The Impact of a Reading Intervention on Reading and Behavioral Outcomes for Fourth and Fifth Grade Students with Reading Difficulties


Book Description

Evidence supports a positive relationship between problem behaviors and reading difficulties across Grades K-12 yet there is a lack of research investigating the role of problem behavior in the context of reading interventions. In this study, data was analyzed from a site-specific subset of students from a multi-site randomized controlled trial (RCT) implementing a multi-component reading intervention for struggling readers in Grades 4 – 5. Data were analyzed to answer the following research questions: (1) What is the impact of multi-component reading intervention for 4th and 5th grade students who are struggling readers on both reading and problem behavior outcomes? and (2) Does problem behavior moderate the effect of a multi-component reading intervention for 4th and 5th grade students who are struggling readers? Students (n = 108) were randomly assigned to a one-year multi-component comprehension reading intervention or a school determined business as usual (BAU) comparison condition after meeting the criterion for identification as a struggling reader by scoring at or below a 90 standard score on the Test of Silent Reading Efficiency and Comprehension (Wagner, Torgesen, Rashotte, & Pearson, 2010) screener assessment. To answer the research questions, data (reading and behavior outcomes) were analyzed using an analysis of covariance to: 1) test the impact of the reading intervention on both reading and behavior outcomes; and 2) test for a significant interaction between measures of problem behavior and condition (i.e., treatment or comparison) on reading outcomes (e.g., Gates MacGinitie Reading Test; MacGainitie, 2000). Models controlled for student-level differences (e.g., reading pretest scores). Type I error associated with multiple comparisons was controlled for using the Benjamani-Hochberg correction to adjust for false discovery rates. Results suggested that the impact of treatment resulted in significant posttest group differences on word reading fluency (p




Evidence-Based Interventions for Students with Learning and Behavioral Challenges


Book Description

This book assembles into one volume summaries of school-based intervention research that relates to those who deal on a regular basis with the growing body of students having high-incidence learning disabilities and/or behavior disorders: special educators, school psychologists, and clinical child psychologists. Chapter authors begin with an overview of their topic followed by a brief section on historical perspectives before moving on to the main section – a critical discussion of empirically based intervention procedures. In those instances where evidence-based prescriptions can legitimately be made, authors discuss best practices and the conditions (e.g., classroom environment, teacher expertise) under which these practices are most effective. A final section deals with policy issues.







Handbook of Reading Interventions


Book Description

Comprehensive, authoritative, and designed for practical utility, this handbook presents evidence-based approaches for helping struggling readers and those at risk for literacy difficulties or delays. Leading experts explain how current research on all aspects of literacy translates into innovative classroom practices. Chapters include clear descriptions of effective interventions for word recognition, spelling, fluency, vocabulary, comprehension, and writing, complete with concrete examples and teaching scripts. Coverage also encompasses preschool literacy instruction and interventions for older readers, English language learners, and students with learning disabilities, as well as peer-mediated and tutoring approaches. An NCTQ Exemplary Text for Reading Instruction




Investigating a Reading Intervention for Fourth and Fifth Grade Students with Disabilities


Book Description

Being a successful reader is virtually synonymous with being a successful student (Slavin, Lake, Davis, and Madden, 2011). While there is a considerable amount of research available for lower elementary struggling readers, the same cannot be said for upper elementary struggling readers in third to fifth grade. When a student reaches third grade, there is a transition from "learning to read" to "reading to learn", and students are now expected to independently implement previously taught phonics strategies. However, struggling readers are so focused on simply decoding the text, they are unable to develop any meaningful understandings. This study set out to investigate the effectiveness of the phonics-based reading intervention S.P.I.R.E. for fourth and fifth-grade students with specific learning disabilities that have a comorbidity with reading difficulties. Results indicate that the phonics-based multisensory reading intervention is an effective reading intervention for upper elementary struggling readers.




Quick Reads


Book Description




Read 180


Book Description

READ 180 is a comprehensive reading intervention program designed to meet the needs of elementary to middle school students whose reading achievement is below the proficient level. The program directly addresses individual needs through differentiated instruction, adaptive and instructional software, high-interest literature, and direct instruction in reading, writing, and vocabulary skills. Stage A provides tools for young struggling readers in elementary school to develop critical literacy skills. Stage B provides middle school struggling readers with topics designed for their level of reading that hold their interest. System 44 was designed for the most challenged, older struggling readers, and helps these students understand that the English language is a finite system of 44 sounds and 26 letters that can be mastered. It uses validated assessment for screening and placement, research-based phonics instruction and highly motivating and age-appropriate adaptive technology.




The Effects of Expository Text Structure Instruction on the Reading Outcomes of 4th and 5th Graders Experiencing Reading Difficulties


Book Description

The purpose of this study was to assess the effects of a standard protocol supplemental expository text structure intervention (i.e., Structures) on 45 4th and 5th graders experiencing reading difficulties. Students were enrolled in six K-8 parochial schools located in a Midwestern suburban city. Within classrooms, students were randomly assigned to Structures intervention or a business-as-usual control condition. Students in the Structures condition were taught to identify and discriminate among the five text structures used by authors of expository text (Meyer, 1975, 1985): description, sequence, cause/effect, compare/contrast, and problem/solution. Students in the business-as-usual control condition participated in the same activities or instruction provided by their respective classroom teachers. At post-test, experimental students (n = 24) in the experimental condition significantly outperformed control students (n = 21) on a proximal (i.e., linked directly with the instructional focus of the intervention) researcher-created measure assessing the ability of students to identify text structures (d = 0.94). Experimental students did not significantly outperform controls on a distal (i.e., not linked directly with the instructional focus of the intervention) researcher-created measure assessing expository reading comprehension (d = 0.14) or on a delayed distal norm-referenced measure of expository reading comprehension (d = -0.11). The results, practical implications, and limitations are discussed.




Research in Education


Book Description




The Effects of an Orton-Gillingham-based Reading Intervention on Students with Emotional/behavior Disorders


Book Description

This study was performed with 4 male students enrolled in a specialized public school for students with emotional/behavior disorders (E/BD). All of the students participated in a 16-week, one-to-one, multisensory reading intervention. The study was a single subject, multiple baseline design. The independent variable was an Orton-Gillingham-based reading intervention for 45 minute sessions. The dependent variable was the students' performance on daily probes of words read correctly and the use of pre- and post-test measures on the Dynamic Indicator of Basic Early Literacy Skills (DIBELS). The intervention consisted of 6 different parts: (a) visual, (b) auditory, (c) blending, (d) introduction of a new skill, (e) oral reading, and (f) 10-point probe. Student behavior was monitored and scored throughout the lessons to compare the relationship between behavior and the number of words read correctly. The results of this study indicate a moderate positive effect on the decoding skills for 3 of the 4 students on raw scores. The greatest improvement in decoding skills was evident in the students' performance on the Nonsense Word Fluency (NWF) task as measured by DIBELS. The researcher was unable to detect a direct correlation between behavior and the number of words read correctly. Patterns suggest, however, that higher behavior scores tended to result in higher numbers of words read correctly. Students and teachers were given questionnaires to measure satisfaction with the intervention. Three of the 4 students who participated in the study reported that they enjoyed working with the researcher, and 3 of the 4 teachers reported an increase in decoding skills transferred across academic areas, although none of the teachers reported any change in the students' disruptive behaviors. The results of this study indicate that some students with E/BD and reading difficulties may benefit from the use of an Orton-Gillingham-based reading intervention. Finally, the researcher presents the limitations to the study. Suggestions for further research are also given.