Exploring the Interplay Between Star Formation and Active Galactic Nuclei and the Role of Environment in Galaxy Evolution


Book Description

One of the central goals of extragalactic astronomy is to understand how galaxies grow their stellar mass and central black holes, the connection between star formation and active galactic nuclei (AGN), and the impact of environment on this growth. In this thesis, I utilize multiwavelength surveys that are both deep and wide, advanced computational codes that model the spectral energy distributions of galaxies with and without AGN, as well as state-of-the-art simulations of galaxy evolution in order to explore how galaxy properties are impacted by their surrounding environment and AGN activity. These studies explore galaxies over a redshift range of 0.015 z 0.023 (lookback time of ~ 0.2 to ~ 0.3 Gyr), and over a redshift range of 0.5 z 3.0 (lookback time of ~ 5 to ~ 12 Gyr). The large-area surveys used here provide some of the largest and most statistically robust samples to-date of rare massive galaxies (with stellar mass M [subscript *] 1011 M☉) and extremely luminous AGN (with X-ray luminosity L [subscript X] 1044 erg s−1) out to z ~ 3, thereby limiting the effects of cosmic variance and Poisson statistics. I analyze the observed stellar masses and star formation rates of galaxies as a function of environment and AGN activity, compare the empirical results to theoretical models of galaxy evolution, and discuss the implications of such comparisons. This work will provide significant guidance and constraints to the future development of theoretical models of galaxy growth. In Chapter 2 (Florez et al. 2021, ApJ, 906, 97) I measure the environmental dependence, where environment is defined by the distance to the third nearest neighbor, of multiple galaxy properties inside the Environmental COntext (ECO) catalog. I focus primarily on void galaxies at redshifts z = 0.015 - 0.023, which I define as the 10% of galaxies having the lowest local density. I compare the properties of void and non-void galaxies: baryonic mass, color, fractional stellar mass growth rate (FSMGR), morphology, and gas-to-stellar-mass ratio. The void galaxies typically have lower baryonic masses than galaxies in denser environments, and they display the properties expected of a lower mass population: they have more late-types, are bluer, have higher FSMGR, and are more gas rich. I also control for baryonic mass and investigate the extent to which void galaxies are different at fixed mass. I find that void galaxies are bluer, more gas-rich, and more star forming at fixed mass than non-void galaxies, which is a possible signature of galaxy assembly bias and other environmental processes. Furthermore, I show that these trends persist even at fixed mass and morphology, and I find that voids host a distinct population of early-types that are bluer and more star-forming than the typical red and quenched early-types. In addition to these empirical observational results, I also present theoretical results from mock catalogs with built-in galaxy assembly bias. I show that a simple matching of galaxy properties to (sub)halo properties, such as mass and age, can recover the observed environmental trends in the local galaxy population. In Chapter 3 (Florez et al. 2020, MNRAS, 497, 3273) I investigate the relation between AGN and star formation activity at 0.5 z 3 by analyzing 898 galaxies with high X-ray luminosity AGN (L [subscript X] 1044 erg s−1) and a large comparison sample of ~ 320,000 galaxies without such AGN. My samples are selected from a large (11.8 deg2) area in Stripe 82 that has multi-wavelength (X-ray to far-IR) data. The enormous comoving volume (~ 0.3 Gpc3) at 0.5




Intrinsic Characteristics of Galaxies in the Distant Universe


Book Description

One of the major questions in observational cosmology is how galaxies formed and how they evolved. In particular, understanding the assembly history of galaxies at the peak epoch of the star formation activity, z=1-3, is a key to understanding the whole picture of the Universe, but remains uncertain. Galaxies with various physical properties and morphologies have different formation and evolution histories. As such, we seek insight into galaxy formation and evolution at z=1-3 using galaxies selected from Cosmic Assembly Near-infrared Deep Extragalactic Legacy Survey (CANDELS) in this dissertation. First, we investigate the relationship between spectral types and morphologies using various parametric diagnostics and visual inspections. Our sample clearly separates into massive, red, and passive galaxies versus less massive, blue, and star forming ones, and this dichotomy correlates very well with the galaxies' morphological properties. From this study, we suggest that the backbone of the Hubble sequence was already in place at z~2. Second, we explore how the choice of star formation histories affects estimating galaxy properties by adopting flexible star formation history models to the fitting of galaxy's spectrum. The estimation of galaxy properties is improved using CANDELS observations providing unprecedented coverage and depths, and using an advanced fitting technique. We find that galaxy properties, particularly age and star formation rate, are sensitive to the choice of star formation histories. We also find that using different best-fit star formation histories leads to significantly different results on the main sequence of star formation. Our results demonstrate that using the best-fit star formation history for each galaxy is more appropriate way than using one analytic model for all galaxy types. Third, with accurately measured stellar mass and star formation rate, we study characteristics of galaxies on, above, and below the main sequence. We find that distinct morphological differences are shown among different galaxy populations using various diagnostics. On average, as star formation activities decrease, galaxies become denser having smaller sizes and steeper light profiles at all explored redshifts. We also show that the compact morphology is not necessary to precede a passivity of star formation. Our results do not support that gas-rich merging is the key driver to assemble very compact, massive early-type galaxies observed at z~2. Instead, we suggest that compact galaxies simply assemble at very early times and evolve through in situ star formation to form compact massive, quiescent galaxies without significant merging events.




Multiwavelength Mapping of Galaxy Formation and Evolution


Book Description

The possibilities of astronomical observation have dramatically increased over the last decade. Major satellites, like the Hubble Space Telescope, Chandra and XMM Newton, are complemented by numerous large ground-based observatories, from 8m-10m optical telescopes to sub-mm and radio facilities. As a result, observational astronomy has access to virtually the whole electromagnetic spectrum of galaxies, even at high redshifts. Theoretical models of galaxy formation and cosmological evolution now face a serious challenge to match the plethora of observational data. In October 2003, over 170 astronomers from 15 countries met for a 4-day workshop to extensively illustrate and discuss all major observational projects and ongoing theoretical efforts to model galaxy formation and evolution. This volume contains the complete proceedings of this meeting and is therefore a unique and timely overview of the current state of research in this rapidly evolving field.




Star Formation and Galaxy Evolution Since Z~2


Book Description

Our recent studies in galaxy evolution have revealed a surprising new paradigm of star formation. Contrary to the notion that major mergers play an increasingly dominant role going backwards in cosmic history, we find that over the last ~10 Gyr, much of star formation has been fueled by accreting cold gas from the cosmic web. Accretion rates were presumably larger in the past, so star forming systems may have very different properties in the early Universe and today. Large scale astronomical surveys, such as the Herschel Multi-Tiered Extragalactic Survey (HerMES), and the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) have provided a wealth of extragalactic data covering a statistically large number of sources. Targeted, niche surveys, like our fine structure line survey of star forming galaxies in the early Universe observed with the redshift (z) Early Universe Spectrometer (ZEUS) have provided detailed observations of high interest sources. We have made use of this diverse set of data to study galaxy evolution from the epoch of peak star formation at z=1-2 up to the present. Data from HerMES is a reliable probe of infrared emission, particularly useful for characterizing the far infrared dust peak, and therefore determining star formation rates out to redshifts of a few. Deep integrations with the Herschel SPIRE photometer rapidly reach the confusion limit, tempering its utility in studying faint high redshift galaxies. With appropriate care taken to identify blended sources, however, HerMES data is useful in identifying bright, red- shifted, star forming sources. We have compiled spectral energy distributions from HerMES and ancillary data and found that, even sources at high redshift are well fit by local star forming galaxy templates. In the local Universe, spectroscopic SDSS data has allowed us to estimate crucial galaxy properties on ~105 sources, providing an opportunity to observe general statistical trends, and constrain theories of galaxy evolution. A toy model of cold flow accretion powered star formation reproduces the observed fundamental plane of galaxy stellar mass, metallicity, and star formation for small and medium mass galaxies. Our fine structure line survey with ZEUS detected the [CII] 157.7 [MICRO SIGN]m line in eight galaxies from the epoch of peak star formation at z=1-2. We augmented this survey with observations of the [OI] 63 [MICRO SIGN]m line and far infrared photometry from Herschel, as well as Spitzer IRS spectra from the literature. Most of our sources have higher than average gas heating efficiency with L[CII] /LF IR 10[-]2 . We interpret the majority of them as being dominated by star formation powered PDRs, extending to kpc scales. In two sources there is evidence for enhanced [CII] emission due to heating by low velocity shocks. These findings are consistent with a picture of gas accretion fueling star formation on a near galaxy-wide scale. In synthesizing this data we find a remarkable consistency in the nature of star formation over the last 10 Gyr. In contrast with the model of sustained hierarchical merging, we find that star formation since z~2 is fueled largely by cold flow accretion of gas from the cosmic web, which presents itself as moderate density star formation with correspondingly moderate UV fields.




Star Formation in Galaxy Evolution: Connecting Numerical Models to Reality


Book Description

This book contains the elaborated and updated versions of the 24 lectures given at the 43rd Saas-Fee Advanced Course. Written by four eminent scientists in the field, the book reviews the physical processes related to star formation, starting from cosmological down to galactic scales. It presents a detailed description of the interstellar medium and its link with the star formation. And it describes the main numerical computational techniques designed to solve the equations governing self-gravitating fluids used for modelling of galactic and extra-galactic systems. This book provides a unique framework which is needed to develop and improve the simulation techniques designed for understanding the formation and evolution of galaxies. Presented in an accessible manner it contains the present day state of knowledge of the field. It serves as an entry point and key reference to students and researchers in astronomy, cosmology, and physics.




Galaxy Evolution and the Redshift Desert


Book Description

This thesis explores the evolution of galaxies from the onset of star formation shortly after the Big Bang until the present day. Particular emphasis lies on the redshift range z = 1.4 2.5, the so-called "redshift desert", as it coincides with the peak epoch of cosmic star formation activity and mass assembly. Most of the information about galaxies and their evolution arrives in the form of their integrated light, i.e. the conglomeration of light emitted by stars of various ages and metallicities. In order to interpret the observed spectra and magnitudes, and to extract the physical parameters we therefore require models. This holds true in particular for galaxies too faint to target them spectroscopically, and for which redshifts and physical parameters derived from only their photometry is the only feasible way to study them in more detail. This thesis is concerned with such models, and describes how GALEV evolutionary synthesis models describe the spectral and chemical evolution of galaxies, accounting for gaseous emission and the increasing initial abundances of successive stellar generations, how they compare to observations and what we can learn from their application. Based on a large model grid, covering all observed galaxy evolution stages, I find that sub-solar metallicities have significant impact on the spectra of galaxies, and can lead to systematic errors and biases if not accounted for. A comparison of models with different metallicities furthermore reveals that photometric redshifts are also systematically biased if sub-solar metallicities are not properly accounted for. I also note that even a small mass-fractions of young stars can dominate the overall spectrum, leading to a large underestimation of the mass and age of the stellar population. The models explain not only the colour evolution of galaxies observed at a range of redshifts, but also their physical parameters. I show that with magnitudes in only a few bands we can successfully explain not only the masses of galaxies, but also their star formation rates and, where available from observations, their metallicities. If additional data are available, the grid of models can be used to refine colour selection criteria and to break degeneracies, e.g. between dust-reddened actively star-forming galaxies and intrinsically old, passively evolving galaxies. Using GAZELLE, a photometric redshift code that is purpose-tailored to harmonise with these models, I can extract accurate redshifts and a wealth of physical parameters from the largest ever sample of observed multi-wavelength photometry of galaxies. I then compare our findings with semi-analytical models that trace the evolution of individual galaxies based on cosmological simulations. In my sample I find a significant population of high-mass galaxies that is not accounted for by this class of models. Furthermore a small percentage of massive, yet starforming galaxies challenges our idea on how these galaxies form and evolve. In an appendix to this thesis I present a complementary approach to reconstruct the evolution of galaxies, using star clusters as tracers. I introduce a new technique to break the age-metallicity degeneracy and obtain individual ages and metallicities for a sample of globular clusters, revealing a merger of two Sb/Sc-type spirals 2 Gyrs ago in NGC 4570, a lenticular galaxy in the Virgo cluster. Also in the appendix I show that, at least in the studied galaxy Arp 78, the initial mass function conforms with our assumptions and does not change in low-density environments as recently predicted. Although studies of galaxy evolution are a major field in astronomy, there is still a lot more to be done to reveal the inner workings of these island universes, and this thesis also addresses how to continue and improve the work presented herein.




Introduction to Galaxy Formation and Evolution


Book Description

Present-day elliptical, spiral and irregular galaxies are large systems made of stars, gas and dark matter. Their properties result from a variety of physical processes that have occurred during the nearly fourteen billion years since the Big Bang. This comprehensive textbook, which bridges the gap between introductory and specialized texts, explains the key physical processes of galaxy formation, from the cosmological recombination of primordial gas to the evolution of the different galaxies that we observe in the Universe today. In a logical sequence, the book introduces cosmology, illustrates the properties of galaxies in the present-day Universe, then explains the physical processes behind galaxy formation in the cosmological context, taking into account the most recent developments in this field. The text ends on how to find distant galaxies with multi-wavelength observations, and how to extract the physical and evolutionary properties based on imaging and spectroscopic data.




Exploring Star Formation in High-mass Galaxies in the Low-z Universe


Book Description

We present a quantitative analysis of high-mass, low-z galaxies in order to investigate the 'downsizing' scenario of galaxy evolution. High-mass, low-z galaxies with ongoing star formation, antithetical to the 'downsizing' model, are identified using the 22[micrometer] data (W4 band) from the Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer (WISE). A cluster and field sample is chosen to investigate any possible environmental effects. The cluster sample is based upon the GMBCG catalog, which contains 55,424 brightest cluster galaxies (BCGs) at 0:1 [approximately less than] z [approximately less than] 0:55 identified in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS). We identify 389 W4-detected BCGs (W4BCGs) that have median SFRs of [approximately]50 M[dot in circle]/yr based upon their total IR luminosity (L[subscript IR]), which is attributed to dust-enshrouded star formation. BCGs with such high SFRs are found in "coolcore" clusters and the star formation is thought to be fueled by a cooling flow." Using Chandra X-ray data, it is shown that a subset of BCGs do reside within coolcores, but their mass deposition rates cannot account for the SFR. For comparison, a field sample is drawn from the Max-Planck Institute for Astrophysics - John Hopkins University (MPA-JHU) "value-added" SDSS DR7 catalog of spectrum measurements. A set of 1,244 high-mass, elliptical field galaxies within the same redshift range as the W4BCG catalog are identified for comparison. The median mass for the field sample is lower than the W4BCGs (Log(M/M[dot in circle])=10.9 and 11.2 respectively), as are their SFRs. However, the specific star formation rate (sSFR), the star formation rate per stellar mass, is comparable for both groups (Log(sSFR)[approximately]-9.7). This possibly reveals that there is no environmental dependence on the sSFR for these W4-detected galaxies. While a possible mechanism responsible for the SFR was identified for the W4BCGs, the process responsible for the star formation in the field sample requires further investigation.




Galaxies at High Redshift


Book Description

This volume presents lectures of the XI Canary Islands Winter School of Astrophysics written by experts in the field.