Experienced Pastoral Burnout and the Self-reported Role of Emotional Intelligence on Leadership Effectiveness During Burnout


Book Description

Emotional intelligence (EI), employee burnout, and effective leadership traits are constructs that have been researched from a traditional, organizational perspective since the 1970s. Over the past 15 years, pastoral leaders and clergy have been identified as leaders working in the same capacity as public safety officials, medical professionals, mental health specialists, and other helping professions. Research suggests that leaders working in helping professions are often exposed to situations that may induce burnout, create emotional dissonance, and may have adverse implications on effective leadership behaviors during experienced burnout. The significance of this study lies in its identification of a gap in the literature that investigates the self-reported causations of pastoral burnout and the roles of self-reported emotional intelligence on effective leadership behaviors during burnout. Therefore, this phenomenological study explores the self-reported factors that contribute to levels of pastoral burnout and the self-reported role of emotional intelligence on pastoral leadership effectiveness during experienced burnout among 12 senior-level pastors who lead in non-denominational churches with 50-500 congregants in the Southeastern region of the United States. The study was conducted using a phenomenological qualitative research design. The participants were interviewed face-to-face. The interviews were uploaded into the NVivo data analysis program where the participants’ statements were transcribed to identify themes and patterns that satisfied theoretical saturation. The constructs of this study were founded on theological and theoretical frameworks that supported the research and interview questions that guided this study.




Resilient Ministry


Book Description

Why does one well-equipped, well-meaning person in ministry succeed while another fails? Bob Burns, Tasha Chapman and Donald Guthrie undertook a five-year intensive research project on the frontlines of pastoral ministry to answer that question. What they found was nothing less than the DNA of thriving ministry today.




Methodist Pastoral Retention


Book Description

This study targeted pastoral burnout symptomology and its relationship to self-perceived leadership attributes. Pastors experience a professional environment that call for ministering to their congregation's spiritual needs; however, additional social and business responsibilities often exist for which the pastor is poorly trained or improperly supported. These situations may cause high levels of stress and anxiety, challenging a pastor's self-perception of their leadership attributes. Eventually, this condition could promote the onset of burnout, which might compel the pastor to leave the ministry. As such, this research sought to establish whether a relationship exists between self-perceived leadership attributes and ministerial burnout for licensed, ordained, or lay clergy (n = 100) serving a congregation of 250 or fewer individuals in the Florida, North Georgia, South Georgia, and Alabama - West Florida Conferences of the United or Global Methodist Church. The design used in this study was a quantitative correlational approach, which determined the degree of relationship between self-perceived leadership attributes and burnout symptomology. The independent variable was self-perceived leadership attributes, measured across five clusters (Drive, Organization, Trust, Interpersonal, and Tolerance) utilizing the Leader Attributes Inventory. The dependent variable was burnout symptomology, measured across three dimensions (emotional exhaustion, depersonalization, and satisfaction in ministry) employing the Francis Burnout Inventory. The Spearman Rho Correlation Coefficient and Ordinal Regression comprised the IBM-SPSS data analysis. The results indicate a weak, yet statistically significant relationship exists between self-perceived leadership attributes and reported levels of burnout.




Caring for Our Shepherds


Book Description

Pastors play a fundamental role in churches across the globe, yet more and more are finding themselves struggling with the stress of ministry life and experiencing burnout. The consequences of pastoral burnout can be severe and impact not only individuals’ physical, mental, and emotional well-being, but spillover to their families and congregations as well. Despite this increasingly common problem, the subject of pastors and their unique experiences has not been well studied. Caring for our Shepherds is written to pastors and for pastors. In this book, researchers on pastoral burnout, Thomas V. Frederick, Yvonne Thai, and Scott Dunbar answer the questions: what is pastoral or ministry burnout, how can it be guarded against, and how can we help those experiencing it? The reader will not only develop a deeper understanding for the demands of ministry, but also be provided with specific practical and spiritual frameworks to cope with those demands in ways that promote a positive and healthy mindset. Caring for our Shepherds is an excellent resource not only for those in ministry, but to those who desire to pour back into those who serve in the church.




Leading Through Burnout: the Influence of Emotional Intelligence on the Ability of Executive Level Physician Leaders to Cope with Occupational Stress and Burnout


Book Description

Physician leadership has been endorsed as a critical component of successful healthcare transformation, and emerging evidence suggests that physician leaders offer a competitive advantage to their organizations. Healthcare executive level leadership roles are inherently stressful, and the transition from a clinical environment to an executive level administrative environment generates unique pressures and challenges for physician leaders that non-physician leaders may not experience. When proper coping skills are not present, occupational stress can have a negative impact on a physician leader’s ability to lead effectively and may impact their emotional and physical wellbeing. This mixed methods study explored the perceptions of 35 Chief Medical Officers (CMOs) regarding their experiences with occupational stress and the influence of emotional intelligence (EI) on their ability to cope with the demands and pressures of their role. The primary method of data collection focused on in-depth interviews, and the interviews were supported with quantitative data using the Maslach Burnout Inventory (MBI) to measure CMOs’ perceived level of stress, emotional exhaustion, cynicism, and professional efficacy. Qualitative data was analyzed using an inductive thematic analysis process as well as a deductive thematic analysis process using the Emotional and Social Competency Inventory (ESCI) model to code the data. Three key findings emerged from this study: 1) EI competencies serve as an effective personal resource that contributes to a CMO’s ability to deal with work-related stress and prevent burnout; 2) CMOs are experiencing high levels of stress, but it is not leading to burnout; and 3) self-efficacy serves as an effective personal resource that contributes to a CMO’s ability to deal with work-related stress and prevent burnout. This study offers an increased awareness of the sources of CMOs’ stress and contributes to an understanding of how emotional intelligence competencies and self-efficacy serve as effective personal resources in the stress appraisal and coping processes. Keywords: stress, occupational stress, coping, burnout, emotional intelligence.




The Resilient Leader


Book Description

Are you experiencing feeling overwhelmed and exhausted in your role as a Pastor, Minister, Chaplain, or leader in the church or marketplace? Do you sometimes worry that you may be on the road to burnout? Have you wondered whether leadership can be sustainable and enjoyable? Social worker, Pastor, author and speaker Dr Amanda Nickson shares insights and examples from her own life of resilience through challenging times to being able to teach others skills in sustainable leadership. Having experienced both compassion fatigue to the point of burnout and compassion satisfaction, Amanda is well placed to share helpful insights into how to build sustainable and balanced lives. Drawing on her experiences as a leader and professional supervisor for Pastors, Chaplains and human services workers, Amanda has a well-grounded perspective on the way forward for empowering existing and emerging leaders. Living as a Christian for over 40 years, Amanda has witnessed numerous pastors and leaders leave their roles due to burnout. She shares how to beat overwhelm and burnout with achievable, sustainable leadership. Are you ready now to make some changes for a sustainable life as a leader? Amanda's passion to equip others to live life to the full is evident through her books, her conversations, and her own remarkable resilience. I met Amanda through our joint interest in supervision, both passionate about walking alongside others, empowering people to connect to their calling, to living authentically and to have confidential, non-judgemental support. I would describe Amanda as someone who has a solid faith and someone you can really rely on. It's out of this steadfastness along with her vast experience and qualifications, that she can share with others how to build resilience. Susan Marcuccio, National Supervision Director, Chaplaincy Australia and Supervisor, Perspective Supervision







Burnout in Ministry


Book Description




Emotional Intelligence for Religious Leaders


Book Description

Religious leaders require tremendous skill in emotional intelligence, yet their training very rarely addresses how to develop the practical skills needed—from self-awareness to resilience. Emotional Intelligence Religious Leaders draws on the latest research in business, psychology, and theology to offer religious leaders the information and tools they need to increase their emotional intelligence and enhance their relationships, communication and conflict management skills, spirituality, and overall well-being. The book offers both a deep understanding of how to develop emotional intelligence and also prescriptive insights about how to practice it that will be helpful for religious leaders in many settings, including congregational ministry, lay ministry, spiritual direction, pastoral counseling, and more.




An Examination of how Emotional Intelligence in Pastoral Ministry Correlates with Job Satisfaction and Burnout


Book Description

This dissertation in practice examines the relationship between emotional intelligence in pastoral ministry and job satisfaction, and pastoral ministry in burnout to discover if there is a correlation between the emotional intelligence of a pastor and their perceived job satisfaction, as well as to discover if there is a correlation between emotional intelligence of a pastor and their perceived burnouit.