MIDDLE SCHOOL TEACHERS PERCEPTIONS OF THE FACTORS THAT SUPPORT OR IMPEDE THE INCLUSION OF READING STRATEGIES INTO CLASSROOM INSTRUCTION.


Book Description

This interpretive case study took place in an urban middle school where content area math and science teachers engaged in content area reading instruction designed to promote students reading development in their content area classes. Participants included eight teachers across grade levels six, seven and eight. Teachers participated in a Background Information Questionnaire designed to obtain their perceptions, literacy beliefs and literacy practices; focus group interviews created to explore their perceptions related to the key themes in the literature regarding content area reading instruction; structured one-on-one interviews to corroborate researcher interpretations of the initial data analysis and to collect individual teacher data on key themes created in focus group interviews; and finally, member checking sessions designed to verify key findings. ArrayKey findings revealed that these teachers held content area reading instruction within their content area class and felt responsible for students literacy learning while also being responsible for teaching content area standards. Students abilities emerged as a major theme regarding perceived impacts on students efforts to comprehend content area texts and vocabulary. Factors that teachers perceived as most supportive in teaching content area reading included instructional factors (teacher motivation and student motivation) and infrastructural factors (support from the administrative team, collaboration with English Language Arts colleagues, district literacy support and buy-in from all staff). Teacher-perceived obstacles to providing effective reading instruction included instructional factors (lack of instructional differentiated resources, excessive testing and student ability) and infrastructural factors (lack of adequate time, lack of proper undergraduate training, inadequate district professional development and student ability). Implications for schools and districts, as well as possibilities for future research were discussed..







Education, A-E


Book Description




Gender Influences


Book Description

Donnalee Rubin examines the responses of thirty-one freshman composition teachers to student writing and shows the negative effects of gender bias on assessment to prove that gender perceptions and expectations can influence assessment decisions that seem neutral on the surface. Arguing that certain pedagogies are more likely to minimize gender bias than others, Rubin believes that teachers are more likely to overcome the influence of gender bias on their teaching if they adopt a process-based method and work intimately with their students through nondirective, supportive conferences. Rubin characterizes the conference/process-centered class as the type of environment in which maternal teaching can be cultivated. She stresses that maternal can describe any teacher, male or female, who exhibits the nurturing and supportive qualities that the conference/process approach embodies. With a primary focus on the student’s well-being and development as a person and a writer, the maternal teacher is in a better position to overcome gender bias that could distort the interpretation of student texts. In order for writing instructors to increase their sensitivity to gender issues in assessment, Rubin recommends that they self-consciously engage in what she calls "responsive reading." Responsive reading occurs when the teacher reads with an eye toward providing the sorts of supportive feedback and dialectic exchange that will encourage student writers to think for themselves and to revise effectively. Rubin argues that when teachers commit to a responsive-reading pedagogy, they are more likely to question their reactions to student writing along the lines of gender influence and to strive for self-conscious awareness of how their own inner male-female voices may distort their reading of student texts. She challenges all writing teachers to become more aware of the inevitable challenge gender influence presents.




A Case Study of Perceptions of Teachers Engaged in Teaching Reading to Adolescent Students in Middle School


Book Description

Reading is a foundational skill that contributes to success in school and life-long endeavors. Teaching students to read and ensuring they learn how to master the five components of the reading process is a primary task of those in the education system. However, there are many students who reach middle school who have not become proficient or advanced readers. Many students continue to struggle with reading, functioning only at a basic or below basic level. The impact of struggling to read can be catastrophic for students and can negatively affect their ability to learn. The focus of this study is a middle school that continually reported a high number of students in 6th, 7th, and 8th grades that struggled with reading. The purpose of the study was to evaluate the perceptions of teachers engaged in teaching reading to adolescent middle school students. Further, the study sought to gain ideas from the teachers regarding adolescent literacy and how to address the problem of middle school students who struggled with reading. This study utilized a qualitative case study methodology. Data were collected through two surveys that used closed and open-ended questions. Data were also gathered from the researcher's classroom observation, team meeting, and informal conversation notes. This study found that a discrepancy existed about the extent of the problem between teachers' perceptions of struggling readers and reported assessment scores. Findings from the study also suggested mixed perceptions regarding the setting and who is responsible for teaching reading among the middle school teachers. In the findings, elements that block students from learning to read or express their reading abilities were identified. The teachers identified numerous ways to assist students but were hesitant to adopt strategies to use in the classroom beyond the aligned curriculum instruction. The findings also revealed that teachers were very definite in listing training needs for teachers and what elements must be included in teaching adolescent literacy. A theme emerged of resistance for some teachers based on the demand to teach a separate reading class and individual perceptions about whose responsibility it is to teach reading. This study may have implications for teachers dealing with similar issues based on the problem of a high number of students that struggle with reading in the middle school setting.




Improving Reading Comprehension Skills of Middle School Learners Using the Secondary Explicit Comprehension Model of Instruction


Book Description

Background: Reading instruction begins at the primary level with reading comprehension issues manifesting themselves by the 3rd-grade and becoming more pronounced by fourth-grade. While primary teachers often teach narrative comprehension skills, middle school teachers have the responsibility to teach both narrative and expository comprehension skills. Purpose: The purpose of this study was to investigate the viability of the Secondary Explicit Comprehension Model of Instruction for middle school teachers to use with students. This study posed the following research questions: 1) What are the perceptions of middle school teachers on the use of the Secondary Explicit Comprehension Model of Instruction? and 2) What is the impact of the Secondary Explicit Comprehension Model of Instruction on the performance of students who repeated the State of Texas Assessments of Academic Readiness (STAAR) Grade 8 Reading Assessment? Methods: This study used a mixed methods approach to answer the research questions. The qualitative data included observation notes and teacher survey responses. The quantitative data included students’ pre-test and post-test scores on the STAAR Grade 8 Reading Assessment. Descriptive statistics were used to describe the impact of selected literacy strategies on the reading comprehension of middle school students. Constant comparative analysis was used to identify the emergent themes related to teacher perceptions about the use of the Secondary Explicit Comprehension Model of Instruction. Results: The results of this study identified three emergent themes: 1) implementation fidelity, 2) viability of the Secondary Explicit Comprehension Model of Instruction to other content areas, and 3) impact of the Secondary Explicit Comprehension Model of Instruction on students who repeated an administration of the STAAR Grade 8 Reading Assessment. Conclusion: Results suggested that the Secondary Explicit Comprehension Model of Instruction is a viable instructional framework that could be used in classroom settings to support middle school educators in effectively teaching reading comprehension skills.