Multidisciplinary Optimization of In-flight Electro-thermal Ice Protection Systems


Book Description

"The numerical multidisciplinary analysis and optimization of in-flight electro-thermal ice protection systems (IPS), in both anti-icing and de-icing modes, are presented by introducing general methodologies. The numerical simulation of the IPS is carried out by solving the conjugate heat transfer (CHT) problem between the fluid and solid domains. The sensitivity analysis of the energy requirements of anti-icing systems is performed with respect to different parameters, such as airspeed, angle of attack (AoA), ambient temperature, liquid water content and median volumetric diameter (MVD). For optimization, the goal is to reduce the power demand of the electro-thermal IPS, while ensuring a safe protection against icing. The design variables taken into account include power density, and the extent and activation time (in case of de-icing) of the electric heating blankets. Various constrained problem formulations for optimization in both the running-wet and evaporative regimes are presented. The formulations are carefully proposed from the physical and mathematical viewpoints; their performance is assessed by means of several numerical test cases to determine the most promising for each regime. The optimization is conducted using the mesh adaptive direct search (MADS) algorithm, which needs a large number of evaluations of the objective and constraint functions. This would be impractical as aero-icing flow simulations are computationally intensive and prohibitive, especially when coupled with conjugate heat transfer calculations, as for ice protection systems. Instead a surrogate-based optimization approach using reduced order modeling is proposed. In this approach, proper orthogonal decomposition (POD), in conjunction with Kriging, is used to replace the expensive CHT simulations. The results obtained show that the methodology is efficient and reliable in optimizing electro-thermal ice protection systems in particular, and thermal-based ones in general." --




Computational Methodology for Electro-thermal Ice Protection System Analysis


Book Description

The new trend in aviation industry is towards „all electric aircraft‟. Thus, there‟s a strong desire to replace bleed air systems with efficient electrical ice protection systems that would provide adequate ice protection. In the current thesis study, a computational methodology was developed to support the design and assess the performance of electro-thermal ice protection systems (ETIPS) for de-icing fixed wing aircraft. The methodology developed was tested using a range of geometries and electrical heater configurations and was validated with experimental data obtained by researchers at Wichita State University (WSU) and other organizations.







Aircraft Ice Protection


Book Description




Computational Methodology for Bleed Air Ice Protection System Parametric Analysis


Book Description

Aircraft in-flight icing is a major safety issue for civil aviation, having already caused hundreds of accidents and incidents related to aerodynamic degradation due to post takeoff ice accretion. Airplane makers have to protect the airframe critical surfaces against ice build up in order to ensure continued safe flight. Ice protection is typically performed by mechanical, chemical, or thermal systems. One of the most traditional and still used techniques is the one known as hot-air anti-icing, which heats the interior of the affected surfaces with an array of small hot-air jets generated by a piccolo tube. In some cases, the thermal energy provided by hot-air ice protection systems is high enough to fully evaporate the impinging supercooled droplets (fully evaporative systems), while in other cases, it is only sufficient to maintain most of the protected region free of ice (running wet systems). In the latter case, runback ice formations are often observed downstream of the wing leading edge depending on hot-air, icing, and flight conditions. The design process of hot-air anti-icing systems is traditionally based on icing wind tunnel experiments, which can be very costly. The experimental effort can be significantly reduced with the use of accurate three-dimensional computational fluid dynamic (CFD) simulation tools. Nevertheless, such type of simulation requires extensive CPU time for exploring all the design variables. This thesis deals with the development of an efficient hot-air anti-icing system simulation tool that can reduce the computational time to identify the critical design parameters by at least two orders of magnitude, as compared to 3-d CFD tools, therefore narrowing down the use of more sophisticated tools to just a small subset of the entire design space. The hot-air anti-icing simulation tool is based on a combination of available CFD software and a thermodynamic model developed in the present work. The computation of the external flow properties is performed with FLUENT (in a 2-d domain) by assuming an isothermal condition to the airfoil external wall. The internal skin heat transfer is computed with the use of local Nusselt number correlations developed through calibrations with CFD data. The internal and external flow properties on the airfoil skin are provided as inputs to a steady state thermodynamic model, which is composed of a 2-d heat diffusion model and a 1-d uniform film model for the runback water flow. The performance of the numerical tool was tested against 3-d CFD simulation and experimental data obtained for a wing equipped with a representative piccolo tube anti-icing system. The results demonstrate that the simplifications do not affect significantly the fidelity of the predictions, suggesting that the numerical tool can be used to support parametric and optimization studies during the development of hot-air anti-icing systems.




Numerical Investigation of a Wing Hot Air Ice Protection System


Book Description

Aircraft icing is a recurrent aviation safety concern. In the past eight years alone, eight icing accidents involving business jets and other aircraft have occurred. The accumulation of ice on critical aerodynamic surfaces, the primary cause of these accidents, leads to considerable performance degradation that compromises the safety of the passengers, the crew, and the vehicle. A variety of surface-deformation and thermal systems provide icing protection for aircraft. Hot air anti-icing systems are the most common for airplanes with aluminum leading edges on wing and tail surfaces, and engine inlets. These surfaces are heated using bleed air redirected from the jet engine compressor and channeled through a piccolo tube located inside the leading edge. A series of hot air jets emanate from small holes on the piccolo tube (piccolo holes) and impinge on the internal surface of the leading edge skin, transferring heat, and increasing the skin temperature to prevent ice accumulation. The design and optimization of hot air anti-icing systems involve both experimental and numerical studies. Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) is a cost-effective analysis tool for bleed air ice protection system design and evaluation. CFD analysis tools, however, require validation against experimental data to determine the accuracy of the numerical schemes, turbulence models, boundary conditions, and results obtained. The present thesis details a CFD methodology developed to simulate the performance of a wing hot air anti-icing system under dry air conditions (no water impingement). Computational simulations were conducted with the commercial CFD code FLUENT to investigate the performance of a hot air anti-icing system installed in the leading edge of a 72-inch span, 60-inch chord business jet wing model. The analysis was performed with a full-span model (FSM) and a partial-span model (PSM). The FSM was used to model the entire length of the piccolo tube to investigate the development of spanwise flow inside the piccolo tube. The PSM was used to model a 2.44-in spanwise section of the wing in order to investigate the internal and external flow properties about the wing with the bleed air system in operation. Computational results obtained with the PSM model were compared with experimental data obtained from icing tests performed at the NASA Glenn Icing Research Tunnel (IRT) facility. The work presented in this thesis includes extensive 2D axisymmetric computational studies performed with a subsonic, heated, turbulent jet impinging on a flat plate to evaluate the performance of five eddy-viscosity turbulence models available in the FLUENT code. The turbulence model studies showed that the Shear Stress Transport (SST) ? -? formulation provided the most consistent prediction of recovery temperatures at the impingement wall. Grid resolution and spatial discretization studies were completed with a three-dimensional version of the jet impingement scenario employed in the turbulence study, and first- and second-order upwind schemes. Three grid resolution levels were considered based on the number of nodes distributed around the nozzle exit circumference in order to apply the same distribution around the piccolo holes circumferences in the anti-icing system PSM. A boundary condition study was performed with the anti-icing models (FSM and PSM). The PSM did not model the piccolo tube internal flow and, consequently, required inflow boundary conditions to be specified at the piccolo holes' exits. The FSM was employed to analyze the flow inside the piccolo tube and to obtain the inflow boundary conditions for the PSM. The approaches applied to extract the boundary conditions were centerline and cell-averaged. Skin temperature results from the PSM were compared with available experimental data and showed that the cell-averaged approach provided the most accurate simulation. Finally, a parametric study was conducted with the anti-icing models (FSM and PSM) to validate the computational methodology with a broad range of cases with variable internal and external flow parameters for which experimental data was available. The results for leading-edge skin temperature as well as piccolo flow properties demonstrated in all cases high-fidelity agreement with experimental data.










Comparative Evaluation of Embedded Heating Elements as Electrothermal Ice Protection Systems for Composite Structures


Book Description

Since the development of modern aviation, the formation of ice on aerodynamic surfaces has been an important topic of study. It has been most critical in aviation because icing accidents have a high probability of being fatal. In energy production applications, such as wind turbines, blade icing can reduce power production efficiency and increase structural loads. Active ice protection systems have thus been developed using mechanical, thermal, or chemical methods. The thermal method is the only one that can both prevent and remove ice formations. Nowadays, hot air (i.e., bleed air from engines) thermal ice protection is used for commercial aircraft primary structures that are composed of metals. Composite structures are more suited to electrothermal ice protection systems than to hot air technology because bleed air is too hot and can cause structural damage to the composite. Design criteria for electrothermal systems heavily stand or fall on heating elements’ properties. Thus, within this work a study was conducted on the thermal efficiency, and temperature uniformity with consideration for manufacturability, availability, and potential impact of physical properties of three different heating element materials: constantan, carbon fiber, and carbon nanotube networks. Tests were performed on flat heater coupons in an icing wind tunnel. Infrared surface temperature measurements and de-icing time measurements revealed that the performance of the different materials did not differ considerably if all were driven by the same nominal power. Rather, the line spacing between the heating elements was the dominant influencing factor.