What is the Impact of a Major Unconventional Monetary Policy Intervention?


Book Description

WWe analyse how unconventional monetary policy affects bank lending standards during crises. We use a major central bank intervention that boosted the capital of banks, “whatever it takes” speech of the European Central Bank President, as a natural experiment. We compare changes in lending standards of euro area versus other banks in a third country, Mexico. The intervention reversed prior risk-taking--in volume, price, and risk ratings--of subsidiaries of euro area banks. Our findings show that large and credible unconventional monetary policies can reduce risk-taking domestically and abroad during crises, at least temporarily, adding a new dimension to the bank capital channel.




Unconventional Monetary Policies in Emerging Markets and Frontier Countries


Book Description

The COVID-19 crisis induced an unprecedented launch of unconventional monetary policy through asset purchase programs (APPs) by emerging market and developing economies. This paper presents a new dataset of APP announcements and implementation from March until August 2020 for 27 emerging markets and 8 small advanced economies. APPs’ effects on bond yields, exchange rates, equities, and debt spreads are estimated using different methodologies. The results confirm that APPs were successful in significantly reducing bond yields in EMDEs, and these effects were stronger than those of policy rate cuts, suggesting that such UMP could be important tools for EMDEs during financial market stress.




Essays on Unconventional Monetary Policy


Book Description

Following the Global Financial Crisis of 2007 { 2010, central banks around the world were forced into unprecedented policy interventions to stabilise asset markets and prevent the global nancial system from collapsing. Because interest rates around the world were at historical lows, \conventional" interest rate policy was not an option. Central banks, led by the US Federal Reserve, resorted to \unconventional" monetary policies, rst to stabilise markets during the height of the crisis, and then to support the economic recovery thereafter. The distinguishing characteristic of these unconventional policies was that they involved direct intervention by central banks in long-term xed income markets, such as government bonds and agency debt. This thesis considers the theoretical channels through which central bank purchases of long-term securities could impact (i) bond yields, (ii) other domestic asset markets, and (iii) spillovers to foreign countries. The theory is then tested and evaluated against the empirical evidence. Based on the empirical results, a simple closed-economy DSGE model is constructed. The model captures and illustrates the transmission from central bank asset purchase shocks to the aggregate economy. The asset purchase shock is subsequently converted to an endogenous balance sheet rule. Simulations show that combining this unconventional (balance sheet) rule with a conventional (short-term interest rate) rule yields a superior policy mix than under the conventional rule alone. Finally, the closed-economy model is extended to an open-economy framework, within which a similar balance sheet rule is evaluated in the context of international capital ows. Again, the combination of the balance sheet and interest rate policy is found to yield a superior outcome than interest rate policy alone. The contribution of this thesis is twofold. It contributes to the understanding of the impact of central bank interventions in xed income markets on long-term yields, as well as the externalities and spillovers to other asset markets. Furthermore, this thesis develops a robust and versatile framework, which is intuitively easy to grasp, within which various aspects of central bank balance sheet policy could be investigated. This thesis' main conclusion is that unconventional monetary policy could complement conventional policy under normal market conditions, and that unconventional policy need not be restricted to crisis times only.




Unconventional Monetary Policies


Book Description

Unconventional monetary policies are relatively recent phenomenon and there are vivid debates on theoretical and empirical level aiming to establish which policies and under what conditions are desirable. This thesis makes a contribution to this debate and its objective is twofold. First, we bring new evidence on the effectiveness of unconventional measures and contribute to their better understanding. Furthermore, we build a theoretical framework that accounts for a disaster probability perceived by investors, a particular feature that prepares the background for unconventional monetary policy intervention. This thesis emphasizes the diversity of unconventional monetary policy strategies and the importance of country-specific characteristics for their design and effectiveness. We conclude that direct asset purchases have important effect on long-term interest rates reduction, especially in the presence of high country default risk. The government bond purchases seem to have an impact on inflation expectations as long as the monetary base is perceived to be permanent. We also find that liquidity provisions had only small impact on interbank market strains. We conclude that the central banks took the role of interbank intermediation making interbank market less relevant for the bank refinancing. Finally, we built a New Keynesian model that accounts for agents' perception of higher disaster risk which leads to self-fulfilling recession. This is a privileged framework to evaluate efficacy of unconventional monetary policies.




Negative Monetary Policy Rates and Portfolio Rebalancing: Evidence from Credit Register Data


Book Description

We study negative interest rate policy (NIRP) exploiting ECB's NIRP introduction and administrative data from Italy, severely hit by the Eurozone crisis. NIRP has expansionary effects on credit supply-- -and hence the real economy---through a portfolio rebalancing channel. NIRP affects banks with higher ex-ante net short-term interbank positions or, more broadly, more liquid balance-sheets, not with higher retail deposits. NIRP-affected banks rebalance their portfolios from liquid assets to credit—especially to riskier and smaller firms—and cut loan rates, inducing sizable real effects. By shifting the entire yield curve downwards, NIRP differs from rate cuts just above the ZLB.




Whatever it Takes


Book Description

We assess how a major, unconventional central bank intervention, Draghi's "whatever it takes" speech, affected lending conditions. Similar to other large interventions, it responded to adverse financial and macroeconomic developments that also influenced the supply and demand for credit. We avoid such endogeneity concerns by focusing on a third country and comparing lending conditions by euro area and other banks to the same borrower. We show that the intervention reversed prior risk-taking - in volume, price, and loan credit ratings - by subsidiaries of euro area banks relative to local and other foreign banks. Our results document a new effect of large central banks' interventions and are robust along many dimensions.




Financial Crisis, US Unconventional Monetary Policy and International Spillovers


Book Description

We study the impact of the US quantitative easing (QE) on both the emerging and advanced economies, estimating a global vector error-correction model (GVECM) and conducting counterfactual analyses. We focus on the effects of reductions in the US term and corporate spreads. First, US QE measures reducing the US corporate spread appear to be more important than lowering the US term spread. Second, US QE measures might have prevented episodes of prolonged recession and deflation in the advanced economies. Third, the estimated effects on the emerging economies have been diverse but often larger than those recorded in the US and other advanced economies. The heterogeneous effects from US QE measures indicate unevenly distributed benefits and costs.




The Effectiveness of Unconventional Monetary Policy at the Zero Lower Bound


Book Description

This paper assesses the macroeconomic effects of unconventional monetary policies by estimating a panel VAR with monthly data from eight advanced economies over a sample spanning the period since the onset of the global finanancial crisis. It finds that an exogenous increase in central bank balance sheets at the zero lower bound leads to a temporary rise in economic activity and consumer prices. The estimated output effects turn out to be qualitatively similar to the ones found in the literature on the effects of conventional monetary policy, while the impact on the price level is weaker and less persistent. Individual country results suggest that there are no major differences in the macroeconomic effects of unconventional monetary policies across countries, despite the heterogeneity of the measures that were taken.




The Impact of Unconventional Monetary Policy on Financial Markets, Credit Markets and Financial Stability


Book Description

In response to the 2008 financial crisis, the Federal Reserve initially responded using the federal funds rate. However, by December 2008 it had reached the zero lower bound (ZLB). With economic conditions still deteriorating the Federal Reserve used unconventional monetary policy actions in the form of Large-Scale Asset Purchases (LSAPs) to lower a range of long-term interest rates. The intention was to stimulate economic activity and promote recovery. The purpose of this dissertation is to analyze the effects of LSAPs from three perspectives. In the first chapter we find that LSAPs had a positive effect on the stock prices of some financial sectors. However, the effects were not as statistically significant for nonfinancial sectors. In the second chapter, we find that LSAPs helped the consumer and mortgage credit markets but not business credit. Overall the effects were weak. In the third chapter, we document the change in the Federal Reserve and banks' balance sheets as a result of LSAPs. It is clear that most of the liquidity injections remained as excess reserves, though we show an upper bound on how much of these injections went into new loans and deposits relative to cash or excess reserves. We discuss alternative ways that LSAPs could have mattered, such as through rebuilding bank balance sheets. Even though the liquidity injections may not be able to stimulate economic recovery they may help rebuilt and strengthen financial institutions. Restoring financial stability is beneficial to avoid a complete collapse of systemically important financial institutions.




Negative Interest Rate Policy (NIRP)


Book Description

More than two years ago the European Central Bank (ECB) adopted a negative interest rate policy (NIRP) to achieve its price stability objective. Negative interest rates have so far supported easier financial conditions and contributed to a modest expansion in credit, demonstrating that the zero lower bound is less binding than previously thought. However, interest rate cuts also weigh on bank profitability. Substantial rate cuts may at some point outweigh the benefits from higher asset values and stronger aggregate demand. Further monetary accommodation may need to rely more on credit easing and an expansion of the ECB’s balance sheet rather than substantial additional reductions in the policy rate.