Mexico's Credit Guarantees Program


Book Description

This study evaluates the efforts of Mexico's public policy to promote private financial access to small rural businesses through credit guarantee schemes (CGS). Private financial intermediaries do not have enough incentives to invest in the rural sector. A credit guarantee system provides such incentives by backing the credits issued for rural enterprises. Financial intermediaries and public trust funds share credit risks to promote the transition from rural peasant economy to modern commodity production system. Adjustments in credit guarantee policies are evaluated in this research. Interrupted time series explores whether financial access improved after the introduction of the FONAGA program. A reduction in the average amount per guaranteed operations suggests a shift in the type of program beneficiaries. More small and basic rural producers are being included in the CGS. Subsequently, the study explores if CGS promoted rural business transition by analyzing levels of agricultural production efficiencies via stochastic frontier analysis (SFA). Efficiency model specifications for beans, corn, sorghum and wheat showed that efficiencies did not improved significantly due to the inclusion of poorer producers in the agricultural system. Finally the CGS provision is spatially evaluated by looking at municipalities with high levels of poverty and checking whether the public program provides credit guarantees to the most in need rural business. FONAGA was able to influence previous program FEGA to allocate credit guarantees in impoverished regions.




An Evaluation of Government Loan Guarantees in Mexico


Book Description

This paper evaluates, under a descriptive approach if, by means of their loan guarantee programs, the Mexican government-owned financial institutions have succeeded in promoting the private banks credit supply to targeted segments of private businesses; fostered the granting of loans that help the competitiveness of private businesses, and, improved the credit terms of the private bank loans to the targeted population. Our database comprises over 23 million loan records. Results point to mixed indications on the aforementioned goals achievement.




Credit Guarantees


Book Description

The problem of collateral is a daily issue for lenders and causes much debate in the development finance community. Given the difficulties experienced in arranging traditional forms of loan security, such as land or chattel mortgages, various collateral substitutes have been proposed. Among the substitutes for traditional collateral is the loan guarantee. Guarantee systems for loans have been proposed, planned and implemented in various countries. The assumption made by proponents of such a service is that the guarantee organization is either better informed about the risk of the loan than the lender or it is better structured financially to be able to manage the risk. Despite the apparent attractiveness of a loan guarantee, the empirical evidence available gives little encouragement. Nevertheless, interest in guarantees continues.







International Trade


Book Description







Are Loan Guarantees Effective? The Case of Mexican Government Banks


Book Description

Mexican Government's Banks offer loan guarantees to private banks in order to spur credit directed to non-financial small and medium sized firms and this policy is examined here. Application of representative data to the comparative static analysis of the guarantee-use decision suggests that these schemes, as currently designed, are justifiable from an economic viewpoint. However, there is some evidence of inefficiency and ineffectiveness about the way these guarantee programs operate. Marginal take-up is plausibly explained only by the benefits perceived by private bankers.