Three Essays on Technical Efficiency of Smallholder Farmers


Book Description

In the first chapter of the dissertation, we estimate the impacts of controlling for environmental production conditions on smallholder farmers' technical efficiency in Ethiopia for maize, sorghum and wheat farming. We use a household panel dataset with annual and cropping season environmental production conditions data. Our results show that accounting for environmental production conditions in the stochastic frontier helps to determine the sources of inefficiencies which may otherwise be ignored or overestimated. The mean estimates of the technical efficiency scores differ when we control for environmental production conditions during the cropping season and annually. The second chapter of the dissertation examines the efficiency of smallholder farmers who adopt improved maize using agricultural household data from Ethiopia. We find that smallholder farmers are becoming more efficient in growing improved seeds than local varieties even though there are still some inefficiencies. The mean technical efficiency of improved maize farmers increases by 2.9%. For improved open pollinated varieties, it increases by 9.21%. We attribute the increase in efficiency to the changes in agricultural systems of most Sub-Saharan African countries. Therefore, given that the dissemination and adoption of improved seeds is increasing in Africa, efforts should be made to assist smallholder farmers to be more efficient in growing these seeds. The third chapter provides an insight into the efficiency of peanut farmers in Haiti. We use the stochastic production frontier to show how the agricultural training program impacts the efficiency of smallholder peanut farmers in Haiti. Specifically, we estimate the technical efficiency of farmers enrolled in the training program offered by a for profit organization and those who qualify to enroll but chose not to. Our results indicate that the program had positive effect on the efficiency of peanut farmers during the spring growing season. Farmers who enrolled in the spring season had efficiency scores of 36% more than those who chose not to enroll. Further, we find a large gap in efficiency scores between farmers who enrolled in the fall and spring growing seasons, suggesting that environmental variables should also be included in farm efficiency studies.




Technical efficiency of smallholder farms in Nigeria


Book Description

This dissertation is based on three essays with a focus on the technical efficiency of smallholder farms in Nigeria. The overall objective of the research is to contribute to the existing literature on the efficiency and productivity of Nigerian agriculture. The first essay examined the development and drivers of the average technical efficiency in Nigerian agriculture based on 64 efficiency studies covering 1999-2008. The second essay went on to further identify the trends in crop diversification while examining its impact on the technical efficiency of smallholder farms in Nigeria. Last but not least, the third essay investigated technical efficiency, inputs substitution and their complementary effects using an output distance function while focusing on cassava production in Nigeria. The second and third essays are based on unbalanced panel data of 846 observations covering three farming season (2006/07-2008/09) from southwestern Nigeria via the application of the stochastic frontier analysis. In summary, the research found that average technical efficiency significantly increased over time across the 64 frontier studies in the country. Besides, the study observed that technical progress characterized food crop production in the country while the mean technical efficiency reported from each of the essays that make up the dissertation showed that there is still room for improvement in Nigerian food crop production as each estimate falls below the frontier level. Furthermore, the research revealed that cropping pattern increased significantly with the intensification of diversification in food crop production in the country. In addition, the study identifies education, credit, extension contacts and crop diversification among others as key drivers of technical efficiency in Nigerian food crop production. In light of this, the research concludes that the latter observation underscores the importance of education, credit and extension contacts as variables of policy concern for the institutions of public and private policies design to reposition the Nigerian food crop production industry in order to meet the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) of food security.




Three Essays on the Role of Information in Farming Decisions and Outcomes


Book Description

This dissertation contributes to the literature on the role of information in farming decisions and performance by answering three related questions: (i) How does the use of market information contribute to agricultural productivity?; (ii) What factors explain the access to and/or the actual use of information in farming?; and (iii) What kind of specific information do farmers need when choosing the market in which to sell their crops? The first chapter provides an overview of the dissertation. In the second chapter, we use a three-step procedure to measure technical efficiency (TE) gains when farmers use information in their decision making. First, we use propensity score matching techniques to obtain comparable samples for information users and nonusers. Next, we apply the selectivity corrected stochastic production frontier model to examine TE for users and nonusers. Third, we implement two recently developed stochastic metafrontier approaches to compare TE between the two groups. Our results show that information users are more efficient than nonusers, regardless of gender, age, or education level. In the third chapter, we examine the factors that influence farmers' decisions to access information and to use information when choosing what crops to grow, considering them as two separate decisions. The difference is important because information will be beneficial only if farmers use it to make better choices. Employing a bivariate probit model, we find that general education has a higher marginal effect on the decision to obtain information, but its marginal effect is smaller on the decision to use information for selecting what crops to grow. On the other hand, neighbors' decisions have a significant marginal effect on farmers' decisions to use information. Finally, based on observed patterns of decisions made by small-scale farmers, the fourth chapter develops a theoretical model to examine the key determinants of market choice. The model shows that this choice depends not only on transportation costs but also on price differences per crop between markets and the crop share out of the total weight of the products the farmer plans to sell. Our findings may help in the design of extension services that provide price information.







Farming Systems and Poverty


Book Description

A joint FAO and World Bank study which shows how the farming systems approach can be used to identify priorities for the reduction of hunger and poverty in the main farming systems of the six major developing regions of the world.




Three Essays on Economics of Water Resources Management in Nepal


Book Description

First essay consists of two steps. First, Technical Efficiency (TE) index is estimated for upriver and downriver ecoregions employing DEA technique. In the second stage, we censored the TE index and run the Tobit regression model to assess the socio-economic factors responsible for explaining technical efficiency of smallholder farming practices. The median technical efficiency values were 0.606 and 0.756 in upriver and downriver respectively. Tobit model indicates lower productivity of small scale farming units are due to inadequate water availability, lack of reliable inputs and poor market services. Access to farm credit and electricity are significant and positive factors explaining technical efficiency in both regions. The second essay examines the on-going consequences of climate change on water resources availability and how adaptation practices and strategies have developed in agricultural practices. Results indicate increasing temperatures, prolonged drought followed by intense precipitation, and greater frequency of flooding than in the past. About two-thirds of small creeks and springs have disappeared and others will soon disappear if current trends continue. Respondents prefer collective water management. Logistic regression analysis shows that farm income, market access, access to extension services, and market distance are significant predictors of adaptive behavior. Essay-3 deals the conveyance, economic and agronomic efficiency of water used, and factors affecting aggregate water use efficiency in the study regions. Farmers in the Mountain region were found relatively more effective at reducing water loss than farmers in the Hill and Terai regions. Water use efficiency scores regressed on farm related socio-economic variables shows that farm size, distance to water source, government agricultural extension services and access to credit positively affect water use efficiency in all regions.













Three Essays on Evaluation and Measurement in Developing Countries


Book Description

The overall theme of this dissertation is on evaluation and measurement in developing countries. All three essays make a contribution to the literature---either with the use of a new empirical method for evaluation or a unique or new data set, or the evaluation of a tool or program not yet evaluated, or by evaluating an aspect within the evaluation literature usually neglected. The results of the three essays have policy relevance and can be used to design or modify anti-poverty programs geared towards the social and productive sectors so that they can have a greater impact on poverty.