The Effect of Star-planet Interactions on Planetary Climate


Book Description

The goal of the work presented here is to explore the unique interactions between a host star, an orbiting planet, and additional planets in a stellar system, and to develop and test methods that include both radiative and gravitational effects on planetary climate and habitability. These methods can then be used to identify and assess the possible climates of potentially habitable planets in observed planetary systems. In this work I explored key star-planet interactions using a hierarchy of models, which I modifed to incorporate the spectrum of stars of different spectral types. Using a 1-D energy-balance climate model, a 1-D line-by-line, radiative-transfer model, and a 3-D general circulation model, I simulated planets covered by ocean, land, and water ice of varying grain size, with incident radiation from stars of different spectral types. I find that terrestrial planets orbiting stars with higher near-UV radiation exhibit a stronger ice-albedo feedback. Ice extent is much greater on a planet orbiting an F-dwarf star than on a planet orbiting a G-dwarf star at an equivalent flux distance, and ice-covered conditions occur on an F-dwarf planet with only a 2% reduction in instellation (incident stellar radiation) relative to the present instellation on Earth, assuming fixed CO2 (present atmospheric level on Earth). A similar planet orbiting the Sun at an equivalent flux distance requires an 8% reduction in instellation, while a planet orbiting an M-dwarf star requires an additional 19% reduction in instellation to become ice-covered, equivalent to 73% of the modern solar constant. The reduction in instellation must be larger for planets orbiting cooler stars due in large part to the stronger absorption of longer-wavelength radiation by icy surfaces on these planets, in addition to stronger absorption by water vapor, CO2, and clouds in their atmospheres, providing increased downwelling longwave radiation. The surface ice-albedo feedback effect becomes less important at the outer edge of the habitable zone, where atmospheric CO2 can be expected to be high. I show that ~3-10 bars of CO2 will entirely mask the climatic effect of ice and snow, leaving the traditional outer limit of the habitable zone unaffected by the spectral dependence of water ice and snow albedo. Simulations of the equilibrium climate response of a planet to increasing instellation from an F-, G-, or M-dwarf star indicate that the exit out of global ice cover is also sensitive to host star spectral energy distribution. Under fixed CO2 conditions, a planet orbiting an M-dwarf star exhibits a smaller resistance to melting out of a frozen state, requiring a smaller instellation to initiate deglaciation than planets orbiting hotter, brighter stars. This is due to the combined effects of surface ice and snow absorption of the large fraction of near-IR radiation emitted by M-dwarfs, and atmospheric near-IR absorption, which weakens the Hadley circulation, reducing the climate hysteresis (the range over which multiple stable equilibia are possible) of M-dwarf planets. Given their greater climatic stability, planets orbiting cooler, lower-mass stars may be the best candidates for long-term habitability and life beyond the Solar System. As lower-mass stars are likely candidates to host multiple rocky planets, it is important to consider whether gravitational interactions among planets may have significant effects on climate and habitability over long timescales. Using an n-body integrator with inputs from a method I developed to determine the locations of all planets in a given system at the same epoch using transit timing data, a specific case is explored- that of Kepler-62f (Borucki et al. 2013), a potentially habitable planet in a five-planet system orbiting a K-dwarf star. The maximum stable initial eccentricity possible for Kepler-62f is identified as e = 0.32. Simulations using a 3-D GCM indicate that Kepler-62f would have areas of the planet with surface temperatures above the freezing point of water with 1 bar or more of CO2 in its atmosphere. If it has an active carbon cycle, Kepler-62f could have ample amounts of greenhouse gases in its atmosphere to maintain atmospheric stability and habitable surface conditions while staying well below the maximum CO2 greenhouse limit. In a low-CO2 case (Earth-like levels), increases in planetary obliquity and orbital eccentricity coupled with an orbital configuration that places the summer solstice at or near pericenter generate regions of the planet with above-freezing surface temperatures, which may cause surface melting of an ice sheet formed during an annual cycle. If Kepler-62f is synchronously rotating and has an ocean, significant cloud cover could develop at the substellar point, increasing planetary albedo and reducing surface temperatures. The methods presented here serve as tested tools that can be used to assess the possible climates of potentially habitable planets in systems with a wide range of orbital architectures as they are discovered.




Handbook of Exoplanets


Book Description

This state-of-the-art reference work includes over 15 sections dealing with all aspects of exoplanets and exobiology research, including historic aspects, the Solar System as a template, objects at the planet-to-star transition, exoplanet detection and characterization with related instrumentation, technology and software tools, planet and planet-system statistics with recent and planned surveys, their atmosphere and formation and evolution processes, habitability and exobiology implications, and outlooks for future exploration and science development, including visionary contributions. Each section has 10-20 contributions written by the top experts in their subject, including both senior researchers as well as young, smart researchers who represent the future of the discipline. All in all, this handbook comprehensively tackles one of the most challenging and dynamic fields of modern astronomy and astrophysics.




Living around Active Stars (IAU S328)


Book Description

The variable activity of stars such as the Sun is mediated through stellar magnetic fields, radiative and energetic particle fluxes, stellar winds and magnetic storms manifested as stellar flares and coronal mass ejections. This activity influences planetary atmospheres, climate and habitability: on the one hand it drives life-sustaining processes on planets, but on the other hand can adversely impact planetary environments rendering them uninhabitable. Studies of this intimate relationship between the parent star, its astrosphere and the planets that it hosts have reached a certain level of maturity in our own Solar System. Based on this understanding, the first attempts are being made to characterize the interactions between distant stars and their planets and understand their coupled evolution, which is relevant for the search for habitable exoplanets. IAU Symposium 328 brings together diverse, interdisciplinary reviews and research papers which address the themes of star-planet interactions and habitability.







Star-Planet Interactions


Book Description

The exoplanet revolution that began three decades ago has drastically changed our knowledge of the extra-solar systems. Today, we face an extreme diversity and complexity of these systems that can only be understood through the intimate link that exists between the planets and their host stars. The understanding, characterization, and the detection of the exoplanets has to be made in close collaboration between stellar and planetary physicists. The purpose of the school and this book is to provide an update of our current knowledge in some selected research fields dedicated to the interplay between stars and planets. It aims to prepare scientists for a rich new decade for exoplanets with space missions like the upcoming PLATO and ARIEL and the new instruments on the VLT and the future ELT.




Comparative Climatology of Terrestrial Planets


Book Description

The early development of life, a fundamental question for humankind, requires the presence of a suitable planetary climate. Our understanding of how habitable planets come to be begins with the worlds closest to home. Venus, Earth, and Mars differ only modestly in their mass and distance from the Sun, yet their current climates could scarcely be more divergent. Only Earth has abundant liquid water, Venus has a runaway greenhouse, and evidence for life-supporting conditions on Mars points to a bygone era. In addition, an Earth-like hydrologic cycle has been revealed in a surprising place: Saturn’s cloud-covered satellite Titan has liquid hydrocarbon rain, lakes, and river networks. Deducing the initial conditions for these diverse worlds and unraveling how and why they diverged to their current climates is a challenge at the forefront of planetary science. Through the contributions of more than sixty leading experts in the field, Comparative Climatology of Terrestrial Planets sets forth the foundations for this emerging new science and brings the reader to the forefront of our current understanding of atmospheric formation and climate evolution. Particular emphasis is given to surface-atmosphere interactions, evolving stellar flux, mantle processes, photochemistry, and interactions with the interplanetary environment, all of which influence the climatology of terrestrial planets. From this cornerstone, both current professionals and most especially new students are brought to the threshold, enabling the next generation of new advances in our own solar system and beyond. Contents Part I: Foundations Jim Hansen Mark Bullock Scot Rafkin Caitlin Griffith Shawn Domagal-Goldman and Antigona Segura Kevin Zahnle Part II: The Greenhouse Effect and Atmospheric Dynamics Curt Covey G. Schubert and J. Mitchell Tim Dowling Francois Forget and Sebastien Lebonnois Vladimir Krasnopolsky Adam Showman Part III: Clouds, Hazes, and Precipitation Larry Esposito A. Määttänen, K. Pérot, F. Montmessin, and A. Hauchecorne Nilton Renno Zibi Turtle Mark Marley Part IV: Surface-Atmosphere Interactions Colin Goldblatt Teresa Segura et al. John Grotzinger Adrian Lenardic D. A. Brain, F. Leblanc, J. G. Luhmann, T. E. Moore, and F. Tian Part V: Solar Influences on Planetary Climate Aaron Zent Jerry Harder F. Tian, E. Chassefiere, F. Leblanc, and D. Brain David Des Marais




On Star-planet Interaction


Book Description

With the explosion of exoplanetary discoveries, the question of planetary habitability is at the forefront, and generates many interesting and complex questions. One of those questions: Are planetary global magnetic fields necessary for the development of complex surface organics and the development of life? Does a global field protect planetary atmospheres? What detection signatures can be gleaned from a planet or moon with a global field as opposed to one without? We have a wealth of in situ magnetospheric data from Earth, as well as solar system planets and their moons from several vital satellite missions, such as the Voyager missions, the Pioneer missions, Galileo, Cassini, Messenger, MAVEN, and New Horizons. Due to the distances involved, it is not tenable to send satellites to obtain data at exoplanetary bodies, so we rely on simulations and using solar system data as analog environments to help set ground truth validation for the numerical work. In this dissertation, I use a multifluid plasma model for gas giant magnetospheres to predict the potential dynamical consequences and detection signatures for giant exoplanets in a warm orbit (~0.2 AU). I discuss the dynamics of plasma loss from an exomoon injected torus, and how the total mass flux out of the system is altered by increased stellar wind forcing as a function of orbital semi-major axis. Detection signatures for such a planet, including transit depth modifications due to plasma densities and radio emissions, show promise for further detecting and characterizing future systems. I also improve the multifluid model by implementing a full treatment of pressure anisotropy at Saturn, with a focus on the dynamics and structure of the magnetosphere. The improvements to the physics of the model generate more accurate system when compared to Cassini data; the anisotropic simulations show stronger current confinement of the Enceladus torus, consistent and well-structure flux interchange events, and global corotational convection that match more closely with the Cassini data than the isotropic model. Turning from giant planets to terrestrial, I use a coupled one-dimensional photochemical and radiative-convective climate model to investigate the effects of M dwarf stellar flare activity on an Earth-like atmosphere for an unmagnetized planet in the nominal habitable zone. I find that EM-only activity - even to the level of some of the most active stars yet observed - is insufficient at the age of the universe to reduce the ozone column to the point that UV-C radiation can reach the surface. However, repeated proton events from frequent daily flare activity, which has been observed on several M dwarfs, can erode the ozone column by several orders of magnitude, allowing the surface of the planet to be bathed in UV-C, which is sterilizing and detrimental to the development of complex organic structures. The ability of a strong planetary magnetic field to deflect incoming stellar wind and flare-energized protons seems to be of import to maintain surface habitability. I also use scaling laws to predict a potential atomic oxygen auroral signal from Proxima Centauri b, the detection of which would constrain the presence of an atmosphere and point to the presence of a magnetic field. The increased forcing from Proxima Centauri's stellar wind is expected to drive powerful emissions, orders of magnitude stronger than at Earth, and within easy reach of the next generation of observational telescopic instruments. Magnetic fields do seem to be important for both detection and potential shielding of the atmosphere of exoplanets, but much work remains to be performed. Future observations combined with simulations validated against solar system star-planet interactions will likely provide answers to these questions, and perhaps lead to a focus on specific planetary targets for extensive investigation of astrobiological interest.




The Atmosphere and Climate of Mars


Book Description

Humanity has long been fascinated by the planet Mars. Was its climate ever conducive to life? What is the atmosphere like today and why did it change so dramatically over time? Eleven spacecraft have successfully flown to Mars since the Viking mission of the 1970s and early 1980s. These orbiters, landers and rovers have generated vast amounts of data that now span a Martian decade (roughly eighteen years). This new volume brings together the many new ideas about the atmosphere and climate system that have emerged, including the complex interplay of the volatile and dust cycles, the atmosphere-surface interactions that connect them over time, and the diversity of the planet's environment and its complex history. Including tutorials and explanations of complicated ideas, students, researchers and non-specialists alike are able to use this resource to gain a thorough and up-to-date understanding of this most Earth-like of planetary neighbours.




Planetary Science


Book Description

Since the publication of the popular first edition, stellar and planetary scientists have produced numerous new observations, theories, and interpretations, including the "demotion" of our former ninth planet Pluto as a dwarf planet. Covering all of these new discoveries, Planetary Science: The Science of Planets around Stars, Second Edition explai