The Impact of Career and Technical Education Programs on Postsecondary Readiness for Overage Black and Latino Students as Perceived by NYCDOE Career and Technical Education Leaders


Book Description

This qualitative study explored the perceptions of twelve New York City Department of Education leaders in Career and Technical Education (CTE) regarding programming, organizational structures and supports that impact college and career readiness of overage Black and Latino students. A grounded theory approach was used to define themes within the responses of CTE leaders that depict leadership practices to support the ability for overage students to graduate from high school and be able to complete a postsecondary college or skilled trade education. Findings concluded that CTE leaders perceived the greatest impact on postsecondary achievement for overage Black and Latino students to be curricula designed to ensure that students meet college readiness benchmarks before moving into CTE pathways, support structures and services that provide for the unique needs of overage high school students, and the use of human and capital resources in creative ways to provide for at-risk student support. A review of NYCDOE achievement data on CTE schools concluded that school leaders' perceptions of impact on achievement for Black and Latino students is reflected in four-year graduation rates for this population but are not necessarily reflected in college readiness index rates. Conclusions informed the researcher's recommendations for increasing the number of CTE schools with a narrow focus and enacting hiring practices and training for CTE leaders with the objective of improving the disproportionately low outcomes for Black and Latino high school student and reducing the number of Black and Latino students who become overage. Recommendations for further study specify a longitudinal study to determine the postsecondary career paths of Black and Latino students who graduate overage from NYCDOE CTE high schools as well as a study of the CTE interests of middle school students identified as at-risk in order to inform further improvements in CTE offerings.




The Impact of Career and Technical Education on the Achievement of at Risk Students


Book Description

One area of education that many school leaders utilize to assist students at risk of dropping out of school is Career and Technical Education (CTE). The hands-on learning and real-world connections that CTE offers are characteristics that are attractive to students who do not see the traditional values associated with a high school education. In contrast to these strengths, some educators doubt the ability of CTE programs to prepare students for college to the same degree as a traditional high school program. The purpose of this study was to determine the impact that CTE programs have on the achievement of at-risk students. Preliminary Scholastic Aptitude Test (PSAT) and Texas Assessment of Knowledge and Skills (TAKS) scores of at-risk high school students (n = 1,161) from a large, suburban school district in Texas were examined to determine if a student's level of involvement in a CTE program affected their achievement at both the minimum skill and college readiness levels. A logistical regression was performed to determine the extent to which at-risk students' level of CTE involvement was related to TAKS English Language Arts and Math scaled scores and to PSAT Critical Reading and Math scores. The results of this study indicated that the achievement levels of at-risk students on the measure of minimum skills were not statistically significantly different when analyzed by level of CTE involvement. The achievement levels of at-risk students on the measure of college readiness levels, however, were statistically significantly lower for students with lower levels of CTE involvement. As the level of CTE involvement increased, this difference disappeared. The results of this study should encourage school leaders to re-examine CTE programs and to determine ways in which to merge the best aspects from academic and CTE courses together to increase achievement for all students.




Equity-Based Career Development and Postsecondary Transitions


Book Description

Former First Lady, Michelle Obama believes that every individual should have some type of postsecondary education or training beyond high school to achieve economic and personal success (Reach Higher Initiative, Better Make Room, 2019). Educational attainment (e.g., a high school diploma, college degree, or postsecondary training) provides career opportunities for advancement into leadership positions and benefits such as health insurance and retirement (Heckman, 2000). Additionally, an individual with a college degree can make over one million dollars more over a lifetime in salary than someone with a high school diploma (Carnevale, Cheah, & Hanson, 2015). Acquiring a college degree can lead to employment opportunities and is considered an asset in the U.S. economy (Washington, 2010). However, certain populations encounter barriers to attaining an education, particularly a postsecondary education, leading to a disparity in receiving the aforementioned benefits. Some of these populations include African American students, LGBTQ students, and students with disabilities. There is a dearth of information and research on providing guidance on implementation, research, and best practices in equity-based career development, college readiness, and successful postsecondary transitions for minoritized, at risk, or vulnerable populations. The editors of this volume invited authors with research and practice expertise around various student populations in preparing them for college and career readiness as well as postsecondary transitions. This book is the first of its kind to discuss career development and postsecondary transitions from an access and equity perspective. Further, this text serves as a call to action to ensure the United States’ most vulnerable populations has an opportunity to successfully transition into multiple postsecondary options after high school.




The Positive Impact of Career and Technical Education on Student Success for Secondary and Post-secondary Life


Book Description

The purpose of this study is to increase awareness to all levels of education of the specific benefits to the students who have been enrolled in Career and Technical Education courses throughout their high school careers. The topic was selected because the students in the Shakopee Public school district have had the opportunity to benefit from Career and Technical Education and have been proven to be successful in secondary and post-secondary life (both in career and college readiness). Research led to summarizing what the key characteristics are that define a success high school student, college student, and as a career professional. Through this study, the goal was to collect data on how many students were being impacted by Career and Technical Education courses in a positive way at all three phases, and then utilize that data to improve future enrollment for all students at Shakopee High School.







Expanding Opportunities


Book Description




An Analysis of Demographic and Educational Characteristics of Career and Technical Education Program of Study Concentrators and Completers


Book Description

Federal legislation requires every student, upon completion of their secondary education, be considered college and career ready. Many states have developed and implemented career and technical education (CTE) programs of study (POS) to answer these mandates. Some stakeholders, familiar with historical vocational education programs, see current CTE coursework as a pipeline to the workforce, rather than a pathway leading to career as well as post-secondary opportunities. This non-experimental quantitative research study used data from a 5A public high school in Texas to determine the extent of the association between identified subpopulations of marginalized students (i.e., racial/ethnic minorities, at-risk, economically disadvantaged, and/or special populations) and whether or not students in Grades 9–12 had concentrated in or completed a program of study. This allowed the cooperating school to examine if observed counts were higher or lower than expected counts for each group, which helped determine if marginalized groups were over or under-represented in CTE coursework. The study also examined the extent to which 2022 graduates identified as CTE completers differed from non-completers when compared on the following dependent variables: aggregate grade point average, 4-year average attendance rate, and the level of performance attained on the Preliminary SAT (PSAT) total score, math section score, and evidence-based reading and writing section score. The association between students having earned concentrator or completer status and the following student subgroups were statistically significant: racial/ethnic minorities, at-risk, economically disadvantaged, and emergent bilingual. The association between students having earned concentrator or completer status and the following student subgroups were not statistically significant: Section 504 and special education. CTE completers had higher, but not statistically significantly higher four-year grade point averages and four-year average attendance rates than non-completers. CTE completers had lower, but not statistically significantly lower scores on the PSAT total score, math section score, and evidence-based reading and writing section score than non-completers. CTE programs have evolved over time yet are still often misunderstood and have a negative perception from stakeholders regarding the academic preparedness they provide students. Advocating for CTE on local, state, and national levels is critical to program existence. This study provided data for administrators to champion CTE and offset the misunderstandings and negative perceptions that exist.




Career and Technical Education's Impact on Student Career and Postsecondary Aspirations


Book Description

The purpose of the study was to show postsecondary aspirations or careers in the workforce for students in the career and technical education (CTE) areas of health science, agriculture, information technology, skilled and technical sciences, and consumer and family sciences.




Improving Post-secondary College and Career Awareness and Readiness at a Rural Career and Technical Center in Northern Virginia


Book Description

The purpose of this applied study was to solve the problem of a lack of post-secondary college and career awareness and readiness among students in a rural Career and Technical Education (CTE) center in Northern Virginia and to formulate a solution to address the problem. The central research question was “How can the problem of a lack of post-secondary college and career readiness (CCR) and awareness among students be solved at a rural CTE Center in Northern Virginia?” The researcher used a multimethod design consisting of both qualitative and quantitative approaches. The first approach was semi-structured interviews using open-ended questions with administrators. The second approach was a focus group consisting of business leaders. The third approach was a closed-ended survey with CTE students. The researcher used an inductive thematic analysis approach to analyze the interviews and six stages of analysis was used: orientation to the data, identification of themes, examining the themes, formulating and assignment of themes, and composing the results (Braun and Clarke, 2013). Five themes emerged from the coded interviews with administrators and four themes emerged from the interview of a focus group. A CTE student survey was conducted, data was analyzed to generate descriptive statistics of minimum, maximum, mean and standard deviation. Descriptive statistics aided in the development of a solution to the problem of a lack of CCR and awareness. Universal themes that emerged were students’ lack of soft skills, the need for students to be CCR when they graduate, the necessity for parents to be involved in CCR and awareness, a demand for increased partnerships between schools and businesses, and the need to integrate academics and CTE to provide application and context. These themes align with prior empirical research data.