Unsteady Behavior of Three-Dimensional Vortices Relevant to Turbulent Boundary Layers


Book Description

The recent accomplishments are reviewed for a research program employing combined analytical-experiments techniques to study the three dimensional characteristics and behavior of vortex motions associated with the turbulence production process in turbulent boundary layers. Progress is described in the development of a new image processing technique which allows the derivation of quantitative data from flow visualization images. The method is used to search for the role of hairpin vortices in the turbulence production process. In the analytical portion of the study, calculations have been carried out to compute the evolution of a hairpin vortex in a shear flow; the interaction of a pair of hairpins has been examined as well as the viscous response at a wall due to the motion of a hairpin vortex. Comparison of these computer simulations with the experimental studies is very encouraging. Computations for the evolving flow between wall layer streaks during a typical cycle in the wall layer of a turbulent boundary layer have also been carried out; these studies show two possible routes to breakdown of the wall layer flow leading to the production process. Keywords: Turbulent boundary layers; Hairpin vortices; Vortex motion.



















Three-dimensional Effects on Unsteady Dynamics and Turbulent Transport Mechanisms of an Impinging Shock Wave/boundary-layer Interaction


Book Description

Shock wave/boundary-layer interactions (SBLIs) are ubiquitous to both the external vehicle body and internal propulsion flowpath. The external surfaces include for example the nose, wings, and tail, while internal surfaces include bounding walls of mixed compression inlets, diffusers, and isolators. To obtain predictions of these flowfields, Reynolds-averaged Navier-Stokes (RANS) computational fluid dynamics (CFD) solvers are preferred over computationally expensive scale-resolving methods like large-eddy simulation (LES), hybrid RANS/LES, and direct numerical simulation (DNS). However, RANS predictions are highly dependent on the choice of turbulence model. Reasons include the fundamental assumption (Boussinesq eddy-viscosity approximation) made in the development of turbulence models and the estimation of the terms that govern turbulence transport. In this work, key mechanisms in the exact Reynolds stress transport equation are examined with a view towards identifying important flow phenomena and improving prediction of flows with SBLIs. Upon linking the unsteady dynamics back to the Reynolds stress transport, significant mechanisms can be isolated, whose relative importance varies across the SBLI region. By discovering the importance of these mechanisms to SBLIs, current models can be improved and mechanisms generally assumed negligible due to the lack of experimental or high-fidelity data can be modeled. With this purpose in mind, wall-resolved LES (WRLES) of SBLI are considered at several Reynolds numbers. The flow conditions and geometry are based on the experiments performed at the Institut Universitaire des Systemes Thermiques Industriel (IUSTI) in Marseille, France at Mach 2.29 for an 8 degree deflection angle shock wave impinging on a turbulent boundary layer developing on the opposite surface. Due to a closely coupled relationship between the corner flow and centerline separation in small- to medium-aspect-ratio configurations, the full tunnel span that includes the two sidewalls and produce a three-dimensional SBLI is studied. Verification of the numerical strategy is achieved by investigating the dependence of the results on mesh resolution, choice of domain size, numerical dissipation of the WRLES framework, and the digital filter inflow generation method. This is followed by detailed validation against the particle image velocimetry data from the experiment to assess the accuracy of the simulations. A comparison between the periodic and full-span simulations confirms that the corner physics is integral to the prediction of the centerline separation. The compression waves, visualized by plotting isosurface of the pressure gradient magnitude, are shown to emanate from the blockage created by the corner separation and are responsible for the amplification of the centerline separation. Furthermore, the phenomenology within the interaction region is invariably linked to the perturbation of the incoming turbulent boundary layer by the reflected-shock foot. It leads to the formation of a band in which the turbulence statistics become prominent and consistent with the development of the shear layer and Kelvin-Helmholtz shedding. The interaction between the corner separation and secondary flow of the second kind, i.e., a pair of counter-rotating vortices symmetric about the corner bisector, significantly diminishes the size of the vortex pair. However, as the corner separation becomes sidewall biased, the clockwise-rotating vortex grows, while the counter clockwise-rotating vortex remains anchored near the corner origin. Unsteady dynamics at the centerline and corner locations are evaluated by computing the weighted power spectral densities (PSDs) of pressure and velocity fluctuations. By placing the probes at key locations, unsteadiness effects related to the reflected-shock foot (low frequency, St ≈ 0.015), shear-layer development (intermediate frequency, St ≈ 0.1), and Kelvin-Helmholtz shedding (high frequency, St ≈ 0.5) are identified. The streamwise and spanwise recirculation dynamics of the centerline separation bubble are explored by employing low-pass filtered PSDs of u′ and w′, where broadband energetic scales in the intermediate-frequency range are found. The same intermediate-frequency scales are also present in the PSDs of the probes located within the corner separation. The corner-centerline two-point correlations illustrate the dynamical coupling of the corner regions with the reflected-shock foot that persists for multiple forward and aft shock oscillation cycles. The corner-corner two-point correlations reveal that the opposing corners are either positively correlated, uncorrelated, or negatively correlated and the period of this behavior cycle is significantly longer than the reflected-shock foot unsteadiness. A rigorous analysis of the Reynolds stress transport budget is performed to evaluate the significance of production, diffusion, transport, redistribution, and dissipation mechanisms in regions of SBLI. The budget sum, computed to serve as a measure of error in the budget, is also a good indicator of non-equilibrium in the flowfield caused by the unsteadiness. The pressure-diffusion mechanism is found to be important at the reflected-shock foot location and in its downstream vicinity. Notably, the analysis of turbulent-diffusion and pressure-strain mechanisms corroborates their key roles in balancing production within the shear-layer development and Kelvin-Helmholtz shedding regions. The molecular diffusion contributes in balancing dissipation near the wall, but is inconsequential in the unsteady regions. Upon considering the behavior of three diffusion mechanisms, the evidence indicates that separate modeling of these mechanisms would be beneficial in RANS simulations of SBLIs. Although the turbulent mass flux mechanism was hypothesized to be significant for the entrainment and ejection of mass from the separation bubble, it is in fact negligible and not a modeling concern. Finally, the spanwise variation in budgets due to the flow three-dimensionality is studied by comparing the centerline, quarter-span, and corner bisector positions. The leading mechanisms in the corner region are convection, production, turbulent diffusion, and pressure strain, while the behavior of quarter-span budgets is dependent upon the streamwise location. Ultimately, these results lay the foundation for a more systematic procedure to close the RANS equations in the presence of three-dimensionality, pressure gradients, and other sources of mechanical non-equilibrium.




Experimental Study of the Effect of Streamwise Vortices on Unsteady Turbulent Boundary-layer Separation


Book Description

This experiment studied the effect of streamwise vortices on unsteady turbulent boundary-layer separation. The objectives were to document the flow field, to characterize the time response of the boundary layer, and to understand the actual mechanisms by which the streamwise vortices modify boundary-layer behavior. A new configuration for non-obtrusive three-component Laser Doppler Anemometry (LDA) determined the phase averaged velocity and Reynolds stress components, in an unsteady water tunnel, at a momentum thickness Reynolds number of 1840. The streamwise vortices were created by three pairs of half-delta wing vortex generators, while the boundary-layer separation was controlled through impulsively initiated opposite-wall suction, which created a strong adverse pressure gradient. The time response of the freestream velocity demonstrates that convection is the primary mechanism by which vortex generators modify the response of the boundary layer. There is an initial fast response throughout the boundary layer which is unaffected by the presence of vortex generators, followed by a slow or convective response, the magnitude of which is substantially modified by the presence of the vortex generators. Flow control, Unsteady turbulent layers. Aircraft, Vortex generators. (jes).







Three-Dimensional Vortex Interactions in Turbulent Boundary Layers


Book Description

A combined analytical experimental program, which has as its continuing objective the detailed investigation of the three dimensional vortex interactions which take place in turbulent boundary layers, is described and the accomplishments detailed. The analytical and numerical studies have examined both the development and characteristics of loop and hairpin vortices in both uniform and shear flows; particular attention has been paid to the strong three dimensional, inviscid viscous interaction of these types of vortical flow structures with wall region fluid. The experimental studies have focussed on the creation & detailed examination of three dimensional hairpin vortices, developing flow visualization patterns for cross-comparison with both the analytical studies and fully turbulent boundary layer flows. A technique for developing quantitative data by image processing of the visualization patterns is also described. Keywords: Turbulent boundary layer; Coherent structure; Flow visualization; Numerical modelling; Vortex wall interactions; Computer aided analysis; Loop vortices; Hairpin vortices.