropriate surrogate for bigheaded carp, their potential overlap in diets, habitat selection, and behavior must be considered. Fifty-seven adult Common Carp and 7 adult bigheaded carp were acoustically tagged in the Starved Rock Pool on the Illinois River in April 2019. Active tracking occurred monthly during the summer (June-October) of 2019 and 2020, as well as with an array of passive receivers in the Illinois River. Common Carp serve as a viable surrogate for bigheaded carp in dam passage, habitat selection during summer (avoidance of main channel, and channel border while selecting for side channel habitats), and movement probability (significance for both species for weekly average discharge). However, these results should be used with caution when predicting range size (larger core ranges for Common Carp, larger total ranges for bighead carp) and movement (different environmental variables influence movement). Because bigheaded carp are likely to spread much farther and faster than common carp, a more migratory surrogate should be explored such as Paddlefish (Polyodon spathula) or Blue Sucker (Cycleptus elongatus).




Effects of Harvest on Bigheaded Carp Populations


Book Description

1st Chapter: Controlling invasive fishes is a pressing issue in fisheries management. Commercial harvest and bounty programs are often used as a control method to reduce abundance and lessen the destructive impacts of an invasive species. One group of species that may be controlled with harvest are invasive carps [Black Carp (Mylopharyngodon piceus), Grass Carp (Ctenopharyngodon idella), Bighead Carp (Hypophthalmichthys nobilis) and Silver Carp (H. molitrix)]. To reduce source populations and propagule pressure of invasive carps near the Laurentian Great Lakes, an enhanced contract commercial fishing program was started on the Peoria Pool of the Illinois River in September 2019. Commercial fishers received compensation of $0.10 for every pound of invasive carps caught in the Peoria Pool of the Illinois River on top of the price they were paid at the fish processing plant. My thesis used mobile hydroacoustic sampling to evaluate the effects of the enhanced contract fishing program by evaluating changes in invasive carp densities, biomass, and size structure from February 2020 to August 2021. The enhanced contract fishing program did increase fishing effort in the Peoria Pool of the Illinois River, which in turn increased harvest from 1,284,931 kgs of invasive carp in 2020 to 1,515,575 kgs of invasive carp in 2021. The average of hydroacoustic densities was 1.19 kgs/1000m3 and there was not a significant change throughout the duration of the project. It will be important to continue evaluating the enhanced contract fishing program as commercial fishing programs can take years to have effects. This study serves as a unique case study for future management by allowing us to assess how bigheaded carp abundances change due to commercial fishing pressure. 2nd Chapter: Understanding the effects and having accurate estimates of demographic rates of an invasive species is important for management. Commercial harvest/removal is a common method of invasive species management. Quantifying mortality rates can be useful in informing population models for future management decisions for Silver Carp removal efforts. The objective of this study was to compare Silver Carp total annual mortality between the Wabash and Illinois Rivers, where additive mortality due to fishing and other factors likely differs. With the necessity of increasing additive mortality to bring down populations, these estimates are important to more accurately parameterize future control models as well as to differentiate between rivers with different management methods and other sources of mortality. For this study, survival and detection probabilities were determined in Program MARK using a Cormack-Jolly-Seber Models of acoustically tagged Silver Carp over 8 years and were compared between the upper and lower Illinois River and the Wabash River. The survival estimate for Silver Carp in the Wabash River (0.97±0.02) was higher than those in the Illinois River (0.22±0.14 to 0.77±0.07). Harvest and perhaps commercial barge traffic are leading to higher mortality in the Illinois River as there was much higher harvest and mortality in the Illinois River than there was in the Wabash River. Higher overall mortality in the Illinois River appears to be affecting densities differently in the upper and lower river due to the differing harvest strategies in these stretches of river. Previous estimates of annual mortality for the Illinois River were similar to our estimates. The Wabash River Silver Carp mortality was much lower than previous published estimates. This study serves as a unique method for evaluating the impacts of large-scale removal efforts and may also be useful in informing the Spatially Explicit Invasive Carp Population (SEICarP) modeling effort on how best to develop future management actions and harvest efforts.







Habitat Selection and Movement of Bighead Carp and Silver Carp in the Lower Illinois River


Book Description

To predict the impact and potential spread of introduced exotic species, we must be able to quantify their dispersal capabilities and habitat requirements. Asian carp have become an increasing nuisance in recent years in the Illinois River, a tributary of the Mississippi River, potentially competing with native species. I implanted fifty silver carp and fifty bighead carp with ultrasonic transmitters during 2004 to quantify their macrohabitat use and their rate and extent of movement in the lower Illinois River (Rkm 130 to Rkm 0) during 2004 and 2005. Movement between Rkm 115 to Rkm 3 was continuously monitored with stationary receivers (N=9), and supplemented with intensive mobile tracking during the spawning season. Movement was associated with the rise and fall of river stage during the spawning season of both years. Mean km/day for bighead carp and silver carp was quantified for both species (bighead carp 6.8 km/day, silver carp 10.6 km/day), demonstrating that these species disperse widely. Available habitat was quantified to determine selection, and discriminant function analysis was used to describe microhabitat changes within macrohabitats between years. Both species preferred channel borders during low water periods, and island side channels during low and high water years. Both species were rarely found in water > 4 m, and avoided main channel habitat during low water. Bighead and silver carp also selected for specific abiotic factors within macrohabitat types during low and high water years, with silver carp showing more sensitivity to abiotic factors than bighead carp. Identifying habitat areas that both species prefer will facilitate management plans to target them for harvest, and determining characteristics of these preferred habitats will aid in predicting future establishment.




Application and Evaluation of Mobile Hydroacoustic Sampling to Inform Management of Bigheaded Carps Near the Invasion Front in the Upper Illinois Waterway


Book Description

Informing monitoring and surveillance efforts for invasive species is crucial for effective management to minimize negative ecological, economic, and social impacts. Management responses to the invasion of silver carp (Hypophthalmichthys molitrix) and bighead carp (H. nobilis)--collectively termed bigheaded carps--in the upper Illinois waterway involve removal efforts to maintain low abundance near the invasion front and surveillance to detect any spread farther upriver. However, the efficiency and effectiveness of these efforts may be limited by the low abundance and patchy distributions of bigheaded carps near the invasion front, as well as the spatial scope of the gears used to sample them. My thesis applied mobile hydroacoustic sampling to understand the factors influencing the distributions of silver carp near the invasion front in the upper Illinois waterway, and factors influencing the observability and detectability of fishes with this gear. These results will be useful to inform removal and surveillance efforts in the upper Illinois waterway and reduce the risk of further upstream invasion into the Great Lakes. To assess factors influencing abundance, bi-monthly (March - October) mobile hydroacoustic sampling was conducted from 2017-2018 and paired with continuous environmental variable data collection in the Dresden Island and Marseilles pools, the upper two invaded pools of the Illinois waterway. Environmental variables collected were water temperature, dissolved oxygen, total dissolved solids, turbidity, chlorophyll-a concentration, blue-green algae concentration, and depth. Logistic and multiple regressions were performed within pool during each sampling period to describe factors associated with silver carp presence, and factors associated with their densities in areas where they were present. Silver carp densities fluctuated across space and time, suggesting environmental variables influenced distributions. Depth was the most consistent predictor of silver carp presence and density, with shallower depths associated with higher abundance. Specifically, in summer months, areas in large backwater habitats with lower temperature, higher dissolved oxygen, and higher chlorophyll-a concentration tended to hold more silver carp. These results suggest removal efforts should be focused on shallower depths within sites, and should target areas in backwaters with lower water temperature, higher dissolved oxygen, and higher chlorophyll-a concentrations during summer months. To inform bigheaded carp surveillance efforts upstream of the invasion front, the influence of factors of vessel speed, wind speed, and beam compensation on the observability (the proportion of the true abundance of fish that fall within the acoustic beam) and detectability (the proportion of observable fish that are detected) of fishes in large rivers with mobile horizontal hydroacoustic sampling was also evaluated. To accomplish this, 23 sets of paired trawl floats (buoys) were deployed in a 2.1 km stretch of the Dresden Island Pool, and four sets of replicate hydroacoustic surveys were conducted past them at three vessel speeds. Mean wind speed during each survey was obtained, and proportion of buoys observed and detected were quantified under two different maximum beam compensation values (6 dB and 12 dB). Results revealed significant interactions between vessel speed and wind speed, with observability increasing with wind speed at slow and fast vessel speeds, but decreasing at intermediate vessel speeds. Detectability decreased with greater wind speed across all vessel speeds, with more pronounced effects at slower vessel speeds. Significant positive effects of beam compensation occurred for both observability and detectability. These results suggest, to improve detection of bigheaded carps, sampling should be focused on calm days under moderate vessel speeds when analyzing with standard beam compensation values. Broadening beam compensation was shown to increase observability and detectability, but needs further investigation. Ultimately, these studies provide valuable information to assist management efforts to control bigheaded carps near the invasion front in the upper Illinois waterway, and detect any individuals that may spread farther upriver towards the Great Lakes.




Evaluation of Upstream Passage and Associated Movement Patterns of Adult Bigheaded Carp (Hypophthalmichthys Nobilis and H. Molitrix) at a Gated Dam on the Illinois River


Book Description

Invasive bighead carp (Hypophthalmichthys nobilis) and silver carp (H. molitrix), hereafter, bigheaded carp, pose a major threat to the Great Lakes ecosystem as they advance toward Lake Michigan via the Illinois River. However, a series of navigation dams may deter their upstream movement. Starved Rock Lock and Dam (SRLD) is the most downstream gated dam on the Illinois River, therefore presenting the first navigation challenge for upstream migrating bigheaded carp. Before 2015, five acoustic receivers near SRLD detected successful upstream passage of only two of 900 tagged bigheaded carp. I further investigated the permeability of SRLD to bigheaded carp migration as a function of temperature, gage height, and dam operation. In 2015, I added 12 receivers around SRLD and acoustically tagged an additional 118 bigheaded carp downstream of SRLD. I also investigated the timing of bigheaded carp arriving downstream of SRLD using a generalized linear model. The explanatory variables influencing bigheaded carp arrival were average water temperature, average tailwater elevation, and the change in average water temperature. During 2015-2016, acoustic receivers recorded a total of 11 upstream passage events through SRLD, with nine through the dam gates, one through the lock chamber, and one undetermined. Passage through the dam gates occurred most frequently at high water levels when the dam gates were completely out of the water. The probability of upstream migrating bigheaded carp approaching SRLD was positively correlated with rising temperature and high gage. No upstream migrants approached SRLD between mid-September and late March. Overall, dam gates were more susceptible to upstream passage than the lock chamber, and environmental factors accurately predicted the arrival of bigheaded carp at SRLD. Modifying gate use during times of bigheaded carp arrival will likely prevent upstream passage through SRLD and other lock and dam structures.




Invasive Asian Carps in North America


Book Description

"Proceedings of the Symposium, 'Invasive Asian Carps in North America: a Forum to Understand the Biology and Manage the Problem,' held in Peoria, Illinois, USA, August 22-23, 2006




Freshwater Fish Distribution


Book Description

This book clearly identifies nearly 170 families of fishes through the use of high-quality illustrations and includes an accurate account of selected members of that particular fish family, as well as a distribution map and accompanying commentary on classification, distribution, and diversity. Key Features* High-quality illustrations of representatives from each family* Distribution map provided for each family* Commentary for each family




The Great Lakes Water Wars


Book Description

The Great Lakes are the largest collection of fresh surface water on earth, and more than 40 million Americans and Canadians live in their basin. Will we divert water from the Great Lakes, causing them to end up like Central Asia's Aral Sea, which has lost 90 percent of its surface area and 75 percent of its volume since 1960? Or will we come to see that unregulated water withdrawals are ultimately catastrophic? Peter Annin writes a fast-paced account of the people and stories behind these upcoming battles. Destined to be the definitive story for the general public as well as policymakers, The Great Lakes Water Wars is a balanced, comprehensive look behind the scenes at the conflicts and compromises that are the past-and future-of this unique resource.