Probing Quasar Accretion Physics with Optical and X-ray Spectroscopy


Book Description

Abstract: Black holes, lurking at the centers of distant galaxies, feed on gas to become quasars. The bulk of the powerful emission from radio-quiet quasars originates from two structures close to the central black hole: the accretion disk and the hot corona. The disk-corona relationship and its dependence on the rate of gas accretion onto the central black hole is not well understood, in part because of the lack of knowledge regarding the corona temperature, density and geometry. To gain a better understanding of the accretion physics that affect the growth and evolution of quasars, as well as the evolution of their host galaxies, I perform a large-scale study of quasar optical through X-ray spectral energy distributions (SED). I have cross-correlated optical DR5 Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) quasars with the XMM-Newton archive of X-ray observations to obtain 792 optically-selected quasars with X-ray observations, 473 of which have X-ray spectra. I investigate relations between accretion rate, optical and X-ray luminosity, and X-ray slope. I compare the observed correlations with population synthesis simulations to determine which correlations are intrinsic to the physics of quasar accretion, and which are simply due to selection effects or the consequence of another correlation. I discuss the results with respect to physical models. At low accretion rates, the disk-corona structure may change significantly. I investigate this possibility in the case of red quasars by using optical and X-ray information to disentangle the effect of absorption and low accretion rates on red quasar SEDs. I find that 7 out of 17 of the reddest SDSS quasars are not well described by absorption. Instead, the red optical colors appear to be intrinsic to the accretion physics, and are perhaps related to the low accretion rates ( L/L Edd -0.05) observed for these objects. By extending the intrinsically red quasar SEDs to the infrared and ultraviolet wavelengths, I constrain standard disk models. By combining studies of large-scale trends with case studies of quasar accretion under extreme conditions, I investigate current models of disk-corona interactions.




Probing the Disk-corona Systems and the Broad Line Regions of Changing-look Quasars with Optical and X-ray Observations


Book Description

""Changing-look" quasars are a new class of highly variable active galactic nuclei that have changed their spectral type over surprisingly short timescales of a few years.The origin of this phenomenon is currently debated, but is likely to reflect some change in the accretion flow. To investigate the disk-corona systems in these objects, I use new Chandra X-ray observations and optical spectroscopy to measure optical/UV-X-ray spectral indices and Eddington ratios of ten previously discovered changing-look quasars at two or more epochs. By comparing these data with simulated results for X-ray binaries undergoing accretion state transitions,I find a likely similarity in spectral indices below 1% Eddington ratio. This implies that the accretion state transition is a possible origin of changing-look quasars. I further investigate the Eddington ratios of changing-look quasars before and after their spectral type changes, and find that changing-look quasars cross the 1% Eddington ratio boundary when their broad emission lines disappear/emerge. This supports the disk-wind model as the origin of broad emission lines"--




Quasar Diversity From the Optical, UV, X-ray, and Time Domain


Book Description

We use both multi-epoch spectroscopy and multi-wavelength data to develop our understanding of black hole accretion physics. We use the multi-epoch quasar spectra to determine how accurately single-epoch spectroscopy can locate quasars in emission-line parameter space to inform investigations where time-resolved spectroscopy is not available. We explore the improvements in the calculation of emission-line measurements that arise from using non-parametric information from many lines, utilizing reconstructions based on an independent component analysis applied to data from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Reverberation Mapping project. We further examine multi-wavelength (particularly UV/X-ray) properties of 1378 quasars in order to link correlations in observed parameters to theoretical models of the physical mechanisms dominating quasars as a function of mass and accretion rate. The clarity of these correlations is improved when 1) similarly using reconstructions based on an independent component analysis, and 2) removing quasars expected to be intrinsically absorbed based on their spectral slopes in the X-ray and optical and between the X-ray and optical. Multi-epoch spectroscopy reveals that single-epoch results do not significantly change where quasars are located in CIV parameter space and do not have a significant impact on investigations of the global Baldwin Effect. Quasars with emission line properties indicative of higher L/LEdd are less variable, consistent with models with enhanced accretion disk density. In addition to using the traditional CIV parameter space measures of CIV EQW and blueshift, we define a "CIV ll distance" along a best-fit polynomial curve that incorporates information from both CIV parameters. The CIV ll distance may be a better indicator of L/LEdd than the CIV EQW or blueshift alone as those relationships are known to break down at the extrema. However, there is only a weak correlation with the X-ray spectral index, which is also expected to be a robust indicator of L/LEdd. We find no X-ray or optical trends in the direction perpendicular to the CIV distance that could be used to reveal differences in accretion disk, wind, or corona structure that could be widening the CIV EQW-blueshift distribution. A different parameter (such as metallicity) not traced by these data must come into play.




Nearly Simultaneous Optical, Ultraviolet, and X Ray Observations of Three Pg Quasars


Book Description

Nearly simultaneous optical, ultraviolet, and x ray observations of three low redshift quasars are presented. The EXOSAT x ray spectra span the range of observed spectral indices for quasars from the canonical 0.7 energy index typical of Seyfert galaxies for PG0923+129 (Mrk 705) to the steep spectral indices frequently seen in higher luminosity quasars with an index of 1.58 for PG0844+349 (Ton 951). None of the quasars exhibits any evidence for a soft x ray excess. This is consistent with accretion disk spectra fit to the IR through UV continua of the quasars -- the best fitting disk spectra peak at approximately 6 eV with black hole masses in the range 5 x 10(exp 7) to 1 x 10(exp 9) solar mass and mass accretion rates of approximately 0.1 times the Eddington-limited rate. These rather soft disk spectra are also compatible with the observed optical and ultraviolet line ratios. Kriss, Gerard A. NASA-CR-186355, NAS 1.26:186355 NAG8-562...




Quasars at All Cosmic Epochs


Book Description

The last 50 years have seen a tremendous progress in the research on quasars. From a time when quasars were unforeseen oddities, we have come to a view that considers quasars as active galactic nuclei, with nuclear activity a coming-of-age experienced by most or all galaxies in their evolution. We have passed from a few tens of known quasars of the early 1970s to the 500,000 listed in the catalogue of the Data Release 14 of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey. Not surprisingly, accretion processes on the central black holes in the nuclei of galaxies — the key concept in our understanding of quasars and active nuclei in general — have gained an outstanding status in present-day astrophysics. Accretion produces a rich spectrum of phenomena in all bands of the electromagnetic spectrum. The power output of highly-accreting quasars has impressive effects on their host galaxies. All the improvement in telescope light gathering and in computing power notwithstanding, we still miss a clear connection between observational properties and theory for quasars, as provided, for example, by the H-R diagram for stars. We do not yet have a complete self-consistent view of nuclear activity with predictive power, as we do for main-sequence stellar sources. At the same time quasars offer many “windows open onto the unknown". On small scales, quasar properties depend on phenomena very close to the black hole event horizon. On large scales, quasars may effect evolution of host galaxies and their circum-galactic environments. Quasars’ potential to map the matter density of the Universe and help reconstruct the Universe’s spacetime geometry is still largely unexploited. The times are ripe for a critical assessment of our present knowledge of quasars as accreting black holes and of their evolution across the cosmic time. The foremost aim of this research topic is to review and contextualize the main observational scenarios following an empirical approach, to present and discuss the accretion scenario, and then to analyze how a closer connection between theory and observation can be achieved, identifying those aspects of our understanding that are still on a shaky terrain and are therefore uncertain knowledge. This research topic covers topics ranging from the nearest environment of the black hole, to the environment of the host galaxies of active nuclei, and to the quasars as markers of the large scale structure and of the geometry of spacetime of the Universe. The spatial domains encompass the accretion disk, the emission and absorption regions, circum-nuclear starbursts, the host galaxy and its interaction with other galaxies. Systematic attention is devoted to some key problems that remain outstanding and are clearly not yet solved: the existence of two quasar classes, radio quiet and radio loud, and in general, the systematic contextualization of quasar properties the properties of the central black hole, the dynamics of the accretion flow in the inner parsecs and the origin of the accretion matter, the quasars’ small and large scale environment, the feedback processes produced by the black hole into the host galaxy, quasar evolutionary patterns from seed black holes to the present-day Universe, and the use of quasars as cosmological standard candles. The timing is appropriate as we are now witnessing a growing body of results from major surveys in the optical, UV X, near and far IR, and radio spectral domains. Radio instrumentation has been upgraded to linear detector — a change that resembles the introduction of CCDs for optical astronomy — making it possible to study radio-quiet quasars at radio frequencies. Herschel and ALMA are especially suited to study the circum-nuclear star formation processes. The new generation of 3D magnetohydrodynamical models offers the prospective of a full physical modeling of the whole quasar emitting regions. At the same time, on the forefront of optical astronomy, applications of adaptive optics to long-slit spectroscopy is yielding unprecedented results on high redshift quasars. Other measurement techniques like 2D and photometric reverberation mapping are also yielding an unprecedented amount of data thanks to dedicated experiments and instruments. Thanks to the instrumental advances, ever growing computing power as well as the coming of age of statistical and analysis techniques, the smallest spatial scales are being probed at unprecedented resolution for wide samples of quasars. On large scales, feedback processes are going out of the realm of single-object studies and are entering into the domain of issues involving efficiency and prevalence over a broad range of cosmic epochs. The Research Topic "Quasars at all Cosmic Epochs" collects a large fraction of the contributions presented at a meeting held in Padova, sponsored jointly by the National Institute for Astrophysics, the Padova Astronomical Observatory, the Department of Physics and Astronomy of the University of Padova, and the Instito de Astrofísica de Andalucía (IAA) of the Consejo Superiór de Investigación Cientifica (CSIC). The meeting has been part of the events meant to celebrate the 250th anniversary of the foundation of the Padova Observatory.




The Astrophysics of Active Galactic Nuclei Variability in Large Scale Spectroscopic Surveys


Book Description

More than 50 years after the initial discovery of the extragalactic nature of quasi-stellar objects (quasars) by Schmidt (1963), studies of luminous active galactic nuclei (AGN) have revolutionized our understanding of black hole growth across cosmic time, accretion and jet physics, as well as galaxy evolution and cosmology. In the coming decade, these studies will be further fueled by large (a few x10^6) samples of quasars from massive optical spectroscopic surveys (e.g., from eBOSS and DESI). These spectra will be accompanied by well-sampled photometric light curves from time-domain imaging surveys (e.g., from Pan-STARRS and LSST), enabling discovery of rare objects and new time-domain phenomena. Current spectroscopic and imaging surveys have well-established that nearly all Type 1 quasars are optically variable, although the origin of this variability is still unknown. The primary goal of this thesis is to investigate various AGN variability phenomena in the UV/optical, to understanding their origin. In particular, I investigate the origin of 10-20% flux variability ubiquitously observed in quasars, the apparent change in accretion states observed in ‘transition blazars’, as well as the rapid fading observed in the recently-discovered ‘changing-look quasars’ phenomenon. I also prepare for the science enabled by the large samples of AGN that will be discovered in future time-domain imaging surveys, by characterizing the unique properties of variability-selected AGN. The primary technique I use in this dissertation to probe AGN variability is repeat optical spectroscopy. AGN optical spectra contain a wealth of information about the central engine, encoded in the properties of the emission lines, absorption lines, and continuum emission. Repeat optical spectroscopy can further probe the time-variable nature of these emission components, but this has previously been little explored in comparison to single-epoch spectroscopy. One notable exception in repeat AGN spectroscopy is the well-established reverberation mapping technique of mapping the size of AGN broad line regions; this has lead to the development of black hole mass estimates based on broad Balmer emission line widths in single-epoch spectroscopy. However, these and other studies based on repeat AGN spectroscopy are only available for small samples of a few dozen AGN at low redshifts, due to the expensive nature of repeat spectroscopy for large samples of faint quasars at higher redshifts. The development of multi-object spectrographs now have the ability to do repeat spectroscopy for large numbers of quasars, opening new windows into AGN astrophysics in the time-domain. Surveys dedicated to repeat quasar spectroscopy, including currently in SDSS-IV and in the future in SDSS-V, will fuel the early science results from this dissertation. In this dissertation, I first use SDSS repeat spectroscopy of quasars to quantify the bluer-when-brighter trend of wavelength-dependent quasar spectral variability, and use it to con- strain simple models of quasar variability. In particular, I test whether the observed spectral variability is consistent with recent toy models of inhomogeneous accretion disks with large temperature fluctuations. These models provide a natural explanation for quasar UV/optical variability, and the first to be consistent with measurements of quasar accretion disk sizes and characteristic timescales of variability. I show that the observed spectral variability can be reproduced by strongly inhomogeneous disks with large temperature fluctuations. I then use SDSS repeat spectroscopy to investigate the origin of the ‘transition blazars’ phenomenon, which is observed in a handful of AGN with relativistic jets aligned with the line of sight. In transition blazars, the blazars appear to switch between BL Lac objects and Flat-Spectrum Radio Quasars (FSRQs) classifications, which correspond to low- and high- accretion rate states, respectively. I show that transition blazars are FSRQs with especially strong beaming, such that the strongly-beamed continuum swamps the broad emission lines. This occasionally causes the broad emission lines to disappear and reappear, producing the transitional behavior. Furthermore, I mine SDSS repeat spectroscopy to uncover the origin of the recently-discovered ‘changing-look quasars’ phenomenon. Repeat optical spectroscopy of this new class of objects show dramatic transitions from luminous broad line quasars into quiescent galaxies or low-luminosity AGN. Surprisingly, these changes occur over timescales of just a few years, a factor of >10^4 faster than both theoretical expectations and scaling spectral state transition timescales in X-ray binaries to 10^8 M_sun supermassive black holes (SMBHs). To understand this phenomenon, I perform the first large systematic search for CL quasars and I show that the fading of the continuum and broad emission lines in CL quasars is consistent with rapidly decreasing accretion rates, while disfavoring alternative interpretations including changes in intrinsic dust extinction and transient tidal disruption events or supernovae. Finally, future time-domain imaging surveys such as the ZTF and LSST will discover a few x10^7 variable objects, and AGN will constitute the majority of variable objects discovered. To understand the science enabled by these massive variability-selected samples of AGN, I utilized spectra from the Time-Domain Spectroscopic Survey (TDSS) to understand the unique properties of variability-selected quasars. TDSS is the first systematic spectroscopic survey of variable objects, and I show that variability-selected quasars complement color-based selection by selecting additional redder quasars, resulting in a smooth redshift distribution. Furthermore, I show that variability selection yields higher fractions of peculiar AGN such as broad absorption line quasars and blazars.




Zooming in on Quasar Accretion Disks Using Chromatic Microlensing


Book Description

Observing the temperature profiles of accretion disks around black holes is a fundamental test of an important astrophysical process. However, angular resolution limitations have prevented such a measurement for distant quasars. We present a new method for determining the size of quasar accretion disks at a range of wavelengths, thus constraining their temperature profiles. The technique uses single-epoch, multi-wavelength optical and nearinfrared imaging of gravitationally lensed quasars in conjunction with X-ray imaging, and takes advantage of the presence of microlensing perturbations to the magnifications of the lensed images. The dependence of these perturbations on the angular size of the source, combined with the temperature structure of quasar accretion disks, causes the flux ratio anomalies due to microlensing to appear chromatic. This allows us to probe regions of the quasar that are too small to be measured by any other technique. We apply this method to observations of 12 lensed quasars, and measure the size of the accretion disk of each in 8 broadband filters between 0.36 and 2.2 microns (in the observed frame). We find that the overall sizes are larger by factors of 3 to 30 than predicted by the standard thin accretion disk model, and that the logarithmic slope of the wavelength-dependent size is ~ 0.2 on average, much shallower than the predicted slope of 4/3. This implies that the temperature is a steeper function of radius than the thin disk model predicts. With this new approach to determining quasar accretion disk sizes, we are thus able to rule out the standard thin disk model as the source of the (rest-frame) ultraviolet and optical continuum in these bright quasars.




High Resolution X-ray Spectroscopy of Cosmic Plasmas


Book Description

This book gives an account of the proceedings of the International Astronomical Union Colloquium 115: High Resolution X-Ray Spectroscopy of Cosmic Plasmas. This was the first IAU meeting dedicated to high resolution X-ray spectroscopy of objects outside the solar system. A broad range of objects and astrophysical conditions are discussed. Results from the first generation of satellites with spectroscopic capability, i.e. the Einstein Observatory, EXOSAT, and Tenma, are reviewed from a perspective of a more precise interpretation allowed by improved theoretical models and plasma diagnostics. Laboratory and solar X-ray results that model or are relevant to conditions found in cosmic X-ray sources are also presented. The colloquium presents a forum for discussion of scientific objectives of new international missions in high resolution X-ray spectroscopy.




Tutorial Guide to X-ray and Gamma-ray Astronomy


Book Description

This book provides a comprehensive introduction to X-ray and gamma-ray astronomy. The first part discusses the basic theoretical and observational topics related to black hole astrophysics; the optics and the detectors employed in X-ray and gamma-ray astronomy; and past, present, and future X-ray and gamma-ray missions. The second part then describes data reduction and analysis, the statistics used in X-ray and gamma-ray astronomy, and demonstrates how to write a successful proposal and a scientific paper. Data reduction in connection with specific X-ray and gamma-ray missions is covered in the appendices. Presenting the state of the art in X-ray and gamma-ray astronomy, this is both a valuable textbook for students and an important reference resource for researchers in the field.