Leveraging Connected Vehicles to Enhance Traffic Responsive Traffic Signal Control


Book Description

For traffic signal control, Time of Day (TOD) mode of operations is widely deployed in practice for selecting a signal timing plan. However, TOD mode in not effective in adapting to variations in traffic conditions, such as special events and holidays, incidents, etc. Several research studies have reported the potential of Traffic Responsive Control operation or Traffic Responsive Plan Selection (TRPS) in reducing delays and the number of stops. For successful implementation of TRPS, accurate traffic state estimation is essential. The current study in this direction investigates a methodology for traffic state estimation for a corridor in Morgantown, WV, by using system detector data and connected vehicles (CV) data. Data from CVs form the basis to estimate queue lengths at signalized intersection approaches. While using data from multiple sources, a single measure in terms of three plan selection parameter was obtained, based on which discriminant functions were developed to classify the observations into states. Based on kmeans clustering, similar traffic states were grouped together and a new set of states were suggested in place of the original states for which up to 93% classification accuracy was obtained. Overall, it was demonstrated that queue length data can be a valuable source of information for traffic state estimation that is needed for implementing the TRPS framework.




Enhanced Traffic Signal Operation Using Connected Vehicle Data


Book Description

As traffic on urban road network increases, congestion and delays are becoming more severe. At grade intersections form capacity bottlenecks in urban road networks because at these locations, capacity must be shared by competing traffic movements. Traffic signals are the most common method by which the right of way is dynamically allocated to conflicting movements. A range of traffic signal control strategies exist including fixed time control, actuated control, and adaptive traffic signal control (ATSC). ATSC relies on traffic sensors to estimate inputs such as traffic demands, queue lengths, etc. and then dynamically adjusts signal timings with the objective to minimize delays and stops at the intersection. Despite, the advantages of these ATSC systems, one of the barriers limiting greater use of these systems is the large number of traffic sensors required to provide the essential information for their signal timing optimization methodologies. A recently introduced technology called connected vehicles will make vehicles capable of providing detailed information such as their position, speed, acceleration rate, etc. in real-time using a wireless technology. The deployment of connected vehicle technology would provide the opportunity to introduce new traffic control strategies or to enhance the existing one. Some work has been done to-date to develop new ATSC systems on the basis of the data provided by connected vehicles which are mainly designed on the assumption that all vehicles on the network are equipped with the connected vehicle technology. The goals of such systems are to: 1) provide better performance at signalized intersections using enhanced algorithms based on richer data provided by the connected vehicles; and 2) reduce (or eliminate) the need for fixed point detectors/sensors in order to reduce deployment and maintenance costs. However, no work has been done to investigate how connected vehicle data can improve the performance of ATSC systems that are currently deployed and that operate using data from traditional detectors. Moreover, achieving a 100% market penetration of connected vehicles may take more than 30 years (even if the technology is mandated on new vehicles). Therefore, it is necessary to provide a solution that is capable of improving the performance of signalized intersections during this transition period using connected vehicle data even at low market penetration rates. This research examines the use of connected vehicle data as the only data source at different market penetration rates aiming to provide the required inputs for conventional adaptive signal control systems. The thesis proposes various methodologies to: 1) estimate queues at signalized intersections; 2) dynamically estimate the saturation flow rate required for optimizing the timings of traffic signals at intersections; and 3) estimate the free flow speed on arterials for the purpose of optimizing offsets between traffic signals. This thesis has resulted in the following findings: 1. Connected vehicle data can be used to estimate the queue length at signalized intersections especially for the purpose of estimating the saturation flow rate. The vehicles' length information provided by connected vehicles can be used to enhance the queue estimation when the traffic composition changes on a network. 2. The proposed methodology for estimating the saturation flow rate is able to estimate temporally varying saturation flow rates in response to changing network conditions, including lane blockages and queue spillback that limit discharge rates, and do so with an acceptable range of errors even at low level of market penetration of connected vehicles. The evaluation of the method for a range of traffic Level of Service (LOS) shows that the maximum observed mean absolute relative error (6.2%) occurs at LOS F and when only 10% of vehicles in the traffic stream are connected vehicles. 3. The proposed method for estimating the Free Flow Speed (FFS) on arterial roads can provide estimations close to the known ground truth and can respond to changes in the FFS. The results also show that the maximum absolute error of approximately 4.7 km/h in the estimated FFS was observed at 10% market penetration rate of connected vehicles. 4. The results of an evaluation of an adaptive signal control system based on connected vehicle data in a microsimulation environment show that the adaptive signal control system is able to adjust timings of signals at intersections in response to changes in the saturation flow rate and free flow speed estimated from connected vehicle data using the proposed methodologies. The comparison of the adaptive signal control system against a fixed time control at 20% and 100% CV market penetration rates shows improvements in average vehicular delay and average number of stops at both market penetration rates and though improvements are larger for 100% CV LMP, approximately 70% of these improvements are achieved at 20% CV LMP.




Traffic Signal Control at Connected Vehicle Equipped Intersections


Book Description

The dissertation presents a connected vehicle based traffic signal control model (CVTSCM) for signalized arterials. The model addresses different levels of traffic congestion starting with the initial deployment of connected vehicle technologies focusing on two modules created in CVTSCM. For near/under-saturated intersections, an arterial-level traffic progression optimization model (ALTPOM) is being proposed. ALTPOM improves traffic progression by optimizing offsets for an entire signalized arterial simultaneously. To optimize these offsets, splits of coordinated intersections are first adjusted to balance predicted upcoming demands of all approaches at individual intersections. An open source traffic simulator was selected to implement and evaluate the performance of ALTPOM. The case studies’ field signal timing plans were coordinated and optimized using TRANSYT-7F as the benchmark. ALTPOM was implemented with connected vehicles penetration rates at 25% and 50%, ALTPOM significantly outperforms TRANSYT-7F with at least 26.0% reduction of control delay (sec/vehicle) and a 4.4% increase of throughput for both directions of major and minor streets. This technique differs from traditional traffic coordination which prioritizes major street traffic, and thereby generally results in degrading performance on minor streets. ALTPOM also provides smooth traffic progression for the coordinated direction with little impact on the opposite direction. The performance of ALTPOM improves as the penetration rate of connected vehicles increases. For saturated/oversaturated conditions, two queue length management based Active Traffic Management (ATM) strategies are proposed, analytically investigated, and experimentally validated. The first strategy distributes as much green time as possible for approaches with higher saturation discharge rate in order to reduce delay. For the second approach, green times are allocated to balance queue lengths of major and minor streets preventing queue spillback or gridlock. Both strategies were formulated initially using uniform arrival and departure, and then validated using field vehicle trajectory data. After validation of the modules, the effectiveness of CVTSCM is proven. Then, conclusions and recommendations for future researches are presented at the end.




Traffic Signal Control in a Connected and Autonomous Vehicle Environment Considering Pedestrians


Book Description

Traffic signals help to maintain order in urban traffic networks and reduce vehicle conflicts by dynamically assigning right-of-way to different vehicle movements. However, by temporarily stopping vehicle movements at regular intervals, traffic signals are a major source of urban congestion and cause increased vehicle delay, fuel consumption, and environmental pollution. Connected and Autonomous Vehicle technology may be utilized to optimize traffic operations at signalized intersections, since connected vehicles have the ability to communicate with the surrounding infrastructure and autonomous vehicles can follow the instructions from the signal or a central control system. Connected vehicle information received by a signal controller can be used to help adjust signal timings to tailor to the specific dynamic vehicle demand. Information about the signal timing plan can then be communicated back to the vehicles so that they can adjust their speeds/trajectories to further improve traffic operations. Based on a thorough literature review of existing studies in the area of signal control utilizing information from connected and autonomous vehicles, three research gaps are found: 1) application are limited to unrealistic intersection configurations; 2) methods are limited to a single mode; or, 3) methods only optimize the average value of measure of effectiveness while ignoring the distribution among vehicles. As a part of this dissertation, several methods will be proposed to increase computational efficiency of an existing CAV-based joint signal timing and vehicle trajectory optimization algorithm so that it can be applied to more realistic intersection settings without adding computational burden. Doing so requires the creation of new methods to accommodate features like multiple lanes on each approach, more than two approaches and turning maneuvers. Methods to incorporate human-driven cooperative vehicles and pedestrians are also proposed and tested. A more equitable traffic signal control method is also designed.




Leveraging Vehicle-to-infrastructure Communications for Adaptive Traffic Signaling and Better Energy Utilization


Book Description

Abstract: According to a recent report by the US Treasury Department, America wastes $8 billion annually in energy costs because of traffic congestion. Adding the cost of lost time, the damage is said to reach around $100 billion. Moreover, high energy consumption adds to air pollution and contributes to the global warming problem. Infrastructure where different entities (cars and traffic signals) can communicate with each other offers the potential for reducing this waste. But by how much? Suppose full information about location, velocity, and acceleration of each vehicle were available for all vehicles in the vicinity of an isolated traffic signal. Could an intelligent traffic signal predict and adjust to the best possible traffic light cycle times to minimize fuel loss per vehicle? If light timing were changed dynamically based on real-time information from new traffic arrivals after a small interval of time, how much lower fuel loss could be achieved than by basing timing on macro-level metrics such as flow rates and limited vehicle information such as that provided by in-pavement loop detectors? Answering these questions involves developing a simulation framework that is based on an understanding of typical yet safe vehicle operation (by human drivers or autonomous vehicles) and of various traffic arrival patterns, as well as the ability to estimate fuel loss (and/or other optimization objectives) in many different situations.




Network Wide Signal Control Strategy Base on Connected Vehicle Technology


Book Description

This dissertation discusses network wide signal control strategies base on connected vehicle technology. Traffic congestion on arterials has become one of the largest threats to economic competitiveness, livability, safety, and long-term environmental sustainability in the United States. In addition, arterials usually experience more blockage than freeways, specifically in terms of intersection congestion. There is no doubt that emerging technologies provide unequaled opportunities to revolutionize “retiming” and mitigate traffic congestion. Connected vehicle technology provides unparalleled safety benefits and holds promise in terms of alleviating both traffic congestion and the environmental impacts of future transportation systems. The objective of this research is to improve the mobility, safety and environmental effects at signalized arterials with connected vehicles. The proposed solution of this dissertation is to formulate traffic signal control models for signalized arterials based on connected vehicle technology. The models optimize offset, split, and cycle length to minimize total queue delay in all directions of coordinated intersections. Then, the models are implemented in a centralized system—including closed-loop systems—first, before expanding the results to distributed systems. The benefits of the models are realized at the infant stage of connected vehicle deployment when the penetration rate of connected vehicles is around 10%. Furthermore, the benefits incentivize the growth of the penetration rate for drivers. In addition, this dissertation contains a performance evaluation in traffic delay, volume throughput, fuel consumption, emission, and safety by providing a case study of coordinated signalized intersections. The case study results show the solution of this dissertation could adapt early deployment of connected vehicle technology and apply to future connected vehicle technology development.




ITS Sensors and Architectures for Traffic Management and Connected Vehicles


Book Description

An intelligent transportation system (ITS) offers considerable opportunities for increasing the safety, efficiency, and predictability of traffic flow and reducing vehicle emissions. Sensors (or detectors) enable the effective gathering of arterial and controlled-access highway information in support of automatic incident detection, active transportation and demand management, traffic-adaptive signal control, and ramp and freeway metering and dispatching of emergency response providers. As traffic flow sensors are integrated with big data sources such as connected and cooperative vehicles, and cell phones and other Bluetooth-enabled devices, more accurate and timely traffic flow information can be obtained. The book examines the roles of traffic management centers that serve cities, counties, and other regions, and the collocation issues that ensue when multiple agencies share the same space. It describes sensor applications and data requirements for several ITS strategies; sensor technologies; sensor installation, initialization, and field-testing procedures; and alternate sources of traffic flow data. The book addresses concerns related to the introduction of automated and connected vehicles, and the benefits that systems engineering and national ITS architectures in the US, Europe, Japan, and elsewhere bring to ITS. Sensor and data fusion benefits to traffic management are described, while the Bayesian and Dempster–Shafer approaches to data fusion are discussed in more detail. ITS Sensors and Architectures for Traffic Management and Connected Vehicles suits the needs of personnel in transportation institutes and highway agencies, and students in undergraduate or graduate transportation engineering courses.




Deep Learning Based on Connected Vehicles


Book Description

The connected vehicle is an emerging technology aimed at deploying and developing a fully connected transportation system which allows the vehicles to dynamically transmit messages between the vehicles (V2V), infrastructure (V2I), Cloud (V2C) and everything (V2X). The connected vehicles can provide an unprecedented amount of data even in the traffic network with a low market penetration rate, which can provide new solutions to transportation issues. This study focuses on micromodeling and quantitatively assessing the potential benefits of the connected vehicles on safety, mobility, and energy efficiency perspectives. In this dissertation, we proposed deep-learning based systems to solve different transportation problems under the environment of connected vehicles. The crash risk prediction system can identify crash-prone intersections and guide the deployment of safety measures to prevent potential crashes. The pothole detection system provides a cost-effective strategy to map the road conditions, which will be beneficial to road maintenance especially when municipal budgets are limited. The slippery condition surveillance system achieves real-time monitoring of pavement slippery conditions impacted by adverse weather and promotes cautious driving behaviors. The adaptive traffic signal control system provides an adaptive, efficient and optimized traffic signal control agent, which can reduce vehicle delay and emissions, improve mobility and energy efficiency. Overall, connected vehicle technology shows great potential in the field of transportation. The safety, mobility and energy efficiency will be further improved with the widespread deployment of connected vehicles and increase of market penetration rate, which is achievable in the near future.




Traffic Signal Timing Optimization with Connected Vehicles


Book Description

The advent and deployment of Connected vehicle (CV) and Vehicle-to-everything (V2X) communications offer the potential to significantly improve the efficiency of traffic signal control systems. The knowledge of vehicle trajectories in the network allows for optimal signal setting and significant improvements in network performance compared to existing traffic signal control systems. This research aims to develop a framework, including modeling techniques, algorithms, and testing strategies, for urban traffic signal optimization with CVs. The objective is to improve the safety, mobility, and sustainability of all vehicles in the study areas utilizing CV data, i.e., real time information on vehicles' locations and speeds, as well as communications to the signal control systems. The proposed framework is able to optimize traffic signal timing for a single intersection and along a corridor under various market penetration of CVs. Under full penetration rate of CVs, the signal timing optimization and coordination problems are first formulated in a centralized scheme as a mixed-integer nonlinear programing (MINLP). Due to the complexity of the model, the problem is decomposed into two levels: an intersection level to optimize phase durations using dynamic programing (DP) and a corridor level to optimize the offsets of all intersections. Under medium-to-high penetration rates of CVs, Kalman filter methods are applied to estimate trajectories of unequipped vehicles given the available trajectories of CVs. The estimated trajectories combined with CV trajectories are utilized in the trajectory-based signal timing optimization process. Under relatively low penetration rates of CVs, a Deep Intersection Spatial Temporal Network (DISTN) is developed to predict short-term movement-based traffic volumes. The predicted volumes are used in a volume-based adaptive signal control method to calculate signal timing parameters. Comprehensive testing and validation of the proposed methods are conducted in traffic simulation and with real world CV (probe vehicle) data. The testing tasks aim to validate that the developed methods are computationally manageable and have the potential to be implemented in CV-based traffic signal applications in the real world.




Dynamic Mobility Applications Analysis


Book Description

"Abstract: The Connected Vehicle Mobility Policy team (herein, policy team) developed this report to document policy considerations for the Multi-Modal Intelligent Traffic Signal System, or MMITSS. MMITSS comprises a "bundle" of dynamic mobility applications (DMA) that leverage existing and new connected vehicle data sets to optimize traffic signal timing for safety, emergency response, and improved mobility. The analysis is based on the policy team's review of a wide range of materials that include: - The MMITSS program's Concept of Operations (ConOps), Stakeholder Input Report, and System Design and Requirements documents. - The Connected Vehicle Reference Implementation Architecture (CVRIA) diagrams for MMITSS. - Discussions with the technical team overseeing development of the prototype applications within the MMITSS bundle and a review of the prototype documents. - Industry best practices and standards in information technology, security and privacy, and data exchange. As policy or institutional issues emerged during the review, they were categorized into one of four categories (not every DMA bundle had issues in all four categories) and were further paired with recommended actions for resolution, if options were available. Where they were not available, additional research is recommended. The four issue categories are: 1. High priority issues need immediate attention and resolution as they may challenge deployment, adoption, and use. 2. Medium priority issues have potentially serious consequences but clear, if challenging, paths to resolution; which should be accomplished prior to technology transfer. 3. Low priority issues have policy implications but also have solutions underway or represent current best practices that can be implemented before MMITSS applications are introduced to the marketplace. 4. Emerging issues have some probability of challenging deployment over time, as MMITSS implementations grow in complexity or geographic coverage. In summary: - One high-priority issue common to other DMA applications was identified and documented. The one issue is concerns of privacy of Personally Identifable Information (PII). Future MITSS deployments will need to ensure careful attention to PII concerns. - Four medium-priority issues were identified and documented. One issue is common to the other DMA applications. The four issues are: certification of Connected Vehicle (CV) technologies; data governance with regard to collecitng, archiving, and accessing CV data; safety of pedestrians and disabled users; and allocating signal priority among multiple agencies and private entities. All of these issues are challenging but have potential technical and policy options that can be applied to resolve them. Further research is recommended to analyze the options for their impacts and to determine the optimal recommendations. - Nine low priority issues were identified and have been documented in this report. They include: governance (legitimacy) of "handicapped" nomadic devices; ensuring functionality throughout the product lifecycle; digital certification for data exchange with nomadic devices; credentialing for technicians; interoperability of New MMITSS components with existing systems; availability to DSRC for real-time data exchange; regional integration and optimization of signal priorities; coordination and participation; concerns of existing signal priority patent owners. - Bicycle safety with MMITSS enabled signal systems may emerge as more important as MMITSS implementations expand to involve multiple agencies or jurisdictions which must work together effectively. Based on the results of this analysis, the policy team does not foresee a need for any new policies to be enacted or any major issues that will stand in the way of successful market adoption and use by industry. All policy and institutional issues identified can be resolved satisfactorily, some with recommended additional research into the following topics: - Existing guidance for collecting and storing Personal Identification Information (PII); identify whether existing policies adequately address MMITSS needs - Legal analysis of liability for pedestrian safety, in the event of an app failure - Case studies of bicycles and alternative technology - Literature review of current coordinated signal timing practices - Inventory Geographic Intersection Data management practices and identify any needed institutional changes - Best practices in inter-jurisdictional agreements for traffic management - Alignment with existing FHWA guidance on bicycles, coordinated signal timing."--Technical report documentation page.